4 ms·
I think there's a great point inside your comment, but that the way you have expressed it is unkindly biased against those on what I surmise to be the opposite
by sanderjd 12y ago
I think there's a great point inside your comment, but that the way you have expressed it is unkindly biased against those on what I surmise to be the opposite of your side of the debate.
When describing the first group, you use lots of seemingly negative descriptions: "rule-oriented and binary", "quickly seizes on any violation", "extends that into a personal judgment", "express their judgments harshly", and "that acid".
When describing the other group you use lots of positive language: "pluck and self-motivation", "admire the ingenuity", "generally more indulgent", and "relentlessly resourceful". Plus there is an appeal to PG's authority on this site.
There are positive and negative aspects of both sides here, and I think you're being pretty harsh toward one of the factions.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Retric 12y agoI understand his stance, but I don't think the point really stand up. Articles about SPAM can be engaging. But, that hardly means people support the activity. IMO, duping in online games is the same basic thing as it's a classic free rider problem. People are not going to buy duped items in a single player game it's only the 'non' duping players that make item duping a profitable activity and their game play is harmed by it. Performance enhancing drugs fall into the same category. The methods/chemistry might be interesting, but clearly 'clean' athletes (and arguably the fans) are harmed by the activity. PS: Or can you actually see a benefit from doping that I am missing?
- dang 12y agoTo my mind the issue isn't whether the game cheating business was good, but whether its badness deserves to overwhelm everything else about the story.
- wpietri 12y agoI think the problem isn't entirely the badness, but that the author seems so oblivious to it despite its pervasiveness in the piece. If the guy had said early on, "Ok, now I realize that part of my problem is that my business was essentially parasitical, and I'm trying to learn from that" I would have been able to read the rest of the article with more equanimity. I really do admire his pluck, and for his age he is learning a lot of hard lessons. But reading this reminded me of watching a horror movie where some goof obliviously walks along with the serial killer right behind them. You just want to shout, "TURN AROUND! LOOK BEHIND YOU!" So I'm not shocked that commenters have to get that off their chests before they can process the rest of it. It also reminds me of the conversations I had in the mid-1990s with spammers, because back then you could actually track 'em down and get 'em on the phone. They had this same inability to see that they were their own worst enemy. They saw problems on all sides and thought the world was against them. But really, the common factor in the problems was them. It is for all of us, of course. But it can be hard to watch others struggle with that.
- dang 12y agoYou're right: I'm biased on this one [1], it affects the words I use, and (most interestingly to me, because I didn't notice it until later), my comment contained some of the quality it was criticizing. If you or anyone wants to write a fairer description, I'd read it with interest. On sunny days I imagine a community in which people would figure these things out together and communication would level up as a result. 1. Originally I wrote that I was a "card-carrying member of the second group", but edited that out after imagining someone taking the joke literally.