3 ms·
Soundbites like "Stop charging for mass transit" unfairly ignore the complexity of the issue at hand. In Sydney, IPART (Independant Pricing and Regulatory Trib
by madeofpalk 12y ago
Soundbites like "Stop charging for mass transit" unfairly ignore the complexity of the issue at hand.
In Sydney, IPART (Independant Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal) recently reported that revenue from Sydney's public transport captures about 30% of the cost associated with running it.
The determined that it doesn't make sense to make PT free (fully subsidised by tax) because public transport is doesn't provide significantly enough value for all tax payers.
http://www.ipart.nsw.gov.au/Home/Industries/Transport/Reviews/External_Benefits_of_Public_Transport/26_Aug_2014_-_Media_Release/Media_Release_-_Estimating_the_wider_benefits_of_public_transport_-_26_August_2014 http://www.ipart.nsw.gov.au/Home/Industries/Transport/Review...
- specialist 12y agoAll transportation is subsidized. Except maybe my morning trot from my bed to the bathroom. The argument for eliminating fares is that the revenue more or less covers the cost of administration. Also, for future, distinguish between capital and operating expenses.
- madeofpalk 12y agoThe argument against eliminating fares (at least in Sydney) is that the added costs would vastly outweigh any benefits of a small number of people getting free transport. That's also ignoring the different ways people would use public transport (and non-public transport) if it were free.
- Retric 12y agoThe more people using public transit the less congested the roads become which is a huge benifit.
- CamperBob2 12y agoThat does not necessarily follow. If you offer free mass transit, the people who take advantage of it may not be the same people who would otherwise be clogging up the roads in their personal cars.
- Retric 12y agoIt does not need to be a 1:1 relationship for my statement to be true. If every 10 rides reduces 1 car trip it's still reducing congestion. The important thing to remember about congestion is at maximum capacity new trips simply increase wait times so a 30 min trip can add more than 30 minutes of wait time spread among all drivers. And removing a 30 minute trip can save people more than 30 minutes of wait time. Granted as delays reduce people my decide to simply take more trips, but a combination of a car congestion tax, free public transit, and walk-able / bike-able city's are far more efficient say trying to stack highways.
- madeofpalk 12y agoI understand this, but it wouldn't be that simple. The more people using PT, the greater the operating and capital expenses are
- chetanahuja 12y agoJust like it doesn't make sense to build expensive, high maintenance highways, largely at public expense to subsidize driving. But that's exactly what's been happening in large parts of the world (led by the US example) for the past 50 years or so..