3 ms·
I use bootstrap because a common design language is a good thing. If your iOS app uses custom controls and deviates from the Apple design language, your desig
by bryanlarsen 12y ago
I use bootstrap because a common design language is a good thing. If your iOS app uses custom controls and deviates from the Apple design language, your design is rightly criticized.
Yet on the web, you are criticized for not being different.
I call B.S.
I don't have to teach my users what a hamburger menu is because they've seen it elsewhere.
My users think my sites look good because I let professional designers do the heavy lifting. Because my sites look like many other sites, they are comfortable, easy to use and not jarring.
The only people who care that you've used Bootstrap are other web developers. And it's probably not because everything looks the same, it's because you did it the easy way. You're supposed to walk up the hill backwards in the snow both ways like all the old-timers did.
Guess what, your clients want you to do it the easy way. The quicker you get the design done, the quicker you can move on to other things that add value to the site.
- SwellJoe 12y agoThe value of a common design language thing really can't be overestimated, I think. I'm working on a new wiki, a new UI for our products, and a new Drupal deployment for our forums/issues/shopping cart. Making all of these look consistent would have been unrealistic on our budget in the past...given that there are now Bootstrap themes for Drupal and MediaWiki (with varying degrees of completeness and quality), it becomes much more reasonable. We may still fail to provide perfect consistency, but it'll be a lot closer than was possible in the past. Also, the "bloat" arguments that I keep seeing are kind of no-op arguments, used against languages, operating systems, applications, etc. when you don't have useful criticisms. "Bloat" means, "it has features I don't use". Which is true of most things that have been in development for a while. It also ignores the ability to roll a custom Bootstrap which is missing the stuff you don't need. Sure there are some inter-dependencies, but nothing too offensive. I like that we now have a higher level abstraction for UI components. I hate it when desktop application designers throw together their own UI components and ignore the OS guidelines and API. That's not to say there isn't room for innovation and novel UI concepts. Just that if you're building a thing with buttons and tables and forms and crap like that, it probably doesn't need to look completely unlike anything else that has ever existed...and it's probably bad design if it does look completely unlike anything else that has ever existed.
- freehunter 12y agoIf Bootstrap means you won't do the "scrolling doesn't actually scroll but flips to the next frame in what is really just a video" then for the love of god please use Bootstrap.
- masklinn 12y ago> If your iOS app uses custom controls and deviates from the Apple design language, your design is rightly criticized. Not necessarily true, even ignoring games (which are a whole 'nother bucket of filth) deviating from Apple's guideline and creating your own aesthetics can work nicely. It is a huge amount of design and implementation work, especially if you want to match the spit and polish of the built-in solutions, but because iOS applications are "full screen" it can in fact work better than on a desktop: there's no chrome with different aesthetics around. Tapbots has been pretty successful at building up and using their own non-native aesthetics. They're completely insane though, their attention to detail is even higher than the platform's.
- k-mcgrady 12y ago>> "Tapbots has been pretty successful at building up and using their own non-native aesthetics. They're completely insane though, their attention to detail is even higher than the platform's." Tapbots has a certain aethetic. But take Tweetbot for example. It uses a navigation bar. It uses a tab bar. It uses a vertically scrolling table view. Tapping a table cell brings you to the next view with same animation every other iOS app uses and the back button is in the top left of the navigation bar like every other iOS app. Design is more than looks. They have made it look great and unique whilst making things work in a way users are familiar with.
- masklinn 12y ago> Tapbots has a certain aethetic. But take Tweetbot for example. Tweetbot 3 has dialed back the custom behavior and aesthetic to match iOS7, but Convertbot and Calcbot have not, neither has Tweetbot/Mac. > Tapping a table cell brings you to the next view Tapping a message cell opens an action drawer under the cell.
- ben336 12y agoNote that Tapbots still hasn't been able to produce a Tweetbot 3 version for iPad, presumably because of the work required to switch the visuals when iOS8 made their aesthetic feel more out of date.
- stronglikedan 12y agoI use Bootstrap, because the majority of the apps that I build are for internal use within the company that I work for. The default look and feel is perfect for these utilitarian apps, and we don't have to worry about being inconsistent in our design by using it. It's just the right tool for my job.