12 ms·
The Dog Ate my Global Warming Data (key climate data is missing)
- ars 17y agoAm I reading this right? All the evidence for global warming comes from a study that has never been peer reviewed? And can't be? And, the study essentially fitted data to a model?
- brazzy 17y agoNo, you're reading it the way that piece of FUD is intended to be read. There's lots of other evidence that the author carefully avoids mentioning. If you're in Europe, go see some glaciers in the Alps while you still can - they won't exist for much longer.
- rimantas 17y agoI saw "lots of evidence" in lots of places, then I saw "there is some evidence" in some places, but I don't recall it going further than that. This is sad, because it makes the whole subject a matter of belief. Even worse, anyone having a bit dissident opinion is likely to be treated as nay-sayer, heretic and the enemy of the Earth. I don't see that as scientific way to tackle the problem.
- borism 17y agowell, let me guess. you're no scientist in the first place?
- steamer25 17y ago>> If you're in Europe, go see some glaciers in the Alps while you still can - they won't exist for much longer. ...said the man opposed to the spread of fear, uncertainty and doubt.
- axod 17y agoLondon used to be overrun with vineyards a couple of hundred years ago. Since then it's dramatically cooled. Things change all the time. Chill out, they sky's not falling.
- jellicle 17y agoYou may be reading what is written correctly. But what is written is very, very false.
- nice1 17y agoWhat do you mean? In what way is it false?
- skorgu 17y agoIANAClimatologist. This[1] chart is not subject to the "missing data" problem; as cited by wikipedia it is composed from freely available data. In addition by including satellite data that is free of an entire class of measurement artifacts it substantially limits the plausible error alleged by the article. The best interpretation of the article is that it is an astonishingly narrow picture of a small slice of an enormous field. [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Satellite_Temperatures.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Satellite_Temperatures.png
- Andys 17y agoIsn't satellite data subject to a different class of measurement artifacts? Since it is measuring reflection at potentially different layers of the atmosphere, some high, some low?
- Tichy 17y agoMaybe scientists can account for that and adjust the models accordingly.
- skorgu 17y agoThe noise is different but the signals are strikingly similar. That's a strong point in favor of the model IMO, but as I said this is a complex, subtle field in which I'm not an expert. Imagine how badly the popular media gets computer stories and think that we're making at least as bad a hash out of this whole field.
- SamAtt 17y agoI think the article's correct but it's mistake is in ascribing motive to the lost dataset. The bottom line is that Global Warming traces its origins back to a study done on a dataset that is now incomplete. But the fact that there's only one dataset isn't exactly a conspiracy. When talking about Global Warming we're talking about measuring a really small number over a really, really big surface area. That's a far bigger job than most people think. All the equipment has to be calibrated exactly, in sync, and distributed across the globe. And as I said the numbers are relatively small. Global Warming asserts a 1.33 degree increase in temperature over the last Century. To put that in perspective the difference between standing on asphalt during a sunny day or standing on concrete during a sunny day is about 3 degrees (because the concrete reflects where as the asphalt absorbs) So it's not some big conspiracy. There's probably only one set of equipment in the world capable of measuring what needs to be measured which is why there's only one dataset available. How parts of it got lost is anyone's guess but I can't imagine in was done with malicious intent or that the study based on that dataset was purposely inaccurate (or at least I don't want to imagine that)
- anigbrowl 17y agomistake is in ascribing motive to the lost dataset Indeed. When you get down to it, the core of many political skeptics' arguments is: evil liberal scientists can't get real jobs so they cooked up 'climate change' to get endless government funding from honest taxpayers like you and me. Those political organs arguing most vociferously against action on climate change oppose any kind of public funding for science that isn't obviously defense-related.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- MaysonL 17y agoThere's plenty of evidence, other than temperature measurements: permafrost, glaciers, and polar ice melting; extended growing seasons; changes in bird migration.
- 17y ago
- catzaa 17y agoMany articles are peer reviewed without actually looking at the data or recreating all the results. The whole idea is that a paper should be reproducible so that people can come along later and reproduce it. If they fail to do that then that is what letters are for. Every paper that has been peer reviewed isn’t faultless.
- brazzy 17y agoA conservative think tank shill serving vested interests by spreading FUD about climate change. How quaint. All over the world, glaciers are receding rapidly, the arctic ice cap is disappearing during summer - changes that are very, very measurable and visible to anyone who cares to look. Satellite measuring does not reach back that far, but shows clear, undeniable upwards trends. And this guy says measures taken to combat this should be reconsidered because one particular set of historical data may have been cooked? I guess he didn't get the memo that denying the existence of global warning has become untenable and the methods of choice are now denying that humans caused it, or claiming that reducing CO2 emission is less cost-effective than protecting against the symptoms.
- randallsquared 17y agoHow is it that people who want to see and check data on a subject of concern have been tarred with the brush of holocaust deniers? I'm starting to assume that anyone using the word "deny" or "denier" in the context of a question of science is trying to shut down research in favor of politics.
- brazzy 17y agoThe thing is: he's not saying "this particular piece of research seems questionable" - he's saying "because this particular piece of research seems questionable, measures based on it and lots of other, better sources should be reconsidered". It is in fact quite similar in style to holocaust deniers (you brought that up, not I): look through the other side's data carefully, find the weakest parts and make a big show of proving those false and conclude that therefore it must all be lies. (And yes, the holocaust deniers often go one step further and just make stuff up) In real science, you try to disprove the other side's strongest arguments, not their weakest ones.
- randallsquared 17y agoActually, from what I remember, holocaust deniers tend to make up stuff out of whole cloth, both for their arguments and against (for easier demolishing, see). Maybe they look at actual evidence now, but I haven't paid attention in years. In any case, I really have no idea whether the data in question was critical to the argument that climate is warming faster than it was earlier (since pretty much everyone accepts that significant global warming has been going on since at least the 1700s; the arguments are in the causes and details), but I just object to the hammering of the "deny", "denial", "denier" refrain.
- lucumo 17y agoArticle lacks sources for its claims. > Patrick J. Michaels is a senior fellow in environmental studies at the Cato Institute and author of Climate of Extremes: Global Warming Science They Don’t Want You to Know. Yeah, figures. Want a grindstone for that axe? Edit: Quote from Wikipedia[1] about the author: "Climate scientist Tom Wigley, [21] a lead author of parts of the report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, is quoted in Ross Gelbspan's book The Heat is On[22]: "Michaels' statements on [the subject of computer models] are a catalog of misrepresentation and misinterpretation… Many of the supposedly factual statements made in Michaels' testimony are either inaccurate or are seriously misleading."[23] Peter Gleick, a conservation analyst and president of the Oakland-based Pacific Institute, said: "Pat Michaels is not one of the nation's leading researchers on climate change. On the contrary, he is one of a very small minority of nay-sayers who continue to dispute the facts and science about climate change in the face of compelling, overwhelming, and growing evidence."[24]" Yeah, I'll take a pass on taking this article at face value. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patrick_Michaels http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patrick_Michaels
- byrneseyeview 17y agoYou don't trust him, because he agrees with the view he expresses in that article? This is easy to settle. He says the data don't exist. You apparently say the smart default is to assume that they do. So find the data, and that's the end of it. Right? Your edit is pretty hilarious: he can't be right, because he's part of Cato and has published stuff arguing against climate change! Look, somebody at the Pacific Institute ("Research for People and the Planet") has published something saying so! You might be right, but your argument is basically "Galileo is wrong, because he's a heretic. The Pope even said so. Is Galileo a Pope? I. Thought. Not."
- lucumo 17y agoEh, no. I don't trust him because he's written anti-climate change before and doesn't give any sources for his claim that the data is basically fraudulent. Seems to me he's just searching for arguments to discard the scientific consensus and not trying to further the debate at all.
- rauljara 17y agoThe idea that the entire case on global warming comes from a single data set that no one made a copy of is absurd on the face of it. Even if one were to willfully believe that the rest of the article is true, something which I am dubious about, it doesn't mean much in the greater scheme of climate science. One can always find a sloppy scientist. That's why scientists practice things like peer review and replication. The conclusion that global warming is real has been replicated across any number of studies. People opposed to the idea that global warming is real will point to any discrepancy, bit of sloppy science, or dispute on any detail as evidence that it must -all- be wrong. But it's a fallacious and misleading argument. A bit of sloppy science is nothing more than one bit of sloppy science. A slight dispute over details is nothing more than a slight dispute over details. The core of the position that global warming is real and caused by humans has overwhelming evidence behind it. One sloppy scientist doesn't change that fact.
- jacoblyles 17y agoSteve Mcintyre is an interesting guy. His hobby is to check the data, statistics, and models published in climate science articles. As far as I know his work is quality, at least several of his corrections have found their way into mainstream climate records. The fact that he has been involved in so many tooth-and-nail fights to obtain the data he seeks, often being flatly denied, ought to concern anyone who cares about the veracity of the claims of climate scientists and activists, as well as anyone with a vested interest in a political system that looks poised to spend trillions of dollars on climate policy over the next decade. You can check out his blog here: http://www.climateaudit.org/ http://www.climateaudit.org/. But be warned, it's not political at all. If you don't have a head for data series and regression models, you'll be put to sleep. The amount of bad scientific practices and obfuscation that this one man has uncovered is staggering (scientists cherry-picking data for a paper and then refusing to provide the whole data set seems a common complaint). However, as good citizens we must believe that the thousands of papers he has not gotten around to checking are perfectly valid. To do otherwise is to be painted with the label of "heretic". In the end, it is the poor treatment of the scientific process by scientists and activists, as well as the religion-like enforcement of agreement, that causes me to hold onto my green skepticism. I'm not sure that climate change won't Kill Us All, but I am not convinced by those that do think so. edit: One final cause of my green skepticism is the fact that so many highly-publicized predictions made by environmentalists in the past, many of whom held PHDs, have been wrong. But more importantly, they have always been wrong in one direction, the direction of overstating the environmental damage done by human activity. The environmentalists of the 1960s foresaw a world that would undergo multiple environmental holocausts by the 1980s, which of course never came to pass. While the quality of past predictions has no direct bearing on the quality of current predictions, indeed one might even assume that modern predictions are of higher quality given more advanced methods and greater funding, it does make me skeptical of any would-be green Nostradamus, at least until one establishes a good track record of predicting the future.
- adammichaelc 17y agoAs always, it has been an intellectual feast to read through the comments on both sides of this debate. I would just like to throw this out there to see what YC thinks. Is this possibly an explanation to the warming we are seeing? Mars Warming Points to Solar, not Human, Causes for Global Warming http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2007/02/070228-mars-warming.html http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2007/02/070228-mars-... Also, I'm curious if anybody knows what other alternative theories are out there?
- duncanj 17y agoThe skepticism in the article about Abdussamatov's conclusions says to me that he has a long way to go before he can really show "solar, not human" cause. It's an alright article. I think it's interesting that it is dated a year and a half after this discussion: http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2005/10/global-warming-on-mars/ http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2005/10/global... "The shrinkage of the Martian South Polar Cap is almost certainly a regional climate change, and is not any indication of global warming trends in the Martian atmosphere. Colaprete et al in Nature 2005 (subscription required) showed, using the Mars GCM, that the south polar climate is unstable due to the peculiar topography near the pole, and the current configuration is on the instability border; we therefore expect to see rapid changes in ice cover as the regional climate transits between the unstable states."
- anamax 17y agoThe sun is doing all sorts of "odd" things. http://physicsworld.com/cws/article/news/40456 http://physicsworld.com/cws/article/news/40456 And, there are strange correlations. http://landscheidt.auditblogs.com http://landscheidt.auditblogs.com
- jcromartie 17y agoThere should be a github for scientific data. Hell, just use github!
- nice1 17y agoScientific data is beginning to be shared these days, at least in some fields.
- jakecarpenter 17y agoThis article brings up an issue I often face when looking at articles from sites like this. How do I know the slant of a news site I don't often read? I don't have a problem with a little bias, (in fact, bias is nearly impossible to eliminate imho) but I'd like to know how to approach the article in the first place. It is easier with sites like npr, cnn, foxnews, but it takes a little bit of googling to find out about many others. How do you guys do it?
- anigbrowl 17y agoI look at the form of the argument presented. If it employs rhetorical fallacies, or lacks qualifiers to broad statements, or shies away from more than the most cursory contextual explanations, then it's probably bullshit. Or in programming terms, watch out for undeclared variables, errors in scope, and abuse of the GOTO statement.
- antipaganda 17y ago+1, awesome analogies.
- Tichy 17y agoTo me the article displayed a typical revisionism trait: picking one small aspect, proving it wrong and thereby claiming to disprove the whole theory. It is like the creationists who think finding some obscure bone somewhere that falls outside of the predictions of some obscure application of evolution theory somehow disproves evolution theory. While I can imagine a lot of things, I very much doubt that the whole climate debate rests on one unobtainable data set.
- chasingsparks 17y agoIgnoring stance, I am just curious -- am I the only one who did not expect this thread to collect so many points and comments?
- billswift 17y agoAnyone interested in global warming should read Solomon's "The Deniers: The World Renowned Scientists Who Stood Up Against Global Warming Hysteria, Political Persecution, and Fraud - And those who are too fearful to do so", http://www.amazon.com/Deniers-Renowned-Scientists-Political-Persecution/dp/0980076315/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1253970788&sr=8-1 http://www.amazon.com/Deniers-Renowned-Scientists-Political-... . Most interestingly, most of the scientists the author interviewed still believe in global warming; they just believe their own research was twisted or misinterpreted to support it, all the rest they still believe. Because of the media barrage supporting global warming, that is all most people, even scientists who do not actually look for disconfirming claims and evidence, ever see. Also, Moore's "Climate of Fear" (published by Cato), http://www.amazon.com/Climate-Fear-Shouldnt-Global-Warming/dp/1882577655/ref=cm_cr_pr_product_top http://www.amazon.com/Climate-Fear-Shouldnt-Global-Warming/d... , points out that the effects even proponents claim have been getting down graded, to the point where the actually expected global warming is likely to be more beneficial than not.
- Calamitous 17y agoThis is the most civil and reasoned discourse I've ever seen on global warming. Just incredible.