4 ms·
Am I reading this right? All the evidence for global warming comes from a study that has never been peer reviewed? And can't be? And, the study essentially fi
by ars 17y ago
Am I reading this right?
All the evidence for global warming comes from a study that has never been peer reviewed? And can't be?
And, the study essentially fitted data to a model?
- brazzy 17y agoNo, you're reading it the way that piece of FUD is intended to be read. There's lots of other evidence that the author carefully avoids mentioning. If you're in Europe, go see some glaciers in the Alps while you still can - they won't exist for much longer.
- rimantas 17y agoI saw "lots of evidence" in lots of places, then I saw "there is some evidence" in some places, but I don't recall it going further than that. This is sad, because it makes the whole subject a matter of belief. Even worse, anyone having a bit dissident opinion is likely to be treated as nay-sayer, heretic and the enemy of the Earth. I don't see that as scientific way to tackle the problem.
- borism 17y agowell, let me guess. you're no scientist in the first place?
- steamer25 17y ago>> If you're in Europe, go see some glaciers in the Alps while you still can - they won't exist for much longer. ...said the man opposed to the spread of fear, uncertainty and doubt.
- axod 17y agoLondon used to be overrun with vineyards a couple of hundred years ago. Since then it's dramatically cooled. Things change all the time. Chill out, they sky's not falling.
- jellicle 17y agoYou may be reading what is written correctly. But what is written is very, very false.
- nice1 17y agoWhat do you mean? In what way is it false?
- skorgu 17y agoIANAClimatologist. This[1] chart is not subject to the "missing data" problem; as cited by wikipedia it is composed from freely available data. In addition by including satellite data that is free of an entire class of measurement artifacts it substantially limits the plausible error alleged by the article. The best interpretation of the article is that it is an astonishingly narrow picture of a small slice of an enormous field. [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Satellite_Temperatures.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Satellite_Temperatures.png
- Andys 17y agoIsn't satellite data subject to a different class of measurement artifacts? Since it is measuring reflection at potentially different layers of the atmosphere, some high, some low?
- Tichy 17y agoMaybe scientists can account for that and adjust the models accordingly.
- skorgu 17y agoThe noise is different but the signals are strikingly similar. That's a strong point in favor of the model IMO, but as I said this is a complex, subtle field in which I'm not an expert. Imagine how badly the popular media gets computer stories and think that we're making at least as bad a hash out of this whole field.
- SamAtt 17y agoI think the article's correct but it's mistake is in ascribing motive to the lost dataset. The bottom line is that Global Warming traces its origins back to a study done on a dataset that is now incomplete. But the fact that there's only one dataset isn't exactly a conspiracy. When talking about Global Warming we're talking about measuring a really small number over a really, really big surface area. That's a far bigger job than most people think. All the equipment has to be calibrated exactly, in sync, and distributed across the globe. And as I said the numbers are relatively small. Global Warming asserts a 1.33 degree increase in temperature over the last Century. To put that in perspective the difference between standing on asphalt during a sunny day or standing on concrete during a sunny day is about 3 degrees (because the concrete reflects where as the asphalt absorbs) So it's not some big conspiracy. There's probably only one set of equipment in the world capable of measuring what needs to be measured which is why there's only one dataset available. How parts of it got lost is anyone's guess but I can't imagine in was done with malicious intent or that the study based on that dataset was purposely inaccurate (or at least I don't want to imagine that)
- anigbrowl 17y agomistake is in ascribing motive to the lost dataset Indeed. When you get down to it, the core of many political skeptics' arguments is: evil liberal scientists can't get real jobs so they cooked up 'climate change' to get endless government funding from honest taxpayers like you and me. Those political organs arguing most vociferously against action on climate change oppose any kind of public funding for science that isn't obviously defense-related.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- MaysonL 17y agoThere's plenty of evidence, other than temperature measurements: permafrost, glaciers, and polar ice melting; extended growing seasons; changes in bird migration.
- 17y ago
- catzaa 17y agoMany articles are peer reviewed without actually looking at the data or recreating all the results. The whole idea is that a paper should be reproducible so that people can come along later and reproduce it. If they fail to do that then that is what letters are for. Every paper that has been peer reviewed isn’t faultless.