6 ms·
Since 2010, trolls have made 3 times as much money in court as real companies
- applecore 12y agoNot surprising, since trolls exist solely to make money through the legal system; companies, usually, make money another way.
- placebo 12y agoI'll bet criminal organisations that use extortion on businesses also make more money than the average businesses being targeted. The fact that trolls use the law instead of violence doesn't make it that much better. Legal but morally offensive practices are certainly not exclusive to patent trolls though. They just get more attention due to the publicity of the action.
- tjaerv 12y ago> The fact that trolls use the law instead of violence… Law enforcement is violence.
- _delirium 12y agoI can believe that, but it doesn't by itself show the full effect of the patent system. The threat of a legal case is important in a lot of places where no actual legal case develops. For example, Stanford's CCRMA computer-music research lab has been funded over the past few decades largely by patent royalties, from licensing patents to synth-makers like Yamaha. IMO that's an example of the patent system functioning largely as intended: R&D group develops something, licenses it to a commercialization group, which develops a product and pays a small percentage as royalties to the R&D group. No court actual court case happened anywhere here, because everyone played by the rules. Yet the possibility of one was necessary, or else there'd be no reason for Yamaha to pay anything at all. So for a full picture of the effect of the patent system, I think you need to look at total licensing royalties, including both court-ordered and contractually agreed ones.
- rayiner 12y agoThe value of the civil legal system is entirely about the influence of the possibility of litigation on primary behavior. Obviously any actual litigation is a loss--but the possibility of recourse to litigation can allow transactions to happen in low-trust environments, and thus be a net win. Similarly, value of NPE's is that they allow recovery of investment into R&D that doesn't lead directly to a product, thus reducing the barrier to investing in R&D.
- derf_ 12y agoSo that would include the nearly $100 million collected by Forgent in settlements over bogus JPEG patents [1]? Or all of the other NPEs who target the small startup, the app writer, or anyone else they can think of who can't afford a long, protracted legal battle? Yeah, this article is just part of a complex picture, but it's telling. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asure_Software#JPEG http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asure_Software#JPEG
- dsugarman 12y agocurious to see more detailed data, this seems to include research companies that, in fields like pharma, are real companies and their major product is patents.
- PythonicAlpha 12y agoNot only pharma: What about ARM? As much as I know, they even don't have a chip factory. They just deal with their chip-designs (I am not sure, if it falls under copyright or the patent system -- but it is just a chip design, some ideas and such they are selling).
- jolux 12y agoThe ARM holding company makes designs and maintains the ARM instruction set and licenses them to manufacturers or designers under a processor license, (for a specific processor without modification), a POP license, (a processor optimized for you if you can't do it yourself), or rarely, an architecture license. Architecture licenses allow you to do whatever you want as long as it implements the ARM ISA. Apple holds an ARM architecture license for the Cortex A15 used to develop the Swift core in the A7 and A8. See http://www.anandtech.com/show/7112/the-arm-diaries-part-1-how-arms-business-model-works http://www.anandtech.com/show/7112/the-arm-diaries-part-1-ho... for more information.
- jkeats 12y agoI think there's a couple of distinctions to be made between trolls and more legitimate IP owners: - trolls usually aren't the original IP creator, - trolls' patents often cover trivial material, or ideas which are included in prior art. I'm gessing that ARM patents are not trivial.
- PythonicAlpha 12y agoYes, you are right. But the distinction that should divide trolls from non-trolls (at least, as much, as the big corporations wanted) was mainly, if a company produces something related to the patent. And that is in my opinion the worst classification you can find (it is handy of course for the big corporations).
- niels_olson 12y agoI'm beginning to think the patent system is a mechanism for lawyers to extract money from people. The odds of another lawyer turning off that spigot seems low.
- rayiner 12y agoThe article equates non-practicing entities with trolls, which isn't really fair. Most universities, for example, are non-practicing entities, and so are vehicles like Mojave Aerospace Ventures, the NPE used by Paul Allen to structure his investment into Rutan's Spaceship One. More importantly, most of the other NPE's hold patents made by practicing companies. There are clearly NPE's that deserve the moniker troll, but that has more to do with abuse of the process than non-practicing status. In a way, NPE's are a refinement of one of the key advantages of the patent system--separating R&D from product development. It's the foil to the natural tendency towards vertical integration and the otherwise inevitable dominance of companies that have the strongest manufacturing capability. All of this is of course orthogonal to the validity of particular kinds of patents.
- sillysaurus3 12y agoHow often do entities like universities or a Paul Allen type company sue for patent royalties? (This isn't to discount your comment in any way. I'm just genuinely curious whether such entities derive substantial revenue from enforcing patent rights, and whether trolls account for >95% of the revenue from patents.)
- rayiner 12y agoMany companies like ARM, Qualcomm, etc, rely on at least the background threat of litigating for their revenue. For obvious reasons, it's the folks with claims at the margin that are most likely to litigate. That doesn't mean that the existence of recourse to litigation doesn't primarily benefit those who are most clearly in the right.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> How often do entities like universities or a Paul Allen type company sue for patent royalties? (This isn't to discount your comment in any way. I'm just genuinely curious whether such entities derive substantial revenue from enforcing patent rights, and whether trolls account for >95% of the revenue from patents.) Part of the reason revenue is skewed toward patent trolls is the way they litigate. In most legitimate negotiations the inventor shows the patented invention to the prospective licensee who then decides whether the amount required to license the patent is worth it for including that feature in their product. If the patent holder is asking too much then the prospective licensee can walk away and pay nothing by just not adding that feature to their product. In this situation there is hardly ever any need for litigation since it would only occur if the company consciously chose to use the technology without licensing it. By contrast, patent trolls almost always knock on the doors of companies that are already allegedly infringing their alleged patents. In that case the practicing entity has no option to walk away because they can be sued for past infringement even if they change their product immediately and will incur significant legal expenses even if they win in court. Furthermore, juries have the unfortunate tendency to vastly overestimate the market value of many patents, and now the defendant has to negotiate against a possible jury award rather than the actual market value of not being able to use the technology. This all adds up to mean that the trolling behavior of filing a lawsuit against someone already allegedly infringing has a much larger revenue potential than the honest behavior of offering to license a new technology to a company that isn't already using it. It also means that the trolls make up a disproportionately large percentage of actual litigation.
- Animats 12y agoIf you look at the EFF's list of patent troll litigation, it turns out that only three small law firms send out most than a few demand letters, and one firm is the big threat generator. Also, if the patent holder wins in court, they weren't a troll. They really did have strong patent rights.
- 5414h 12y agohow can a troll make money ?
- TeMPOraL 12y agoThe more I watch the development of patent trolling cases or net neutrality issues, the more I come to conclusion that the real problem is that we don't have any good legal and economical representation of the term "asshole". Most of discussions around those topics tend to be about whether or not a given proxy is good enough to capture the majority of despicable behaviour. The core issue is - and I'm probably stating the obvious, but it bears repeating every now and then - that we don't have a legal framework for capturing intent.
- cbd1984 12y agoLaws take intent into account all the time. It's the difference between acting and assault, for example: Do you intend to put on a show or do you intend to make someone afraid for their safety? The problem you're hitting on is that being an asshole isn't illegal, because we can't write laws that vague. Well, we could, but they'd be applied inconsistently enough that courts would practically fall over themselves to strike them down. And they should: One person's idea of asshole behavior is another person's idea of normal variation, which is fun when the difference comes down to culture, which always gets recast in terms of race, as in Europe's anti-Roma racism.
- rhino369 12y agoSCOTUS handed down two rulings this year that pretty much exactly that. http://www.mwe.com/Unanimous-Supreme-Court-Exceptional-Patent-Cases-Determined-at-District-Courts-Discretion-with-Appellate-Review-only-for-Abuse-05-05-2014/ http://www.mwe.com/Unanimous-Supreme-Court-Exceptional-Paten... Intentionally threatening clearly bullshit infringement claims is going to be clamped down on.
- josaka 12y agoThese stats do not reflect the effect of recent changes in the law. Money being awarded now is from lawsuits launched at least one or two years ago. New case filings are down 40% year-over-year[1], and anecdotally, we're hearing that many troll-friendly firms are severely curtailing their new filings due to new procedures at the US Patent Office to attack patents in parallel early in a litigation [2]. [1] See for drop in filings, http://www.iam-magazine.com/blog/Detail.aspx?g=dadf4dce-0f75-45dc-9339-dacb0f7bb465 http://www.iam-magazine.com/blog/Detail.aspx?g=dadf4dce-0f75... [2] See for stats on IPR: http://www.insidecounsel.com/2014/03/19/patent-owners-beware-your-patent-has-a-15-percent http://www.insidecounsel.com/2014/03/19/patent-owners-beware...