3 ms·
I think the fundamental problem is that Android permissions (and privilege controls for most other platforms) are far too coarsely-grained. I'm perfectly happy
by jdietrich 12y ago
I think the fundamental problem is that Android permissions (and privilege controls for most other platforms) are far too coarsely-grained.
I'm perfectly happy to allow an app to save files to a specific named folder on my device. I'm perfectly happy to grant access to my camera when specifically prompted for barcode scanning or what have you. I'm happy to allow an app to check whether I'm on 3G or Wifi to save on data costs. Android permissions are currently far too binary. Permissions need to be more specific and explicit, atomised down to the finest possible gradations; The permissions dialog needs to clearly explain precisely what is being accessed, with extra resources available to help the user understand the privacy and security implications.
This frustrates me both as a developer and as a user. As a user, I avoid all sorts of apps that are probably requesting permissions for good reason, but that I don't really trust. As a developer, I find myself leaving out potentially useful features so that I don't present the user with a laundry-list of permissions.
I fastidiously explain exactly why my apps require permissions in the app description, but I shouldn't need to and my users shouldn't need to trust me - I should be able to specify the exact subset of functionality needed by my app and my users should be able to grant me that and only that.
Users should be able to reject or falsify any API request at will, and the SDK should be designed around this; Appropriate and flexible exception handling for API calls should be mandatory, with UI to alert the user if functionality is unavailable or unreliable due to their privacy settings, and with the option to allow specific access on a case-by-case basis.
As an industry, we need to look past our short-term lust for analytics data and ad impressions, and think about the future of computing. I think we are grossly underestimating the importance and urgency of user trust, which is hard-earned and easily lost. With the increasing ubiquity of computing and recent revelations about surveillance and leaks, we need to be making bold decisions to empower users to control their own data and devices. The future of computing is truly bleak if we cannot truthfully convince users that they are the masters of their devices and not the servants. Without decisive action, we risk a catastrophic and wholly justifiable collapse of trust that could set us back decades.
- seanflyon 12y ago> I think the fundamental problem is that Android permissions (and privilege controls for most other platforms) are far too coarsely-grained. I think that point of view is only relevant to a small percentage of users who pay enough attention.