5 ms·
Ask HN: Would a “National Fire Drill” save more lives than it cost?
In the wake of the Ebola outbreak, it occurred to me that there is a slim possibility travel and "physical interactions" might actually be imposed.
It also occurs to me that fire drills help the occupants of buildings to be more calm and better prepared in the event of a real fire.
So would it be possibly to estimate the numbers who would die if we practised a two day shutdown as if an infectious outbreak was occurring - not to train the emergency services but to make sure all us citizens had thought about the many necessities of a shutdown? Got a calor gas cooker or extra twenty tins of tomatoes or ...
There is a (small?) likelihood of harm during such an exercise. But will the benefits outweigh the cost?
- dalke 12y agoFires break out often. We have plenty of experience in how to handle it, and the likely variations. They also take place in relatively small areas, where it's possible to stagger the training. It's very hard to practice large-scale events where we don't know the details of how to handle it. A disease transmitted by animals or insects is different than water born is different than through bodily contact, etc. We have quarantine laws in place, btw. See http://www.cdc.gov/quarantine/specificlawsregulations.html http://www.cdc.gov/quarantine/specificlawsregulations.html . They haven't been used since the Spanish Flu pandemic of 1918-1919. How often do we need to train in order that everyone has an idea of what to do? Once a year? Once a decade? Without experience giving feedback, how do you judge if it's often enough? In any case we know that hurricanes come to the Gulf and Atlantic coasts, and we know that people are supposed to keep emergency supplies. Every year there's available training, reminders on grocery bags, mentions in the news shows, etc. We also know that they don't - one need only look at how quickly certain things like batteries are sold out. If people don't plan for once-every-few-years events, they aren't likely to plan for once-every-century events.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoThe hurricane comparison is a good one - but presumably some of the people who did buy batteries did so because they saw the warning on the shopping bag - and would not if the bag was blank. I am pretty sure the lessons of crowd behaviour is that the difference between mass riots and calm management is to be measured at the margin. So almost any drills that can prevent a nation breakin down have a lot of value, which is my not very hidden agenda here. I am also fairly sure that fire drills seem not to evolve with time and experience, makng it hard to believe that just because we cannot measure how effective a drill is in staging off national disaster - the essence has not changed in twenty years by my memory. Despite a down thread comment it seems that preparedness is considered a good thing in itself by fire services.
- dalke 12y agoEh, I can't find pictures of the bags I remember from when I lived in Florida. It's the regular brown paper bags. They would have a suggested shopping list on the side, to help plan before a hurricane comes. They would also have a hurricane tracking map. It's definitely a early planning thing because it's pointless to get the list of things to buy after you've gone through checkout. Here's an example I can find - “Prepare for Hurricane Season” coupons for 6/22 to 7/19 (the start of hurricane season) http://www.iheartpublix.com/2014/06/new-publix-coupons-prepare-hurricane-season-valid-622-719/ http://www.iheartpublix.com/2014/06/new-publix-coupons-prepa... . Same basic point though - buy staples early because the shelves will quickly be bare if a hurricane is coming. "almost any drills that can prevent a nation breakin down have a lot of value" You need to demonstrate that 1) the nation might break down, 2) there are predictable way(s) that it will break down, 3) there are drills which might prevent that from happening, 4) that a significant proportion (10%? 80%) of the people will participate, and 5) that it's worth the costs, including social effects. Otherwise (and IMHO) you are worried about fantasy scenarios. And I don't even agree with part 1) For another historical example, look towards civil defense preparations for nuclear war. Should we still be doing "duck and cover" drills, on the off chance that a nuclear bomb will go off? When I was a kid they tested the civil defense / nuclear missile warning system every month, just in case. I wonder if they still do that now.. Compare that to the fire, tornado, earthquake, tsunami, etc. drills that people do now. Those are more likely, there's more experience with them, and there are specific ways to handle each one. "fire drills seem not to evolve with time and experience" The technique for sharpening pencils hasn't changed much either. There's something like 130 years of experience in doing school fire drills. Why should you expect to see big changes in the last 20 years?
- lifeisstillgood 12y ago"National breakdown" does sound extreme, but the damage to "society" by failing to prepare for a hurricane is the sort if level of impact I am thinking of - not World War Z. But we lack even the minimum levels of putting advice on shopping bags in the vast majority of States and countries. If there is a real need to lock down say two states, is it reasonable to expect the one that regularly has hurricane drills and experience will fare better - I assume so - and primarily because it's citizens are more prepared for hurricanes and thus anything is slightly easier to deal with. This is an eminently reasonable position to take IMNSHO - most armies will tell you preparation beats most everything else. all your points are valid and I am far more convinced than before I started. I guess my only objection is experience has taught me to beware of convincing explanations that I ought to do nothing ... Which barely counts as a rational position.
- impendia 12y agoIn my experience, fire drills make people too calm in the event of a fire. Five years ago, fire alarms rang throughout the office building I was working in. People were nonchalant. Most people left eventually, although some people went back in to pick up some books to read or grab some work to do. Meanwhile, and to my surprise, there was actually a fire. The fire department showed up, and they were pissed that people weren't taking the alarm seriously.
- dalke 12y agoThat means your fire drills aren't being run correctly. Rather, how come this poor behavior wasn't noticed during earlier drills? Did the staff fire warden not have the management support to be able to affect staff behavior?
- impendia 12y agoWe'd never had a fire drill in this building, but like all Americans we'd been through dozens of fire drills before, mostly in school. I don't really understand your second question. Our office did not employ or appoint a fire warden. In any case, I was unaware of anyone outside the fire department who was upset.
- dalke 12y agoYou started with "In my experience, fire drills make people too calm in the event of a fire." I thought that meant that your building had fire drills, and those previous drills made them too calm. A real fire drill is more than setting off alarms to see if they work. There are also local fire wardens, which are staff whose job it is to see that people hear the alerts and evacuate, and who make sure that people don't try to re-enter the building. I've done consulting work for chemical manufacturing companies. A couple required that I go through (pretty basic) training just to work on site. Another had a fire alarm go off at about 6pm, when I and others were still there. Almost evacuated that building (there was some doofus who was on a phone call and refused to leave.) I was only there for consulting work, and don't know what happened to that person. But if management believes that fire drills, and responding correctly to actual fire alarms, are necessary, then they will reprimand those who don't participate. But what you experienced was different than I thought. There were no fire drills, people were mostly using their experiences from school/college, and management didn't care. That's not the same as fire drills making people complacent. It could be that the lack of fire drills making people complacent. In any case, I'm not suggesting your building needs regular fire drills. Buildings are much safer now they they used to be, and most places don't have fire drills because the cost of running them is worse than the benefits of not. (Chemical companies which store lots of flammable materials on-site, and schools or hospital care facilities with a lot of people who need assistance to evaluate, are exceptions.)
- logn 12y agoIn the northern parts, that's called an ice storm. Few people die. Almost anyone can live 2 days without food, and water is normally safe after boiling. I think the bigger problem is that local governments are underfunded and national governments are such bureaucracies that it's nearly impossible to mobilize a rapid and effective response.