3 ms·
It looks like this ticket was opened a year ago, during which almost no discussion took place. People only started to voice objections after the patch was alrea
by xg15 12y ago
It looks like this ticket was opened a year ago, during which almost no discussion took place. People only started to voice objections after the patch was already written and submitted.
I think it would be useful if tickets with breaking changes could come to the public's attention a bit earlier than this time.
I have no idea how to find such tickets of course. The search function of the issue tracker doesn't seem very helpful...
- Intermernet 12y agoVery good point. It seems that this was tagged "Type-Feature" which is meant to mean "Request for new or improved features". I'm not sure how removing functionality is a "new or improved" feature, except from the developers POV due to reduced complexity. This is probably not how the users would define "new or improved". They possibly need a new tag for "Type-FeatureRemoval" or similar.
- zorbo 12y ago> I think it would be useful if tickets with breaking changes could come to the public's attention a bit earlier than this time. Given the reactions here and at the bug tracker, I don't think that would be a very good idea. People are having knee-jerk reactions without apparently even having read the first few comments. If the Hacker News crowd can't be arsed to understand what's going on, then the last thing you want is "the public's attention" on the decision making process.