3 ms·
It depends. The rate of smoke alarms going off inadvertently while someone is cooking is high compared to the actual incidence of fires. The rate of smoke ala
by dllthomas 12y ago
It depends. The rate of smoke alarms going off inadvertently while someone is cooking is high compared to the actual incidence of fires. The rate of smoke alarms going of when no one is doing anything heat-related is clearly lower. If you are a person who just burned some toast, that is almost certainly the reason the smoke alarm is going off, and it's entirely reasonable to address the symptoms. If you are a person who woke up to a smoke alarm, and no one else was cooking anything, things are a little different.
- x1798DE 12y agoI don't know if I've ever experienced personal (home) fire alarms going off for no reason, and I've never had them go off because of an actual fire, but I have had them go off when someone else is cooking (alerting me that someone is cooking, whether or not I knew that), or due to steam from a shower, if they are placed wrong - again, whether or not I knew someone was taking a shower. In corporate/organizational environments - often in buildings made entirely of concrete - I've had them go off very frequently, but almost never as a result of a dangerous condition - usually either a drill, a small fire that was immediately put out, someone pulling the fire alarm as a prank/protest or something else like someone burning popcorn or something. I still think the point stands.
- dllthomas 12y agoWhich point? My point was that in a (nonadversarial) context where you have known triggers for false alarms, P(problem|alarm) falls dramatically once you have identified the presence of such a trigger, and it's entirely reasonable for our actions to reflect this.