3 ms·
I read an article once that said that when suicide was illegal in the UK, the rate was a lot lower. I'm not sure if that was true or not, but as a thought expe
by gadders 12y ago
I read an article once that said that when suicide was illegal in the UK, the rate was a lot lower.
I'm not sure if that was true or not, but as a thought experiment: if making suicide illegal lowered it's occurrance, would you support that?
- alex_hitchins 12y agoI believe when it was illegal here in the UK, coroners would look for ways to record the death in more favourable ways (mostly for the family). So an overdose would be recorded as death by misadventure and not suicide.
- raverbashing 12y agoExactly this This type of law is only good to make people misreport things. Accidents/Misadventures/Suspected murder etc
- ninguem2 12y agoIt is a terrible idea. What are the consequences? Punishment for those who attempt and fail or punishment for the families of those who succeed by denying them life insurance, proper burial and so on.
- gadders 12y agoI think people who tried and failed may have been punished. AFAIK, life insurance has never paid out for suicide and doesn't now.
- pravda 12y ago>life insurance has never paid out for suicide and doesn't now. In the USA, life insurance does cover suicide, as long as it is not within 2 years of the issue date.
- npizzolato 12y agoI don't know how you would possibly go about making suicide illegal, but punishing those left behind sounds like the worst possible "solution" to suicide.
- glandium 12y agoI don't know if all countries that had such a law removed it, but in some countries, attempted suicide was a crime punished by death penalty.