6 ms·
Ubisoft's Game Developer 'Limbo'
- dang 12y agoUrl changed from http://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/227464/New_report_looks_inside_Ubisofts_littleknown_interproject.php http://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/227464/New_report_looks_i..., which points to this.
- bmh100 12y agoThis was an appropriate exercise in link replacement. The original post adds little to the original content, basically summarizing it.
- Mithaldu 12y agoI don't really understand the negativity. You get paid to spend your time: 1. finding work inside ubisoft 2. finding work outside ubisoft 3. improving your skills on your own 4. work on projects you didn't have time for while in perpetual crunch on a ubisoft project The alternative is to be let go immediately and do all of the above on government aid (if your location even has that). Am i missing something or are the negative voices mentioned in the article just people who don't deal well under self-direction?
- antimagic 12y agoYeah, I'm right there with you. What an opportunity! You're sitting in an office, surrounded by a bunch of other game developers / designers with nothing to do. How are they not churning out indie-style games by the dozen??? The description of "interproject" sounds like my dream job (well, apart from the lighting). Anyone that finds themselves in that position, and then wastng it by doing nothing, well, those people would by high on my list for firing if I was management of Ubisoft. Maybe that's the point, maybe this is a test to see if they actually want to retain the employee or not. You would have to suspect that the people that find themselves in interproject are already not the best performers, who would have already been poached to participate on other projects, so this is a way of winnowing the herd a bit maybe?
- pjmlp 12y ago> How are they not churning out indie-style games by the dozen??? Work contract?
- mrpollo 12y agoI think he meant developing/prototyping ideas not actually releasing them
- antimagic 12y agoShe meant developing indie games for Ubisoft. Surely they should be able to come up with a few that would be good enough to become actual products...
- pjmlp 12y agoAh ok, then I fully agree with you.
- unwind 12y agoIsn't that a contradiction? If they're a bunch of professional game developers sitting in an office run by one of the industry's most famous developers/publishers and developing games, then how can they be said to be doing "independent" games? From my experience of the game industry, it would be quite hard to do something that very much looks like a game project at a place like that, without also involving the normal planning/financing/sales/marketing requirements. If it looks like a game project, in those circles it's probably going to be a game project, and there are rules for those. Just my thoughts.
- antimagic 12y agoWhich would be why, in my original post, I used the phrase "indie-style"...
- wingerlang 12y ago> .. then how can they be said to be doing "independent" games? They would still be doing the game/prototype independently from the company. There would be no difference in the making of the game from an "actual" indie dev. Now for the IP, legal things surrounding it that's a different question.
- erikb 12y agoI can understand where the negativity comes from, as can anybody else who was without work for some months or maybe even years. You are absolutely correct that there are a lot of opportunities in that kind of department, though. People who use them are probably the kind of people who find another project within weeks.
- csallen 12y agoFrom the article: >> Programmers and project managers, for example, are often high in demand within the studio, and if they're sent to interproject, they could wind up leaving after just a few weeks. ... But other employees said they spent months and months in interproject, unsuccessfully looking for new gigs within the company, before they were finally let go. I suspect there's a lot of overlap between the types of people who see free time as a productive opportunity and the people who are valuable enough to get snapped back up quickly and vice versa.
- raverbashing 12y agoBe very careful with n.4 though
- watwut 12y agoExactly. Having few weeks you can spend learning about technologies you had no time for while at project and catching up the news is beneficial thing. I would consider it a perk. Too much time in limbo would be bad thing, just like unemployment. However, paid limbo while you can look for job still beats being really unemployed, so again, perk.
- akavel 12y agoFrom being in partially similar (although not exactly same) situation (kinda "on the bench" as described in other comments, or kinda "interproject nothing to do"), I'll try to list some disadvantages I noticed (they surprised me somewhat too): - it's hard to invest all your self into a "new project prototype"/"quick indie game"/... because: you totally don't know how much time you have (1 day? half year?) till you're "hired back"/"given new work"; and also there's huge probability the corporation will totally ignore your result however awesome it is, and at the same time you can't legally take it away and reanimate on your own because it's company property (done on company time). So, there's a strong feeling you might pour lots of hard work into project doomed to stupid failure and done on totally unpredictable schedule. - you start to have feelings of "I'm worthless -- nobody needs me" -- because that's actually the truth: nobody needs you (at this moment - but maybe longer? maybe that's an allusion?). Also, in consequence, you start to lose confidence and trust to others: you were so strongly needed just days before (in the intensive project while you were "fully hired"), but then they threw you away so quickly and lightly... so were they lying from the beginning and did never really need you? or maybe you only thought you are good but are poor and they were relieved to get rid of you? think, why did they choose to get rid of you, not this other guy? also, why they didn't tell you anything straight in your face? And then after all of this, when living in this official "limbo", you're 100% surrounded by a band of similar "pseudo-loosers-maybe-not-really-but-often-feeling-so", many of whom feel similarly, resulting in a self-reinforcing echo chamber... (not to say the article notes that the building itself is already depressing...) - A side note, for a partially different situation: (warning: stream of consciousness coming; sorry, don't have this analyzed well yet): when you're in an unofficial "interproject nothing to do", there are also two additional problems: one is, that it's unofficial; officially the company and manager expect you To Do Something, but they don't have time to give you something concrete, or give you crap looking totally like "nobody really needs it, but you'll have something to do". The second one is, that your schedule is even more unpredictable, because however long it spans eventually (even more than half a year), every minute you know they might just come and give you some serious work (fresh bug, or some longer project) and dump whatever "prototype" you were doing immediately. Finally, now I realized your prioritization also gets partially botched, because whatever crappy work you were given as "important" before, something slightly more important may come and show that the previous thing was in fact just pseudo-important. That said, you can try to fight to retain consciousness and self-confidence, but it is really not trivial, and there are ways in which this situation can be depressing. Not to say it's 100% so (for some time this can feel like vacation, opportunities for learning, etc, etc), but the advantages were already listed in other comments, so I wanted to just show the disadvantages here. And just to make it clear, regarding suggestion of "people who don't deal well under self-direction", I totally can, have loads of free-time hobby projects and entertainments (i.e. out of work), managed to have some of them published and open sourced, also did some freelancing gigs. So, for me this argument seems totally irrelevant. edit: also, what started to interest me now, after reading the article and putting down my thoughts, that I don't really know, and am very curious, how this situation could be improved? because I believe its existence is rather unavoidable; I suppose in every one programming job there are more or less explicit interproject periods. (Or aren't they?) edit2: I mean, improved by the management guys / boss / company owner.
- tempVariable 12y agoI don't want to repeat what other already have said, so here's another point: this 'opportunity' is about 40% sponsored by corporate government aid. I know first hand from a person who is going to Quebec next month as a 'digital artist' to work on a great project and he is fully aware that the company will receive about 40% of his salary back from citizens of Quebec and Canada. That 'career vector limbo' is more of an anomaly corporate credit conditions that are very favorable in that region. It distorts market salary conditions so much so that they are willing to poach other bodies to ship them to Quebec. I am not surprised at all to see this story posted.
- bmh100 12y agoIt is great that Ubisoft is retaining its employees this way. What is unfortunate is the wasted potential. Hundreds of talented employees sitting around with no management deadlines? This the perfect opportunity to create an internal innovation lab, with employees creating small experiments ("projects"). At a minimum, it hones skills and encourages collaboration between former members of different teams. In the best case scenario, new profitable games are invented. Eric Ries would have a lot to say about this.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoYou've got these employees who have been working 80 hours a week in a big company, where they're told exactly what to do. Then suddenly you essentially tell them: go make some cool stuff, or you'll probably be fired. Nobody's going to tell you what that cool stuff is, though; figure it out yourself. Some people will thrive in that environment. But for most, it's just going to ratchet up the stress, especially since they're coming in burnt-out. Most working for a big company do it because they work better in an environment where they're told what to do. The path to success is crystal clear. IMO, interproject should be all about burn-out prevention. The job path for video game developers is fairly standard. You spend your 20s developing video games, and then you get married and get a real job: twice the pay, half the hours. Interproject could keep those employees in Ubisoft rather than forcing them out. P.S. By married, I mean "mortgage and a baby". Very few people in Quebec actually get married.
- Fuzzwah 12y ago> Very few people in Quebec actually get married. I'm interested in this line. I take it there is a cultural reason for this?
- srgpqt 12y agoVery high divorce rate and overall fading religious beliefs. Only benefit to marriage is income tax relief for stay-at-home moms/dads.
- bryanlarsen 12y ago
- jpatte 12y agoSeems like Ubisoft is managing their employees just like every French consulting company is managing its consultants between projects. Why is it considered unorthodox? Is it because Ubisoft is a game editor and other editors never do that, or because they host their own projects with their own schedules, and therefore should be somewhat able to better reallocate their workforce?
- eloisant 12y agoProbably because the way French consulting companies manage their employees is awful. They're a reason they're called "meat sellers".
- raverbashing 12y agoYES Thanks to French Labour Laws, nobody hires anymore, except those consulting companies.
- S4M 12y agoThat's actually true and some big companies employ consultants from those consulting firms for couple of years - costing much more than a permanent or even contract employee would.
- yardie 12y agoSo let me get this straight. You work on a project that may require up to 80hours/week for weeks and months at a time. And then at the end instead of massive layoffs, as game companies are known to do, they send you to an office to wind down, spaz out, and recharge. This I don't mind. Sounds better than the emotional rollercoaster of working hard and layoffs. Also, the Japanese were doing this for a long time. Salarymen, between projects, regularly came into work and did nothing all day. Eventually when a new division started you had a viable pool of candidates.
- mkohlmyr 12y agoSeems to me if Ubisoft had half a brain they would turn this in to a 20% time of sorts. A bunch of talented game developers we already pay wages have a few months off? What if.. gasp.. We let them make games? Any games. There's literally nothing whatsoever to lose. Worst case scenario your employees do something they enjoy for a while.
- raverbashing 12y agoI thought about this, but you know why this doesn't happen? I don't get the motivation at working at Ubisoft. They're about blockbusters, about series, etc Sure, Assassin's Creed is very interesting, but it's more of a movie production than a game. Looks like you would get a lot of crunch time and work on very hard things for a (slight) financial gain and your name on the credits.
- illumen 12y agoThe bench. That's what it's called at some companies. I've seen it at maybe seven companies. Not every place I've been at, but a good portion. Agencies, or studios where project work is common. You do a project, and then move onto another one. However, sometimes there isn't a project starting at the exact time, or the project managers think a person needs a break.
- ghshephard 12y agoI'm surprised employees on "Interproject" (also known as being on the Bench pretty much every consulting company out there) don't just treat this as vacation and let Ubisoft know they'll check their voicemail every couple days to see if they any new gigs coming up. If the place is depressing, and you aren't actually doing work - why not spend the time resting, recharging and relaxing.
- crdoconnor 12y ago>I'm surprised employees on "Interproject" (also known as being on the Bench pretty much every consulting company out there) don't just treat this as vacation and let Ubisoft know they'll check their voicemail every couple days to see if they any new gigs coming up. That behavior sounds like it would lead you into getting laid off as often as not.
- crdoconnor 12y ago>I'm surprised employees on "Interproject" (also known as being on the Bench pretty much every consulting company out there) don't just treat this as vacation and let Ubisoft know they'll check their voicemail every couple days to see if they any new gigs coming up. That behavior sounds like it would lead you into getting laid off as often as not. Ubisoft clearly expects you to be proactive in finding projects.
- JamesBaxter 12y agoReminds me of the sequence where Big Head gets kicked off the Nucleus project in "Silicon Valley"
- CmonDev 12y agoBut those guys were vesting not just resting. Salary is not same.
- snorrah 12y agoThis sounds exactly like being "on the bench" at a big IT company - no current project, yet still retained and encouraged to find new work for a while before any mention of redundancy or unemployment rolls around. Edit - ghshephard pretty much nailed it in his post just before mine!
- aluhut 12y agoWhat an awful article. So much text, so few informations. We need an tl;dr app that measures the amount of informations and gives you a tl;dr version if the blow-up and repetitions reach a certain percentage of the complete length of the article.
- abluecloud 12y agohttp://www.textteaser.com/ http://www.textteaser.com/ - Chrome extension. Generated for this article (pretty rubbish, tbf): One morning late last year, not long after Guillaume, a developer at Ubisoft Montreal, had finished working on his newest game, he was told he'd be moving offices. Guillaumewho asked that I not use his real name for this storysoon found himself on the third floor of one of Ubisoft's buildings in downtown Montreal. For the days, weeks, or maybe even months to come, they were in "limbo," as Guillaume put it. Call it Video Game Developer Purgatory. But as each person finishes his or her role on a game, there won't always be new positions or projects open just yet. So instead of just laying off the ones who can't be placed on new teams, Ubisoft sends them to limbo. Though I wasn't able to talk to anyone who had a positive experience in Ubisoft's game developer limbo, it certainly seems better for employees than mass layoffs.
- aluhut 12y agoPretty good. I should try this. Thank you.
- FollowSteph3 12y agoI think the main problem is that people from HN are on average much more self-motivated than your average person. And as a result the average person who goes on bench quickly gets bored with nothing to do rather than take the initiative and do something. They need someone to direct them. Remember most people socialize, watch tv, etc. most people are not self-motivators. It's sad but unfortunately it's the reality. On a positive note we need employees, not everyone can be an entrepreneur. I think Ubisoft is doing a very good thing. It's better than most companies. If they want to maximize their retainment investment they just need to have some direction for the people on the bench. The problem is, is it worth this additional investment? Probably not. On a positive note your self motivators can take advantage of it which is great. And those that don't, well they don't.
- lostcolony 12y agoA lot of people seem to be viewing this from a developer's perspective, when those are the people spending the least amount of time interproject. You mostly have the non-programmers. You can't build an indie; you can't even really come up with a real project with any hope of coming to fruition, to make use of the talent, because any member of it could be pulled away at any time. And it's hard to motivate yourself when you know anything you -do- do belongs to Ubisoft, and there's no expectations set on you. It's easy on the sidelines to say "Well, -I- would...", except no, you probably wouldn't. Your employer benched you, you have no tasks, and anything you produce on your own is theirs, and you're free to go home. Any reasonable person would go home; even if you want to spend the time working on something better to do it where you can claim it wasn't at work, using work resources, and take credit for it. That said, Ubisoft should probably be finding things to task these people with. You've got artists and designers and such? Concept art and design of new ideas. Treat this as the equivalent of an R&D department for the company rather than a place to cool your heels. If need be, task a few people with coming up with pitches to provide structure, etc. Basically, try and change it so people feel that even while benched, they are being valued, and their work, though not able to be a project due to lack of consistent resources, is still worthwhile and can still effect the direction of the company.
- CmonDev 12y agoThey should assign them to work on an ultra-violent mini shooter with an unreasonable number of different weapons and monsters.