4 ms·
A. I really like that Ebert stories occasionally pop up on HN, before and after his death. I don't think there is a newspaper writer whose words I've paid more
by danso 12y ago
A. I really like that Ebert stories occasionally pop up on HN, before and after his death. I don't think there is a newspaper writer whose words I've paid more attention to, and I still reflexively visit rogerbert.com on Fridays to see the latest reviews (some of his replacements are pretty good, but they aren't Roger yet).
B. I've always thought it'd be a great thing for university classes to have, as a weekly assignment or final project, for each student to choose a Wiki page and actively edit it, whether it's to add actual content, improve the writing quality, or to restructure and reorganize the page and its priorities.
Hopefully, in practice, once a student starts putting work into a page, they will face resistance from the page's traditional editors. And that's when the fun begins: the students would learn from the give-and-take of the collaborative editing process, as well as getting a great deal of editing experience, period...and if the student is halfway-apt, the debates over significance/sourcing/structure would compel the student to do even more research on the topic...in fact, that's why I stay away from Wikipedia editing, because I end up spending hours doing research and fact-finding, even for trivial things...it's character building, but bad for the work schedule :).
The whole thing is also a lesson about the Internet community and dynamic...which, sure, you could learn by spending a semester on Reddit...on the other hand, at the end of the Wikipedia assignment, both the student and the world more directly benefits from the product of the student's labor: a better Wikipedia page.
- ivanca 12y agoYeah, this needs to happen. It need to start somewhere so if someone here works at a college it should start the movement. WaS = Wikipedia as Assignment.
- rspeer 12y agoThis exists: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:School_and_university_projects http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:School_and_university... And it definitely helps to coordinate them through that page. Otherwise, active editors tend to just say "GAAAH why are all these new users suddenly editing on similar topics and not following the style guide at all," and sometimes they conclude it's some sort of coordinated manipulation and start reverting en masse, which is never a good thing to happen to a school assignment.
- pXMzR2A 12y ago> as a weekly assignment or final project, for each student to choose a Wiki page and actively edit it http://dynamicecology.wordpress.com/2014/05/05/using-wikipedia-in-the-classroom-a-cautionary-tale/ http://dynamicecology.wordpress.com/2014/05/05/using-wikiped... and http://dynamicecology.wordpress.com/2014/05/10/follow-up-to-my-cautionary-tale-regarding-using-wikipedia-in-the-classroom/ http://dynamicecology.wordpress.com/2014/05/10/follow-up-to-...
- CJefferson 12y agoWhat happens when the existing editors decide to block the student's changes, even when they are well referenced and fix existing errors? Would be hard in practice to mark. Perhaps the student could submit what they would like the page to look like, and the lecturer could just mark that. Putting even part of a student's mark in the hands of often irrational Wikipedia editors seems unreasonable.
- dspillett 12y agoUnless they really take exception to the changes and properly expunge them, the student's updated version will still be visible in the history (with a diff between it and the previous versions easy to view) - so overly territorial editors wouldn't be that much of a problem unless they were completely fruit-loop. And as a precautionary measure, there is always "File, Save Page As".
- x1798DE 12y agoJust to add to this, getting in touch with a Wikipedian who deals with this sort of thing a lot - preferably before starting the assignment, but if necessary after some sort of drama has occurred - probably goes a long way. There are a lot of under-watched corners of Wikipedia where territorial fruit loops sit on guard, but experienced editors usually know how to navigate those rough waters when they come upon them. Generally when people start these courses they just notify everyone ahead of time, get advice from wikipedians, make sure the students are adequately sourcing and documenting their process, etc. You tend to have these conflict issues when a student goes into an article and dumps a whole bunch of changes of varying quality in there at once, then doesn't know where to go to find sympathetic editors who can sort out relevant quality and policy concerns from basic territorial behavior.
- dspillett 12y agoAlso as the suggestion was for a learning/experience exercise, running into someone like that is a useful life lesson especially if things turn out well in the end. Being able to work around such problems (often it is a matter of carefully controlling your tone & presentation, including being aware that the person on the other end knows nothing about you and has no body language cues to gauge your behaviour from so you have to be more careful to be very clear in your intent than you would in real life) and find the common ground needed to cooperate is a very useful life skill.
- jebus989 12y agoB is a indeed good idea and it already happens, though not as much as Wikipedia would like. Why make a class write a long essay that'll eventually be filed in a bin somewhere when they could be make real contributions to open knowledge? It also might help with Wikipedia's recruitment problem. There's some advice to help implement successful Wiki-assignments here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Student_assignments https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Student_assignments
- protonfish 12y agoIt's unfair to blame "the Internet community and dynamic" in general. The community and dynamic are built by the rules of the site. There is a reason that Wikipedia has quality content that would not be possible by a free-for-all editable page. As much as their rules have resulted in the output of a wonderful source of knowledge, it is far from unquestioningly perfect. The worst problem I see is the need for a single consensus on a page. I would prefer, if there was a controversy in a page's community, to split into multiple pages each representing the topic from a clear viewpoint instead of a single page of watered-down groupthink.
- hotgoldminer 12y agoWhy limit to formal classrooms and universities. Perhaps the Wikipedia editing community could start programs to teach and nurture new editors. People like structure and guidance, and the commitment to a group would help with motivation. Does this exist? If not, anyone else interested?