2 ms·
> And who gets to pick what's productive or not? The community! That's what we're talking about here: how can the majority of some community avoid losing their
by acqq 12y ago
> And who gets to pick what's productive or not?
The community! That's what we're talking about here: how can the majority of some community avoid losing their own gathering place to a minority that makes the same place unhabitable for the rest. See Hacker News. Voting. Moderating.
Edit: Sometimes even resuliting in graying this very comment out. Which is OK if we beleive in the basic principle.
- ObviousScience 12y agoIn the case of Hacker News, not everyone agrees on what's productive or not. Saying "the community" without some way to decide between split opinions isn't a real answer to how we're going to pick. One could argue that we're already doing some form of community driven decision about what's productive on Hacker News (what, with the voting and what not), but you're clearly not happy with what people settled on through that method.
- acqq 12y ago> but you're clearly not happy with what people settled on through that method. I am. And I'm also willing to risk having the post downvoted if it goes against what some "voters" would find offensive to their beliefs. For example, a lot of US people, including those on HN, believe it's not allowed to directly "talk negative" about any religion (when I just point to obvious aggresive teachings in them). And I beleive that that approach makes the world much worse.