3 ms·
> Being downvoted to zero is very demoralising as it makes the commenter feel the same as having their comment flagged in other systems. Like for example causin
by minimaxir 12y ago
> Being downvoted to zero is very demoralising as it makes the commenter feel the same as having their comment flagged in other systems. Like for example causing flamebait, hatred, inappropriateness etc.
As a counterpoint, downvotes serve as a signal that you said something bad and now have an opportunity to learn (which is better than beign flagged on forums, which goes on a permanent record of sorts). If you got flagged on forums for flaming/spamming, you know not to do that again, and what happens if you do.
Yes, there are silly reasons for being downvoted on Hacker News in particular, but it's not something that should be taken personally.
- neilellis 12y agoNot taking it personally - however it is demoralizing - and therefore discouraging. Take as a truly hypothetical situation that a commenter came out as gay in a comment and that comment got downvoted so that it appears greyed out and had a negative number next to it. Would that be welcoming? That's what I'm suggesting is negative, it's unnecessary to have a system that actively discourages people because someone doesn't agree with them. And don't forget not all of us (and I am an active HN user) can downvote. So we get a skewed view of people's comments. Simple accountability (i.e. the reason for downvoting) would cure this. If people disagree with a comment they simply won't vote for it, and will upvote a comment they agree with. That's why I feel it's unnecessary to have downvoting by opinion. IMHO - of course :-)