5 ms·
According to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_McCarthy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_McCarthy > historian John Earl Haynes concluded that, of 159 peo
by jjoonathan 12y ago
According to
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_McCarthy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_McCarthy
> historian John Earl Haynes concluded that, of 159 people identified on lists used or referenced by McCarthy, evidence was substantial that nine had aided Soviet espionage efforts.
9/159. A 94% false positive rate.
- aurelian 12y agoWhy don't you quote the next sentence? "He suggested that a majority of those on the lists could legitimately have been considered security risks, but that a substantial minority could not."
- jjoonathan 12y agoBecause it's nearly tautological: everyone on that list got there for some reason. The fact that a majority of those reasons weren't entirely made up isn't an indication of their quality as predictors of espionage. Since we now have access to the ground truth we can compute the actual false positive rate. The great-grandparent post suggests that such an examination would vindicate McCarthy, but I have trouble sympathizing with this view. A 94% false-positive rate (96% if you use McCarthy's original figure) is bad no matter how you slice it.
- aurelian 12y agoMcCarthy identified several agents actively engaged in espionage. KGB records identify hundreds more that he missed. McCarthy identified many more people in sensitive positions who were security risks, many with Communist associations. Even if those people were not actively engaged in espionage, they should not have held sensitive positions. KGB/NKVD archives reveal they had hundreds of agents in the executive branch in the 1940s. McCarthy spurred the removal of Soviet moles, Communist sympathizers, and other security risks from sensitive positions. In this, he did the US a great service, as regrettable as false accusations are. Edit: In response to your questions, it's as if you didn't read what I just wrote. Regarding the Soviet records of infiltration, several books have been written on these records and their revelations.
- cafard 12y agoMcCarthy was a showman, not a serious investigator. In the long run, he did more harm to the cause he nominally worked for.
- jjoonathan 12y agoI have zero sympathy for the view that people who disagree with current social/economic/espionage policy should be removed from office on that basis alone. On the contrary, such disagreement is central to how democracy works and those who would threaten it are the true threats to our society. That said, we continue to disagree about the numbers, and I would like to know the resolution. Could you expand on your claim that "KGB/NKVD archives reveal they had hundreds of agents in the executive branch in the 1940s"? Did McCarthy have a very high false negative rate (thereby finding only 9 of the hundreds of spies)? Are you counting "security risks" as "agents"? What gives?
- A_COMPUTER 12y ago>I have zero sympathy for the view that people who disagree with current social/economic/espionage policy should be removed from office on that basis alone. Why? They'll just do a shitty job anyway. People rightfully get up in arms when Republicans want to see an opponent of the EPA appointed to the EPA, or department of education, because they know why it's being done, to undermine it. HUAC was set up to rout out Nazi sympathizers before it started going after communism, should they have been left alone?
- aurelian 12y agoCommunists, meaning people who were members of the Communist Party or identified as Communists and associated with other Communists, were more likely to have come into contact with Soviet agents and been persuaded to spy or subvert US aims. We are talking about security risks not security certainties. It's entirely reasonable to remove risky people from sensitive positions. Any organization that failed to do so would fail to achieve the objectives given to it through the democratic process; it would serve another master. This is entirely separate from the question of who should choose the objectives of the government. Ironically, Communists wished to overthrow the US government and were anti-democratic.
- saalweachter 12y agoYou know, the problem with lists like this is that, once you've made the list, any organization with a cover-your-ass mentality (eg, every organization) is going to treat it as sacrosanct. Regardless of how flimsy the list was to start with, no amount of evidence can ever clear someone well enough. The risk isn't "chance of being wrong * real-world consequences of being wrong", it's "chance of being wrong * (real-world consequences of being wrong + career consequences of 'letting the guy on the known-threat list slip through')". The career consequences have infinite weight, so the chance of being wrong can never be low enough.