3 ms·
I agree with lambda that it is probably the patent clause. Suppose I'm distributing GPLv3 software as part of my commercial product. I'm fully complying with G
by tzs 12y ago
I agree with lambda that it is probably the patent clause.
Suppose I'm distributing GPLv3 software as part of my commercial product. I'm fully complying with GPLv3.
Some third party comes along who is in the business of distributing software, and tells me that they have a patent covering the GPLv3 software I'm distributing.
They want me to buy a license for their patent for $1/copy sold of my commercial product. This license would cover the use of the GPLv3 software in that copy of my product. It would not cover copies or derivative works made from those copies.
GPLv3 says that I must reject this licensing deal. I can only accept a licensing deal that results in all of the copies and derivative works made from those copies or their down streams and so on receiving patent licenses.
If I cannot arrange for this open ended licensing, I have to either stop distributing the GPLv3 code, or I'll have to try to defeat the patent.
No way am I going to distribute GPLv3 code as an essential part of my product with that "all or nothing" patent licensing restriction hanging over it.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoDistributing something under GPLv2 (or for that matter the BSD license) allows the licensee to make an unlimited number of copies. You can't comply with the GPLv2 without authorizing an unlimited number of copies. Licensing an unlimited number of copies while only paying for a patent license for one is just begging for a lawsuit by the patent holder, your customers, or both. It also has the strong potential to make your partners and customers Displeased. It seems very strange to have such a strong desire to be able to do something which seems like such a bad idea. And, all of the other people distributing the GPL software will be in the same boat, so the sensible thing to do in any event is to get together with them and buy or challenge the patent. Or modify the software so that it doesn't infringe.