30 ms·
You are equating universities with trolls. It's easy to tell the difference. Universities have employees who are listed as inventors. Trolls don't. Universities
by Zigurd 12y ago
You are equating universities with trolls. It's easy to tell the difference. Universities have employees who are listed as inventors. Trolls don't. Universities license their patents on reasonable terms and seldom litigate or even threaten litigation. Universities are able to do this because their patents cover valuable technologies. Trolls Trolls buy up crap patents and wield them like a motorcycle chain wielded by a street thug on unsuspecting passers by to see who's got a wallet worth taking.
Yet, by your lights, none of the above is an abuse of process. Even the patents sold off by failed ventures are toxic. Relatively few things a zero-stage venture has implemented are worth patenting. Investors requiring ventures to file provisionals are proliferating crap patents. These patents become vanity vehicles, listing "inventors" who are polishing their resumes.
You say you can tell drug money from money carried by people who distrust banks. Yet here you are willfully blind.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sillysaurus3 12y agoYour comment is overshadowed by your emotion, which is a shame. It could've been much better. For example, if you have any source for "Universities license their patents on reasonable terms and seldom litigate or even threaten litigation," then that would be interesting. Or a direct, actionable suggestion about how the current system could change. I'm worried that comments like yours will make people like rayiner less inclined to contribute to HN, especially with sentences like "You say you can tell drug money from money carried by people who distrust banks. Yet here you are willfully blind," which seems to be both an unrelated topic and a personal attack.
- Zigurd 12y agorayiner deserves to be called out. He is selectively perceptive of distinctions. That's dishonest. And I'd rather have him and/or keep him out of the government that off HN. He's the kind of opportunist who got us our rent-seeking telcos and cablecos.
- sillysaurus3 12y agoPersonal attacks are not allowed on HN. Please stop this.
- whatusername 12y agoI've seen plenty of people call CSIRO a troll. And it's definitely a NPE and also not a university.
- philh 12y ago> You are equating universities with trolls. Huh? Ve said, > The article equates non-practicing entities with trolls, which isn't really fair. Most universities, for example, are non-practicing entities which pretty clearly is intended to mean that universities are not trolls. Did you mean "you're distinguishing between them, but I don't"? (I can't work out where you're expressing your honest opinion, where you're describing what you think is rayiner's opinion, and where you're being sarcastic.)
- tptacek 12y agoThe singular "they" is as old as Chaucer and used by Shakespeare, Conrad, Austen, and EB White. The made-up word "ve" is, for what it's worth, an attempt to pick a usage fight that you won't win. :) Join us in camp "gender-neutral singular 'they'". You have nothing to lose but your &c &c &c.
- philh 12y agoSingular they is one thing, specific-person they is another. I haven't actually checked, but I suspect that most-if-not-all of those historical instances are referring to a person in abstract, rather than a known person of unknown gender. Regardless, I'm not necessarily expecting to win this usage fight, but for the amount of effort it costs me, I don't mind throwing in anyway.
- idlewords 12y ago"I haven't actually checked" means you're wasting everybody's time right now.
- tptacek 12y agoNo. Not so. You've already lost this fight. See the positive side: now you can use "they" instead of "ve" and not fight your autocorrect like I just had to. Don't take my word for it. This is a whole section of the estimable Language Log blog: http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?cat=27 http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?cat=27
- sthu11182 12y agoThe example of VirnetX is interesting because it is "troll" in the eyes of many, but the patents it is suing on are from SAIC, with whom they are partnering with.