3 ms·
> It is an army, a cult, a family. As an outsider, this make Y Combinator seem more creepy to me than welcoming. (especially the bold bullet-point list of what
by minimaxir 12y ago
> It is an army, a cult, a family.
As an outsider, this make Y Combinator seem more creepy to me than welcoming. (especially the bold bullet-point list of what the YC partners do)
The problem with this "cult of personality" is that it takes away from the product. While well-written, the article was more about "How do I please the YC partners?" instead of "How do I make Shout the best it can be?"
- emmett 12y agoI think the point of the article was the opposite. The first two times they applied, they were focused on YC. The third time (the time they got in), he says: "Nothing else mattered, including YC. Application time came around and we thought about not applying. It seems a bit silly to say now (to us), but it is true." They'd become focused on the business and product, and that was the key.
- jaoued 12y agoI would disagree as well. I read the story of two young co-founders managing & learning through their failures of applying to YC & eventually getting thru, made them stronger, and building some solid foundations for working again together in the future. When the going gets tough...
- iillmaticc 12y agoLol not everything is a white paper. This was simply a "don't give up" story that I think MOST of us found encouraging. But everyone's allowed to be a critic I guess.
- 7Figures2Commas 12y agoI think that sentence was a poor addition, but my impression of Y Combinator from the author's entire post was that the author most highly valued the social experience ("It reminded me of my first night at Columbia. My new friends and I sat on the hall in our dorm and talked. As we shared our first night exchanging childhood stories..."), which seemed to take on metaphysical properties ("we were somewhere truly special"). For all of the exuberance about the experience, however, I found a stark contrast in the final sentence of the post: > We aren’t sure where things will go from here. Shout may or may not succeed. But I know Henri and I feel fortunate to be a part of YC. Obviously, new business ventures always face a level of uncertainty, and the risk of failure should be acknowledged. But it's kind of strange that the author seems so detached from the success or failure of the business and so resigned to going wherever the world takes his business. In short, it reads like the author was a lot more determined to get into YC than he is to take the bull by the horns and try to make his app a success now that school's out.
- hstern 12y agoWe realize that uncertainty exists but we are hardly detached from it. Our every waking hour is spent fighting it, in fact. I reckon the point was rather that in spite of that uncertainty, the experience, for us, had intrinsic value. We also believe our experience leads us to a better Shout! School isn't out, it's just begun!