4 ms·
I don't get why you haven't been downvoted to hell yet: removing people from their positions for the views they hold is _unamerican_. As an entirely aside if h
by tomjen3 12y ago
I don't get why you haven't been downvoted to hell yet: removing people from their positions for the views they hold is _unamerican_.
As an entirely aside if he identified a few real spies and missed hundreds doesn't that suggest he was ineffective, to the point of actual harm?
- dalke 12y agoI would qualify that to allow certain bona fide exceptions. If a nuclear missile launch team has the position that nuclear weapons are unjustified and that pacifistic solutions are the only correct solution to national disagreements, then I think it's okay to remove them from their position, even if they've never acted on their views by not launching when the launch order came.
- aurelian 12y agoRemoving enemy agents from positions is not unAmerican. Removing people with known security risks from sensitive positions is not unAmerican. He missed hundreds of agents, identified several agents and many more security risks, and spurred heightened security awareness that was a very good thing at the time. Expecting him to know the identity of every Soviet agent before attempting to remove any security risks is unreasonable.
- smutticus 12y agoJust because some members of the American Communist party were working for the Soviets, does not mean that every member was. Guilt by association is generally not a crime under common law. I don't know what 'unamerican' means, I know how it was used, but I don't think anyone really knows what it means. Therefore I'm bringing up common law. Whether something is unamerican or not is irrelevant. We're supposed to live in a nation of laws, not arbitrary standards.
- SamReidHughes 12y agoWe're talking about security risks, not guilt.
- jjoonathan 12y agoA potential spy does (potentially) subvert democracy. But removing an elected official from office definitely subverts democracy. You need to be pretty darn certain of the former before the latter becomes the lesser of two evils. Assuming my numbers are correct, "security risk" is far too poor of a standard to decide in favor of removal from office. On the other hand, it sure is a handy standard if your actual goal is to remove your opponents from office...
- SamReidHughes 12y agoWhat elected officials are you talking about?
- dalke 12y agoConsider Victor Berger, elected as a Representative from Wisconsin in 1918. The House refused to let him serve, since he was a convicted felon (he violated the horrid Espionage Act) and war opponent. This was justified by Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment: > No person shall be a Senator or Representative in Congress, or elector of President and Vice President, or hold any office, civil or military, under the United States, or under any State, who, having previously taken an oath, as a member of Congress, or as an officer of the United States, or as a member of any State legislature, or as an executive or judicial officer of any State, to support the Constitution of the United States, shall have engaged in insurrection or rebellion against the same, or given aid or comfort to the enemies thereof. Following the logic that birthed the foul Espionage Act, "not wanting to go to war" = "aiding the enemy", hence Berger wasn't seated in 1919 nor, after rewinning the election, in 1920. He was a Socialist, not a Communist. Not that it really matters; an anti-war Communist would have had no better chance. That said, I'm as confused as you about jjoonathan' comment, as removing (or at least preventing) elected officials from holding office was at best a contingency plan during the Red Scares.
- jjoonathan 12y agoYou make it sound like we're talking about a few false positives and a few false negatives. >94% false positive rate (9/159) >95% false negative rate ((200-9)/200) If it's unreasonable to call this a shit screening process, what would you consider reasonable?! In any case, it seems virtually certain that McCarthy's accusations were far more effective as political tools rather than as filters against soviet subversion, in accordance with the traditional narrative.
- SamReidHughes 12y ago> removing people from their positions for the views they hold is _unamerican_. If you're going to argue about a hiring preference being "unamerican" or not instead of its inherent morality, I don't know what game you're playing. Did you get your posting techniques from the Simple Sabotage Field Manual?