3 ms·
The justice system is "broken" only if you believe that it's ultimate goal is justice. The truth however is that it's simply double-speak. 1984 illustrated thi
by enraged_camel 12y ago
The justice system is "broken" only if you believe that it's ultimate goal is justice.
The truth however is that it's simply double-speak. 1984 illustrated this beautifully. The Ministry of Truth was in charge of fabricating lies. The Ministry of Love was in charge of punishing and torturing dissidents. The Ministry of Peace was in charge of conducting perpetual war.
In our case, the justice system is in charge of injustice, for example by making sure that rich people remain in power and that their wealth and property are protected (from the poor) and ruthlessly prosecuting anyone who threatens the social order -- especially minorities.
- javajosh 12y agoI think that's a dangerous way to think about things - not dangerous because it will get you branded a Winston Smith and arrested, but because it sets up an unnecessary and unhealthy duality between us and them. Injustice in the criminal system is, more often than not, driven by smug complacency and convenient, lazy bias rather than any real desire for injustice. That is, the "majority evil" position is to simply do nothing while good people get shredded in the machine - they aren't actively trying to sharpen the machine's teeth. Even the police who make mistakes, I would guess, are usually doing so out of laziness. The details take too much effort to see. The circumstances are always complicated. It's much easier to be happy if you are always "just doing your job". Check the boxes, go home and watch football. The solution here is not to cynically label the system as unrepentantly evil, but rather to offer inducements to their job properly, by for example installing ubiquitous surveillance, and allowing supervisors (people with higher intelligence and morality) to review and punish police mis-behavior, and reward exemplary behavior.
- enraged_camel 12y agoSorry, I wasn't clear. I'm not suggesting that the majority is evil. On the contrary, the majority are simply lazy and complacent. In 1984 this was captured perfectly. There is the Inner Party, who is a small, elite group who fabricate the lies and call the shots. There's the Outer Party, the relatively uneducated and loyal group that naively believes in the party's ideals and does its bidding (e.g. the police), and there's the general populace (what Orwell labeled "the proles). The most remarkable thing about the setting in 1984 is that almost everyone believes that the Party is altruistic and noble and does everything (including conducting wars) for the greater good, and that any imperfections in the way the system works are unintended and can be fixed. Indeed, keeping up this illusion is so important for social order that it is the primary motivation behind the Inner Party's desire for total control through things like state-sponsored propaganda and ubiquitous surveillance.
- steanne 12y agoside note: my hazy recollection of 1984 didn't include the names of the ministries, so when you went from truth to love, i assumed the next one, a la ultima, would be courage.