4 ms·
If someone is smart enough to play chess at the highest levels, wouldn't he/she be better off as a mathematician?
by amichail 17y ago
If someone is smart enough to play chess at the highest levels, wouldn't he/she be better off as a mathematician?
- jefffoster 17y agoIs there any evidence that there is a strong correlation between playing chess at a high level and being a great mathematician?
- pixcavator 17y agoIn my experience mathematicians become quite good at chess - if they take it seriously. That's why I gave up playing long time ago.
- mquander 17y agoIn my experience, anyone of average intelligence becomes quite good at chess, if they take it seriously.
- varjag 17y agoIf you are a great chess player you wouldn't have time to become a decent mathematician.
- tomjen2 17y agoNot really, a mathematician would likely make less money than a toplevel chess player.
- pg 17y agoBut the falloff is sharp. A friend of mine was once ranked 44th in the world, and he switched to programming because he couldn't make a living playing chess.
- mquander 17y agoFat chance. There's only perhaps a few dozen people in the world who can actually even make a living playing chess (as opposed to teaching it on the side.) It's notoriously difficult. Many American chess players switch to poker or a different profession.
- aquateen 17y agoEven then, I remember seeing ads for lessons by Gata Kamsky in the back of Chess Life about 8 years ago.
- slackenerny 17y agoAccording to James Simons, "The average annual income of leading research mathematicians (those, say, with at least three articles in the Annals of Mathematics) is about 10,000,000 USD" ;]
- osipov 17y agothat's because Simons defines "leading" mathematicians as ones working for RenTech
- nearestneighbor 17y agoI'm skeptical of that. There is one web site (besides the above comment) that has this quote. It links to the Wikipedia article about James Simons as its source. The Wikipedia article does not seem to mention the quote. Even if James Simons did say that, I'd like to see his source. Edit: it just occurred to me that, since we are talking about "average" and not "median", this may as well be true, if a handful of mathematicians make a gazillion dollars a year. Very senior faculty members in the top research universities in the US are likely to make only $200-500k per year.
- mquander 17y ago"Only," but that's ten times what a professional chessplayer outside of the top 10 in the world makes.
- startingup 17y agoSimons is worth several billions ($10 billion perhaps?) and the number of mathematicians with at least 3 articles in the Annals of Mathematics cannot be huge (1000 perhaps?). I am pretty sure that was what Simons was getting at. Seeing your smiley, I assume you knew that too!
- ig1 17y agoNot really. Only a handful of top-level chess players are in the multi-million dollar range, while there are thousands of mathematicians in that range (the majority from the financial industry).
- osipov 17y agobeing "smart enough" in chess translates to being "smart enough" in purely mechanical aspects of mathematics. imho, you are underestimating the creative aspect of mathematics.
- nvoorhies 17y agoIs there no similar translation between the creative aspects of chess and mathematics?
- pixcavator 17y agoKarpov spent a year (I think) studying math as a freshman... "He couldn't make it" as the story goes.