5 ms·
You summarized already in your sentences ("I'm bewildered by this article. It seems really damaging, and like it doesn't really add very much to the corpus they
by acqq 12y ago
You summarized already in your sentences ("I'm bewildered by this article. It seems really damaging, and like it doesn't really add very much to the corpus they've already published") how you feel and why you feel that way: it appears damaging because it contains the paragraphs that explicitly contain the words "it's damaging." But it's just a general introduction to the "juicy bits" without the bits themselves.
In fact you recognized this too writing: "it doesn't really add very much to the corpus they've already published." Once you attempt to identify the new information, you can recognize that 99.5% of it appeared in some other form before.
The older published documents already were marked "top secret." This markings are given to the content that is considered "damaging" by these who write the documents. You just percieved it differently because these markings were just markings for you, not the sentences spelling out "damaging."
Still, the value to the public of this very document is that it's a single document summarizing nicely the previously disclosed ones in much less words. By its nature though it doesn't contain the details published previously. (Edit: technically, it's a set of the documents but all of them together appear to me just as a big table of contents for the disclosures already published.)
Now let's discuss the new 0.5% of information, even if it's very general.
- xnull2guest 12y agoTo clarify I mean that I don't believe it adds much to the corpus of information about domestic and civil rights infractions. On the other hand it deals a pretty big blow geopolitically/internationally. The big deal about this article is that it reveals the major tactical capabilities and efforts the NSA has invested in the intelligence war. Edit: Right now HN is limiting the number of replies I can initiate. Will reply as I can.
- acqq 12y ago> The big deal about this article is that it reveals the major tactical capabilities and efforts the NSA has invested in the intelligence war. It does? What is actually new and specific I fail to see. But it's a really, really nice summary.
- xnull2guest 12y agoSENTRY EAGLE and the 13 page draft (summarized in the article) is new. SENTRY EAGLE is the protection program outlined jointly by the NSA and the U.S. Strategic Command. The first line reads: "SENTRY EAGLE... compartmented program protecting the highest and most sensitive level [by] NSA/JFCC to support the U.S. government's efforts to protect America's cyberspace." https://firstlook.org/theintercept/document/2014/10/10/national-initiative-protection-program-sentry-eagle/ https://firstlook.org/theintercept/document/2014/10/10/natio... The document goes on to specify the broad U.S. cyber protection strategy broken down into Sentry Hawk, Sentry Falcon, Sentry Osprey, Sentry Raven, Sentry Condor, and Sentry Owl - all of which are new. Add on top data about infiltration into (allied) South Korea and Germany. Not a good day for the NSA.
- acqq 12y agoThe names are certainly new, but AFAIK the names themselves aren't classified. What's behind the names is classified, but more details about such actions were already published. We just learn more names, that is, how they call these actions internally. And we get a nice summary of the previous disclosures. Written by the authorities who otherwise denied the parts of it even as the specific documents were published. It's that everything is written together that's new. The new potential to embarrasment of the officials is in having it all in one document, which makes the denials much harder.
- xnull2guest 12y agoIt's like seeing certain plays from a sport team before, and then after a game seeing their notebook with their general game strategy. Yeah everything we saw before 'fits in' to what was released today - for example we already knew from examples that the NSA works to break encryption - but now we also know that it is considered one of six key investments and that it probably has its own leadership separate from the others. This is useful because you know what programs have more overhead talking to each other/partnering. For example to speculate that corporations probably aren't helping very much with the crypto breaking effort. (The names are most definitely classified.)
- Tomte 12y ago> To clarify I mean that I don't believe it adds much to the corpus of information about domestic and civil rights infractions. As a foreigner, I'm actually more interested in non-domestic stuff.
- hueving 12y agoOf course, but to be honest, that was the previous expectation of the NSA. It's not that apparent that there is anything useful to gain by leaking their attempts to spy on foreign counties like every other country does.
- belorn 12y agoSince when is sabotage an act of spying, or for that matter acceptable behavior in peace time? Lets say Swedish spies was sent to the US in order to infiltrate and weaken the 911 system, the power grid, or other key infrastructures of the US. Would you shrug at that also, since after all, what should people expect from spies? Sabotage and spying is two different activities. Sabotage is a tactic employed during war. Spying is a tactic employed during peace. Confusing the two simply states that peace is war, and war is peace, and anything goes so long its against foreigners.
- coldtea 12y ago>On the other hand it deals a pretty big blow geopolitically/internationally. So? For me (Godwin's law be damned) it's like leaked documents about Nazi germany practices. If you were not a German you'd cheer, and if you were a non-Nazi German you'd also cheer.