4 ms·
Complaining about farmers using too much water is the same as complaining about people eating too much food. The word "food" doesn't even occur in this article
by nitrogen 12y ago
Complaining about farmers using too much water is the same as complaining about people eating too much food. The word "food" doesn't even occur in this article that appears to have started with a conclusion ("markets are magic!!!") and omitted facts until the conclusion was justified.
The disruption to our nation's economy and lower classes caused by an increase in food prices or scarcity as a result of hasty water management changes would potentially destabilize society.
Edit: the article also failed to mention that the water delivered to farmers has most likely not been purified, chlorinated, or protected from animals, so of course it will be cheaper than culinary water.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- stickfigure 12y agoGiven how inexpensive it is to ship food (see: any out-of-season vegetable), expensive water in dry regions like CA seems unlikely to have a significant impact on overall food prices. It might disrupt the local economies of certain farming regions, though this would arguably be a good thing for the economy as a whole.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Given how inexpensive it is to ship food (see: any out-of-season vegetable), expensive water in dry regions like CA seems unlikely to have a significant impact on overall food prices. Sure, shipping food may be cheap, but you can't ship food that isn't being grown, and there's not an extra unused lot the size of California's agricultural land lying around waiting to take up the slack that differs only in the cost of shipping to the end consumer. Lost production in California is lost supply, and will effect prices.
- gnopgnip 12y agoThe price of many foods would not be affected by an increase in the cost of water. This is referred to as pricing goods at what the market will bear. Additionally if the end goal is to provide affordable food, there are more direct means to this end.
- guard-of-terra 12y agoOptimising the 20% of water spent on humans seems suboptimal. Not much gains to have there, just stress. All the billboards who make you think it's you who spent all the water. It's the same thing where people are advised to conserve electricity yet we see large offices glowing with every light all night and day.
- hueving 12y agoI think you're confused. Most offices shut off the lights at night.
- pjc50 12y agoDifferent foods have very different levels of water use. Growing rice in dry California while imposing increasing restrictions on residential water use is not sustainable.
- dllthomas 12y ago"Complaining about farmers using too much water is the same as complaining about people eating too much food." That's not true. Changes in practices and capital investment can change water use for the same crops grown. Also, some crops use quite a bit more water than other crops. There is a relationship between levels of water use on farms and levels of food consumption, but they are not "the same thing".