3 ms·
> What RMS did invent is a clever license that allowed companies to contribute to open-source projects with no risk of their contributions being taken by their
by bad_user 17y ago
> What RMS did invent is a clever license that allowed companies to contribute to open-source projects with no risk of their contributions being taken by their competitors.
Actually the first big donation to open-source by a corporation is Netscape's Mozilla. It was distributed under their own license (MPL) following the definition of "open-source" ... a definition set forth because the term "free software" had ideological connotations.
Of course the FSF did valuable legal work prior to that, and they had a model to follow when defining what "open-source" is, but it was innevitable anyway.
The "open source" movement is not RMS's. Linux may have never been so popular without the work of Miguel, or without the folks at the Apache Foundation, or without Netscape's contribution, or without the contribution of so many others.
People have different goals, motivators and ideals. We will never get rid of proprietary software unless a business model is born that is better than selling copies of software. And that won't happen soon.
So instead of spreading the "free software virus" by brute force and activism, why not invite the corporations to contribute, such that at least the development tools and platforms become more open? And that's exactly what people like Miguel are doing.
I mean, I've worked on a couple of smallish projects in dotNet, and the landscape outside Microsoft is a waistland ... the majority of third party tools and libraries are proprietary. But more and more open-source tools are starting to come out of the Mono community or from CodePlex. The dotNet community is really warming up to "open-source". And I think that's really something.
- rbanffy 17y agoI think that the .NET users warming up to open-source is an important first step, but I don't believe Microsoft can act against its own interests by making a true commitment to open-source. Free Software has, indeed, ideological connotations. I strongly advocate for the freedoms it defends and also for the "giving back" attitude it obliges. Free Software, by its very definition, stays free. There are no such warranties in he rest of the open-source space. OS is useful, but I don't think it's enough.
- bad_user 17y ago> I don't believe Microsoft can act against its own interests by making a true commitment to open-source. I don't think Microsoft is acting against its interests by committing to open-source. Quite the contrary. If they open-sourced Silverlight, would they lose money from their authoring tools? What they would lose is some level of control, but they could win a big enough user-base to take on Flash, which is still king. Would I care if their authoring tools are proprietary and expensive? Not at all if they're getting the job done, as long as the platform is open. You see, open source is really about economics, being many times a cheaper and more effective way of developing and distributing software. If you want to talk about rights with normal people, you'll have to explain those rights in terms of benefits. Having the ability to share software with your friends is not a good incentive for many software developers. But having your piece of software maintained by others (when you don't want to die doing that) is an incentive. And I don't think that the "giving back" attitude should be forced. It should come naturally from the inherent gains. We are so blinded by the individualism promoted by capitalism that we forget sharing and cooperation have real advantages. But being blinded by an ideology with opposites points of view is evenly shortsighted. You see, while many people in Silicon Valley or in Cambridge are working happily in startups or on cool projects that will save the world someday, the rest of the world is kind of stuck in consultancy with flat hourly bills, working on boring and-not-quite-fulfilling projects that in many countries pays less than your average gas-station supervisor. And working on Free Software when your hourly rate is $10 an hour you can trust me it's not that great. Another thing about open-source software is that there are clear disadvantages of the development model. You can see that in the unpolished GUIs of the open-source applications or in the lack of documentation (there are times when I thank God if I find a blog-post with an example for a library I'm trying to use). The notable exceptions are only those where the software itself is a complementary to something else that sells (like hardware, or ads) ... which is ironic since Microsoft was worshiped back in the day by many programmers for being a successfully pure software company (finally, our profession was going to have recognition). So yeah, fighting a war against proprietary software is futile. Proprietary software will never be replaced by ideology. A better business model will (like <gasp> software as a service ... in which the software doesn't even run on your machine).