4 ms·
Well, it's not too hard to imagine a situation when the computer loses control over the breaks, engine and the transmission - so it quickly realizes that in its
by gambiting 12y ago
Well, it's not too hard to imagine a situation when the computer loses control over the breaks, engine and the transmission - so it quickly realizes that in its own state it cannot bring the car to a halt. In that instance an automatic car would do what that airplane did - assume that it's own instruments are unreliable(after all, maybe the breaks work when you push the pedal, it's just a sensor that's broken), and give the control back to the driver. And then the driver would have very little time to react - as soon as the autopilot disengages the driver would have to avoid hitting other traffic, buildings or falling off a cliff. And then we arrive in the same situation as those pilots were in - an experienced driver, who had many hours of actual behind-the-wheel experience could possibly save the car and himself from an accident, avoiding obstacles long enough for the car to stop. An unexperienced driver, who has only ever "driven" automatic vehicles would lack the wisdom to avoid crashing, would most likely panic and let the car hit something. To me, the comparison is almost perfect.
- mikeash 12y agoA broken sensor wouldn't completely disable the brakes. It would make them less precise, but the computer could still apply braking force. You'd have multiply-redundant systems to ensure that they were always available. It would take way more than just a couple of sensor failures as happened here, and that kind of massive failure only appears in really dire circumstances coupled with bad design, e.g. that DC-10 that lost all hydraulic systems when the engine exploded, because they managed to route them all past the same point.
- gambiting 12y agoYes, but the computer only knows as much as its sensors tell it. If according to the sensors the breaks are not working, it doesn't matter that they defacto work - the only logical conclusion that the computer can take at that point is assume it's unable to apply breaks and relinquish command to the driver. And even multiple sensors can become broken - like here, the plane had 3 sensor pipes and they all became clogged with ice. The autopilot assumed that the values are invalid, therefore it couldn't continue functioning - and gave control back to the pilots. Also, don't forget that you can't have redundant systems for everything, unless you want to be driving a tank. Imagine driving an automatic car and then some bird poo falls on the laser-sensor and the car literally can't see anymore(I am exaggerating, but the car can surely be blinded by something, the laser sensor on top can become dirty or damaged). The best it could do is apply full breaking force,but if you are on a motorway and there is an 18-wheeler behind you it could be a fatal idea. Again - the autopilot can't continue, it has to give control back to the driver - and the driver might crash the car if they are not experienced enough.