4 ms·
Shouldn't evidence be inadmissible based on how it was obtained? An illegal search is an illegal search regardless of what was searched or who owns it. I'm not
by phkahler 12y ago
Shouldn't evidence be inadmissible based on how it was obtained? An illegal search is an illegal search regardless of what was searched or who owns it.
I'm not a fan of the defendant here, but I am a fan of holding the authorities to the rules. You know it's their job to uphold the law.
- forgottenpass 12y agoThat's just the way it works. I agree with you, but the courts don't.
- dietrichepp 12y ago> I'm not a fan of the defendant here, but I am a fan of holding the authorities to the rules. You know it's their job to uphold the law. Yes, evidence is inadmissible based on how it is obtained. However, there are rules and procedures for how you get evidence excluded from a trial. This is why you pay good money for good lawyers: they know the rules for excluding evidence. I recommend watching the 1992 moive "My Cousin Vinny".
- munchbunny 12y agoThe unfortunate part of all of this is that we're now in a system where you win by paying more money to cover more technicalities than the other guy. Sure, this follows the rules, but it seems perverse to lose on a technicality that is easy to resolve with a "hey, prove you own the server. you did? ok."
- anigbrowl 12y agoBut the thing is the judge gave them exactly that option and Ulbricht's lawyer inexplicably declined to take it - see page 22 onwards. So either a) Ulbright can't prove he owns the server (in which case he can't very well claim privacy rights in something that's not his property to start with), or b) he is not willing to, even though doing so might keep most of the evidence out of trial. Maybe that's because of some super-clever legal tactic they plan to unveil at appeal (although this seems very unlikely, as this is such a basic procedural issue) or maybe it's for some extrajudicial reason, like because it would reveal the identity of some partner in crime who would then seek terrible revenge. Or any other number of other possibilities.
- nitrogen 12y agoShouldn't the government's claim that the server was owned by Ulbright effectively concede the point?
- anigbrowl 12y agoI don't know, but I think Ulbricht would need to concede that explictly. I don't feel like digging through all the filings to try and figure out his counsel's strategy at this hour, though.
- TehCorwiz 12y agoYour typo fits the Pesci's accent.
- jMyles 12y ago> I'm not a fan of the defendant here I want to suggest that this phrase is potentially toxic. Ross's name has been horribly tarnished, not unlike aaronsw before him. I, for one, think that the evidence suggests he's a pretty good dude. I have seen nothing that makes me believe there is any truth to the arranged murder allegations. Also, having met and spent half a day in his mother's company, I can tell you that she is a warm, concerned soul and I got the distinct sense that she was telling the truth about this whole thing.
- nemo 12y agoPutting aside the accusation that he tried to put a hit on someone, do you think he's innocent person and wasn't running the Silk Road, or that he was a nice guy who just happened to be flagrantly flouting the law in running an illicit marketplace for drugs, kiddie porn, stolen credit cards, and other illicit goods and services, while engaged in a money laundering scheme? I am genuinely wondering here.
- jMyles 12y agoIf the accusations about him running the Silk Road are true, I think two things: 1) The technology and political material he published as DPR is compelling, interesting, and worth reading. This contribution is meaningful. 2) That there is nothing inherently criminal or morally reprehensible about allowing people to freely transact with one another. ...but that's not the point I was making. The point I was making was that any time the government targets somebody, we find ourselves saying, "I don't want to defend <x>, but I will say..." But why not? Especially with aaronsw. I find it shocking that this phrase was suddenly through around so often after the indictments. We all knew what he was doing. I supported him 100% and do not believe he did anything wrong. At the end of the day, we have to be willing to defend not only each other's speech and actions, but each other's characters if in fact they're worth defending. I think aaronsw and DPR are characters that are worth defending.
- nemo 12y agoWhile I have a lot of sympathy for aaronsw, and admired a lot of the work he did, I don't see a lot in common between the two. The Feds. charged both, but the thing is that the charges brought against aaronsw were largely absurd. He appeared to have broken a few misdemeanor-class laws, but was charged with wire fraud and the CFAA in ways that didn't really fit what he did at all. The Feds. are charging Ulricht with things that he mostly was personally responsible for. He very much appeared to be engaged in narcotics trafficking conspiracy, continuing criminal enterprise, computer hacking conspiracy, and money laundering conspiracy. He set up an environment where people can freely transact with one another, but tailored that environment to narcotics trafficking, credit card fraud, selling malware, and money laundering, and chose to engage in tailoring the site specifically for those things. He was fully aware of the illegal transactions occurring through his site and not only did nothing to stop it, but enabled it and profited from it. He was also hit with a Kingpin charge that probably will stick, since he was personally involved and managed an organized crime scheme. The Silk Road designed a site for drug trafficking and other illicit activities, recruited drug and encouraged dealers, and took a commission from the sales. Since the Feds. have the server they have a sea of evidence to show how the site wasn't running with no knowledge of what transactions were happening, but tailored itself to be effective at drug, CC, and malware trafficking. Whatever you think morally about profiting off drug deals, malware sales, CC fraud, and money laundering, the law is really clear about it. aaronsw was engaged in a kind of hacktivism that expanded open access to public information and contributed to the open web in many ways. Ulricht was engaged in making a profit by opening a marketplace for illegal activities and tailoring it for drug deals. There's a world of difference.
- anigbrowl 12y agoYour understanding of the rules is in error, though. And in this case, the court has never got to the question of whether the search was illegal, because the defendant's motion to suppress is not well-formed (despite the court providing the defense with an opportunity to correct that). Courts don't have much initiative in our common-law system, constitutionally speaking their function is to resolve disputes between parties, meaning the onus is on the defense to make the argument about the illegality of the search warrant and to do so in correct legal form.