9 ms·
A recent study (I can't find it unfortunately) on eating breakfast discovered that people who ate breakfast would fidget throughout the morning, as their body d
by crazygringo 12y ago
A recent study (I can't find it unfortunately) on eating breakfast discovered that people who ate breakfast would fidget throughout the morning, as their body did its best to burn extra calories. Whereas people who didn't eat breakfast wouldn't fidget, since there was no need for their body to burn extra calories. This is entirely subconscious.
The fallacy of calories in/out has nothing to do with "thermodynamics" (seriously, will this misunderstanding please die!), and everything to do with the fact that metabolism and behavior are not constants, but can change based on calorie intake. Just like the body's ability to gain or lose fat is not a function just of available calories, but of hormonal regulation that makes fat cells absorb or release calories.
- physPop 12y agoThere is no > fallacy of calories in/out and it has everything to do with thermodynamics. This is exemplified in your very own example: fidgeting more means a higher expenditure of energy. Chemical energy doesn't magically disappear. While metabolic regulation is certainly a complex subject it is simply wrong to categorically state that thermodynamics is somehow obviated.
- sjwright 12y agoIt's wrong in the sense that the human body isn't a closed system.
- icelancer 12y agoThis is not a "misunderstanding" on my end. I know quite a bit about nutrition science and exercise physiology. There are a large number of people who honestly believe that the laws of thermodynamics can be trumped by human biology, excluding any and all externalities. The OP made a statement that may place him in that category. If you want to talk about satiety, diet patterns, behavior remapping, nutrient partitioning, fat/muscle ratios, glycogen stores, or other advanced topics, feel free. But the idea that thermodynamics do not govern 85% (being very generous here) of the effectiveness of a weight loss program is willful self-delusion.
- jvrossb 12y agoI think the idea is that 10 grams of sugar for example may get broken down by person A in such a way as to generate 40 calories whereas person B might only generate 30. No violation of the laws of thermodynamics there.
- scotty79 12y agoJust violation of basic biochemistry, I suppose.
- logfromblammo 12y agoAbsorption of food energy from food is affected by several factors, including the proportions of different species of microbes inside the intestines. Sucrose sugar will be more uniformly absorbed, as the enzymes required to break it down into fructose and glucose are nearly universal. Glucose metabolism is fundamental to animal physiology. Fructose metabolism is about the same for all humans. For something like the lactose in cow's milk, the relative metabolic impact for different humans can vary greatly. Some people can metabolize it directly. In others, gut bacteria must digest it into a usable form first. For those people, the composition of their gut flora will determine how efficiently the food energy from lactose is absorbed by their bodies. That is how the energy calculated by complete combustion in a bomb calorimeter might differ significantly from the energy added to a biological organism. That calorimeter value is essentially the upper limit for "calories in". Using that value means that you still have an unknown value for digestion and metabolism inefficiency in the "calories out" column. This is why counting "calories in" and "calories out" does not work as expected. The former can be determined easily with the aforementioned calorimeter. But the latter is a complex function that includes "calories in" as an input parameter. You would literally have to wear measurement devices on your body 24 hours a day in a controlled environment, and use special toilets to ever know exactly what your "calories out" numbers are. You would have to calculate thermal losses, water balance, and gas exchange. This is simply not practical for anyone. Recommending it is madness. It is far more useful to experimentally determine, on a per-person basis, the actions and activities that result in changes in body composition, do the ones that cause adverse changes less, and the ones that cause desired changes more. There are very few recommendations that work the same way for everyone. But for people that want to reduce their body fat percentage, some stand out. Consume fewer monosaccharides, disaccharides, and trisaccharides. Do strength exercises regularly. Do cardio exercises regularly. Following those three recommendations often achieve the desired results without the need to count calories. But other ways are possible, some of which are not universally applicable to all humans. In the absence of sophisticated measurement equipment, it is more practical to simply experiment, using plausible hypotheses, until the desired results are achieved. Do what works. Avoid what does not work. Your results will vary from other animals with different biochemical responses, including other humans that may be closely related to you genetically.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]