4 ms·
I really like this idea ... but: Give use access to your facebook and $20 a month. In return, you get ONE match a month. If they don't want to meet you, that's
by shkkmo 12y ago
I really like this idea ... but:
Give use access to your facebook and $20 a month. In return, you get ONE match a month. If they don't want to meet you, that's too bad. You paid $20 to be rejected.
The two things you would need to do to sell me are:
1) Allow access without facebook. I'd be fine scanning a driver's license for you that matches the name on the credit card I pay with.
2) If you don't provide a good match (i.e.) one that wants to meet me, you should provide another match.
- Meekro 12y agoThose objections sound reasonable, but why do you think that you only get one match per month? I don't see that text on the front page -- do they tell you later?
- shkkmo 12y agoI read their FAQ: 1 match per month at $20 https://datingring.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/202344714-How-much-does-it-cost-to-become-a-member- https://datingring.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/202344714-H... Policy on matches that don't want to meet: https://datingring.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/203302640-What-happens-if-none-of-my-matches-want-to-meet- https://datingring.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/203302640-W...
- laurenkay 12y agoThanks for this feedback - very helpful. 1) It's now on our list to add signin without Facebook, since that's been such a popular request. 2) The problem there is that if you don't like your second match, then what? What's hard is that matchmaking isn't a common thing you pay for, so people aren't used to the risks involved. If you go to a restaurant, you generally don't ask to try out a meal for free, or ask for a second one if you don't like the first. If we were to provide two choices, we'd have to raise the price. We're the one matchmaking service where a personal matchmaker is going to send you a match for $20 .. most charge thousands. Additionally, it's not so much about the business model as it is about trying to change the way people so quickly write one another off. If you know you only get one shot, and this person has been chosen specifically for you by a matchmaker, there's a much higher chance you'll give them a shot, which is what we want. People are far too picky and miss out on lots of great people. If you want 1,000 chances, there's always Tinder :) And lastly, we're going to build a free match into the signup flow, so there's at least that :)
- throwaway_abc 12y ago> 2) The problem there is that if you don't like your second match, then what? It should be your choice. If you choose not to go on a date, thats on you, the dating ring's work has been done. If, however, you accept the date and they dont, there is nothing you could have done and should be set up with someone else. From the dating ring's perspective, that should be fine too because work was done for value (i.e. the party that declined the date got their value). This also goes well with your second statement.
- EarthLaunch 12y agoI'm not the person you replied to, but you've definitely thought this through, and thanks for explaining. I would sign up after reading that explanation. I think you'll need to find a way to express these things during conversion. I have a single friend who I'd recommend this to, except I'm sure she wouldn't want to spend $20 on a potential flop. You'd have to really change the perception of the value of your matches (vs dating sites). Of course, how much is a guaranteed good match worth? To me? $500+ easily. I think your biggest hurdle will be managing expectations. Good luck :)
- jedberg 12y ago> f you go to a restaurant, you generally don't ask to try out a meal for free, or ask for a second one if you don't like the first I most certainly do. I usually don't have to ask. When they come out and ask how the food was, I tell them the taste wasn't to my liking or wasn't what I expected, and they usually offer to comp the meal or bring a new one. I'm not saying I expect you guys to do this, I'm just saying you should probably find a new analogy. :) Although I think what OP is saying is that if you provide a match and the other person rejects it, you should provide another match, since obviously you didn't make a good choice. In other words, you should be guaranteeing one date per month, not one match. Not a successful date, but just a date.
- laurenkay 12y agoThanks for the replies, all. Re: restaurants - maybe not the best analogy. But just like a restaurant, we don't openly advertise it, but when people complain, we're always more than generous with credits / refunds. I'm working on a blog post to explain this better, as it's much more complicated than I could gracefully express in a HN comment, but just because someone is rejected doesn't mean we didn't do our job well. Dating is a numbers game, and success is no where near 50% for any dating site. What we do - unlike most other services - is work behind the scenes to improve success rates for future matches, if we see that certain people are being rejected often. For some people, though, the $20 model simply won't work if they find they're not getting enough dates. That's why we also offer Premium, which is a more personalized, tailored approach for a higher price point. Some people simply don't do well with photos, or for other reasons, and at $20, no matter how good we are at matching, it's simply not the perfect fit for everyone. And lastly - this is our first week with this model, so we are taking all of these comments very seriously, and thinking a lot about how to make a sustainable business model that satisfies the most people. When it comes to dating .. you're unfortunately never going to make everyone happy, but we're trying really hard to make as many people happy as possible. What's interesting is that we've heard almost no complaints about the $60/month model, only about the $20/month one. So we're debating how to make that plan more enticing, or if such a low price point works for the amount of personalization that goes into our service.
- laurenkay 12y ago@rogerbinns - The problem with being paid on success is that people are really bad at understanding the value behind 'success' and also, it's very hard to verify. Working backwards, it's easy to convince someone that finding their life partner is worth $1 million, and a 1% chance of that therefore is 10k. But most people still think $20 is too much to spend at just a chance. If they were to pay on success, no matter how good we were, we'd be losing a lot of money. Some startups are fine doing that, but we wanted to create a sustainable business model from the start. Also, I've heard the 'if you're good, you lose customers' comment a lot, but that is not the case with dating. People who are successful still go on a lot of dates, and the better you are, the more people they refer. Our goal is 100% to provide the best matches possible, so that people like us, refer their friends, and end up happy / in love / dating / having sex / doing what they want. If we had a crappy service that kept 'dangling' people in front of one another, a) none of us would want to work here and b) we'd have very high churn and die very quickly.
- Fuzzwah 12y agoI realize you're hectically trying to respond to a heap of comments here, but you really need to ensure you're clicking reply to the actual comment you're replying to.
- icambron 12y agoI think the key on the rejection thing is to remember that the other person is also on the hook for $20, and won't get another match if they reject you. So if the service is even basically working from a matching perspective [1], you should get a date. Rejecting you is basically saying, "this person is so bad that I'd rather give up my $20 than trust them that this might be a match". I also think it's interesting that you focussed on the possibility of you being rejected as opposed to you rejecting the match. [1] A big if. I'm skeptical about the whole thing, specifically about the "we match people, not profiles" claim, which makes little sense to me, since your profile is all they know about you. But my point is that the economics of it seem OK.
- laurenkay 12y agoAh, correct. I meant to say also that we used to send people on dates for $20, and the few times people had bad times, they said they would have rather paid $20 not to go. So it's better to spend $20 and not waste time, than it is to spend $20 and go on a date that you know instantly isn't a good fit. [1] We should explain this better, but when you sign up, you'll see you can tell your matchmaker a lot more about yourself, and we use feedback from each match / date to improve matches. Plus, of course, we're using all of the research we've collected on what makes people compatible. So it's definitely off of more than just a profile, but I get what you're saying.
- genericuser 12y agoHonest question, if you think someone is unmatchable based on their expectations not matching up with what they offer. Will you let them know and refuse their business, or will you just throw other unmatchable people at them and keep taking their money. (basically will a reject pool exist where you don't really put in any effort, but just slap together the left overs) As someone who's only matches on Tinder and OKCupid in the past few months have been camsites and escorts this is an actual concern of mine.
- laurenkay 12y ago@genericuser A big value add to what we do is that we will offer advice to people who keep getting rejected. If it's that their expectations are too high, we have it on our list to guide some people toward Premium. Not so we can make more money from them (our margins on Premium are lower) but because some people need coaching more than they need matches.
- jeffreyrogers 12y agoI'm glad they're charging money at least. It's nice to see a startup focus on revenues for a change.
- euphemize 12y agoMuch agreed with your points. In addition, this part: "Your profile also gives our matchmakers a glimpse into what you’re like as a real person, but don’t worry - we don’t base too much of our matching on your photos that your friend took that one time at that party after a few glasses of red wine :)" ...really terrifies me. I need to trust that the people doing this selection understand the context of my pictures while not knowing me at all? If I'm serious about finding a match using this service, I will gladly spend a full hours filling out a form telling you more about myself, rather than giving you access to my FB account.
- laurenkay 12y agoWe do also have you fill out a profile, and you're able to share any info you want with your matchmaker. You can also update them after each match. If you really want to spend hours and do a more in depth search, that's what Premium is for.