4 ms·
Yep, that's it. Shakespeare's dialect is full of false friends. Indeed, the irony today is that the Russians, the French and other people in foreign countries
by chrismealy 12y ago
Yep, that's it. Shakespeare's dialect is full of false friends.
Indeed, the irony today is that the Russians, the French and other people in foreign countries possess Shakespeare to a much greater extent than we do, for the simple reason that unlike us, they get to enjoy Shakespeare in the language they speak. Shakespeare is translated into rich, poetic varieties of these languages, to be sure, but since it is the rich, poetic modern varieties of the languages, the typical spectator in Paris, Moscow or Berlin can attend a production of Hamlet and enjoy a play rather than an exercise. In Japan, new editions of Shakespeare in Japanese are regularly best-sellers—utterly unimaginable here, since, like the Japanese, we prefer to experience literature in the language we speak, and a new edition of original Shakespeare no longer fits this definition. In an illuminating twist on this, one friend of mine—and a very cultured, literate one at that—has told me that the first time they truly understood more than the gist of what was going on in a Shakespeare play was when they saw one in French!
-- http://www.tcg.org/publications/at/jan10/shakespeare.cfm http://www.tcg.org/publications/at/jan10/shakespeare.cfm
- bane 12y agoThe flip side is that English speakers get to enjoy a treasure trove of 500 years of stories that are basically riffs on his works and a vast collection of day to day sayings and words which color our everyday language. We actually get to live intimately with his works even if we can barely understand the originals.
- bhaak 12y agoSo do you when you speak German and French. Shakespeare isn't just an English classic, he is an European and a World's classic and in Europe, many countries have lived intimately with him for centuries as well. Granted, not all went as far as the Germans and Klingons, but thinking that only the English people have a long lived history with Shakespeare is false. I looked at what Wikipedia had about Shakespeare's influence in non-English countries and was surprised that this is hardly mentioned. Is this really an obscure fact that for example in the 19th century Shakespeare was widely more popular in Germany than in Britain or that Goethe and Voltaire were avid admirers of Shakespeare?