6 ms·
Me and my 'useless' gall bladder
- derekp7 12y agoI had to have mine removed last year. Prior to that, I had about 2 years of periodic extreme stomach pain, which felt kind of like the pain you would have after drinking too much strong whiskey. The first time that it got really bad I went to an acute care center, they said it was either ulcer or gastritis. Eventually, after about the 4th trip to the doctor I ended up on the ER due to the extreme pain. They did an ultrasound test, and found gall stones logged in the duct leading to the stomach. Meanwhile I was put on a zero fat diet until the surgery (since fat activates the gall bladder and pushes on the stones in the duct). Now this is something that gets me upset. Before the surgery, I had to go in for another test, where they observe the gall bladder by injecting iodine. Then after 2 hours the radiologist said there is a second part of the test which activates the gall bladder, so they could observe that. I then asked him what the effects of that would be, since the stones are logged in the duct, and I was on a no-fat diet due to it. So he calls the surgeon, then comes back and says "We are skipping that second test -- if we went through with it, you would have been in so much pain that we would have to hospitalize you". Again, this is an example of needing to know enough about your own condition, and not leave all the details in the hands of the professionals.
- freshyill 12y agoI had mine removed two years ago and my experience was similar. The first time it happened, it felt like just an odd kind of hunger—it seemed like my stomach was just telling me to feed it. Then I was fine for about four or five years before it would come back periodically over two years or so, getting worse each time. The second time I went to the doctor about it, they did some bloodwork and found that I had an elevated white blood cell count. It was two days after the appointment and they called me up (I was still home sick) and told me to get to the ER immediately. They considered operating that night, but said I'd have a better chance of getting a laparoscopic surgery if I waited for the infection to subside. They injected me with some really good painkillers and eventually sent me on my way. I was on antibiotics for a few weeks before surgery. As it turned out, the stones were still too big, and the whole thing was still a mess, so my surgeon just had to just cut me open. He later told me it was one of the worst gallbladders he'd ever seen. Instead of one night in the hospital, it was five days, and then another few weeks of recovery at home. Overall it was pretty rough but I haven't found that it has affected my ability to digest fat much, if at all.
- Morgawr 12y agoWhen I was 17, 8 years ago, I was diagnosed with gall stones. Before that, I remember eating something before going to sleep, it was around 2AM (bad eating habits, I know) and as soon as I finished my sandwich an acute pain hit my chest. I was 100% sure I was having some kind of heart attack and I rushed into my parents' room asking for help. I had to lay down on my bed with my mom panicking while my father called an ambulance, by the time they arrived the pain had completely stopped. I was given a quick check but nothing serious so they just went away. Then the following night it happened again (curse you, bad eating habits) and I got rushed into ER. They found a lot of gall stones and one of them was blocking some ducts, I think with pancreas but I don't remember. Due to an atrociously slow and bureaucratic process, I had to stay in the hospital for a whole month before surgery, because my delicate situation wouldn't let me eat even the lightest of foods, not even soup. Eventually I got surgery and said bye to my gall bladder. It's certainly an experience I wouldn't recommend to anyone. It's fairly low risk and very common, however the pain and feeling of something holding your chest was atrocious.
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoI had gallstones a few years ago. They are intensely painful. At first I chalked it up to bad food. The second time, I thought I must have an ulcer. The third time I realized it was my gallbladder. I went to an excellent specialist who confirmed to me what it was. The internist tells me he'll simply remove it. "You don't need your gallbladder anyway." I beg to differ. He wants to provide a sure result, first time, every time. I have a different goal: I want to do the least harm, least intrusion possible. I was perfectly fine with suffering a bit longer to achieve my goal. I postponed my appointment to proceed with the surgery and started by trying a "gallbladder cleansing." This is far from 100% reliable, but for me it worked. If it hadn't, I would have proceeded to the next mildest approach. Surgery is my last resort. For my doctor, it was his first. I'm in this for the long haul; it's my body and I have a responsibility to learn and understand it, to take proper care of it.
- greghinch 12y ago> and started by trying a "gallbladder cleansing." Can you elaborate on what this is?
- linguafranca 12y agoI had a similar experience recently. I recently had an ingrown toenail. The last time I had one (in high school) I let it get so bad that after gym class my white sock would be entirely red with blood. I had to go to a pediatrist who ended up using some kind of special scissors to cut a large chunk of my toenail off to fix it and wrapped it up for a while. Presuming I would have to go through this again, and would need a referral, I went to my local physician. Not surprisingly, said it was indeed an ingrown toenail. But, surprisingly, her first suggestion was to prescribe me some antibiotics! That was the first time in my life I had wondered about the suggested treatment, and I actually asked her "how would that help?" And I can't remember her answer, but it seemed really dumb, so I just said "no thanks" and asked what the alternatives were, and she said "to just let it grow out" after which I would be all fine. Now, recalling this story, I remember someone telling me about "BRAIN" or something like it, an acronym that includes "risk" and "alternatives" and "intrusive" and something else.
- Leon 12y agoAs someone who had their gallbladder out with complications afterwards, I feel like this article isn't realistic to the after effects. It's great the author did not have any, but before they recommend people go have it removed they should know that someone might be tied down to taking medicine daily for the rest of their life in the not-so-rare situation that their body disagrees with not having a gallbladder.
- curlyquote 12y agoI had mine removed about 4 years ago, haven't ever felt healthier than I do now.
- VLM 12y agoApparently care varies greatly by country. In Wisconsin about three months ago my mother in law was jerked around for about two weeks in the hospital before they would take it out. Multiple MRIs and endless apparently pointless tests. In her opinion they were making too much money off her, to be interested in curing her permanently by just taking it out. She's fine now.
- tahn 12y agoIn recent weeks I've been laid out a few times with gastrointestinal pain for 8+ hours after eating, and fat is maybe a correlation (pizza, chorizo in a meal, potatoes with butter). Then again, donuts seemingly haven't bothered me and I also got sick after a roast beef sandwich. Unfortunately I live in the middle of nowhere and my GP's only idea after everything he knew to try was negative has been to refer me to a gastroenterologist in a major city, with even the "emergency" appointment weeks away. After reading the story and comments, think I'll double down on avoiding fat and see if my GP can do anything about checking my gallbladder.
- Jtsummers 12y agoMy diagnosis was either ulcers or gallstones. I didn't fit the typical age or gender for gallstones, but they checked anyways. The diagnosis was confirmed with an ultrasound. Even in the middle of nowhere there's likely a clinic that can examine your gallbladder via ultrasound if they have someone that knows what they're looking for, otherwise perhaps it could be sent off to a hospital or doctor in a nearby city without requiring you to travel.
- bitwize 12y agoMy sister had hers out -- while 9 months pregnant no less. There are dietary changes that must be made, as it becomes more difficult to digest fatty foods. So while you can live without one, it is not a useless organ -- much like the appendix.
- vanderZwan 12y agoThere was a recent hypothesis that the appendix was a kind of "storage" for beneficial gut bacteria, important in keeping the gut flora ecosystem going. Of course, the whole notion of gut flora as being important for digestion is relatively new, so that turns out to be its main function it's no wonder we used to think it was useless. I wonder if that kind of misunderstanding applies to the gall bladder as well.
- csdrane 12y agoAgreed. I think blanket statements like "medical science has established that it is an almost completely useless organ [1]" need to caveat this with "medical science as it currently stands today". [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8454918 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8454918
- imgabe 12y agoI think we can safely infer that we are not referring to medical science from the future.
- SoftwareMaven 12y agoPeople blame gall stones on a fatty diet, but I think that is mistaken causality. It is certainly true that gall stone attacks often accompany fatty foods, but that's to be expected: the gall bladder's purpose is to pump out bile to help digest fatty acids. My anecdotal surveys of people with gall problems has led me to believe it is often a low fat diet that causes the stones, perhaps because the gall bladder is not being used enough to fully "clean" itself out between meals. This may be made worse by a lack of vitamin K2 causing poor calcium handling within the body (which, itself, is a fat soluble vitamin). These conditions cause impurities to build into gall stones and, when a fatty meal is eaten, the gall bladder tries to secrete bile and pushes the stone(s) into a biliary duct. Many people have been told they cannot eat fatty foods after their gall bladder is removed. For most, this isn't true, but it does take effort to rebuild one's ability to eat fat (you need to slowly work up to it), and some people are required to supplement with bear bile. Given a reduction in fat almost necessarily implies an increase in carbohydrates, and an increase in carbohydrate is strong associated with increased insulin resistance and the negative health outcomes associated with that, it's a worthwhile effort. I have misgivings about any supposedly "useless" organs. We know a lot about how the body works, but we certainly don't know everything. That a person can live without an organ does not mean they are living an optimal life without it.
- abecedarius 12y agoMore than anecdotal: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24321208 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24321208 Another anecdote: of the people close to me, one has had gallstones and gallbladder removal; they are also the one who'd done the most low-fat dieting over the years.
- flyrain 12y agoI have my gall bladder removed half year ago. Feel very good now. I am glad to see this post. I don't think "gallbladder cleansing" is a good idea. One of reason is that the gall bladder keeps making stone, and the little stone in the gall bladder might drop into the bile duct, which cause more serious problem.
- duckingtest 12y agoRemoving 'useless' organs like gall bladder, as a standard practice, would be catastrophic. Civilization is not a given, people can get stranded on uninhabited islands even today. Having these ancient adaptations in these situations can make the difference between life and death.
- jmiwhite 12y agoAnecdote: two people close to me have undergone cholecystectomy, and both developed IBS-D shortly following the operation; cholestyramine (essentially a powdered resin that absorbs bile in the the GI tract) proved to be a safe treatment. It seems that removing the gallbladder didn't make things worse on the whole - the symptoms of biliary obstruction were far worse than diarrhea or the daily requirement to consume orange-flavored plastic dust - but it did reveal an underlying excess of bile production that would irritate whatever it could downstream. I would be interested to know what caused that in the first place, and if it could be treated non-surgically.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]