4 ms·
As the article makes clear, they're just incompetent. However police-types seem to be very conservative by nature which can lead to a very technophobic workforc
by Someone1234 12y ago
As the article makes clear, they're just incompetent. However police-types seem to be very conservative by nature which can lead to a very technophobic workforce.
It is pretty surprising how slowly police are changing with the times. You'd expect every major police force to have a "computer crimes" division, but they don't. Only really the MET (London's police force) has a decent computer crimes division.
You often read about digital crimes (e.g. harassment, theft, fraud, etc) going completely uninvestigated because of how few "digital police" they have (e.g. 1/1000th the size of the officers investigating physical crimes).
As a specific example, for almost a year when you Googled "UK passport renew" the first Google adword result was an obviously fraudulent one, yet nothing was done even though they had to have known about it.
PS - I bet you could use Tasker (or a similar app) to wipe your phone if it didn't regain data access for a long period of time (e.g. 6-12 hours). So if they took your phone and shoved it into a bag, the phone still auto-wipes if they fail to turn it off.
PPS - Although realistically you're best not storing the data on your phone at all. The UK police can force you to give up your encryption keys, however they would struggle to get your data off of a foreign owned-operated website.
- vinceguidry 12y ago> Only really the MET (London's police force) has a decent computer crimes division. It doesn't surprise me. Doing this stuff effectively is very hard, the number of people who could get up to speed quickly is small. It's not like your company's IT department. If I recall correctly, there was a sort-of mini bubble some years back where every force out there rushed to get a computer crimes division. We can all have fun imagining how most of those went.
- bunderbunder 12y agoI suspect for most forces the payroll budget is nowhere near large enough to hire people with appropriate skills, either. I've lived in places where the chief of police's salary would be considered entry-level pay by IT professionals.
- adav 12y agoThis applies to every public sector job that's related to cutting-edge IT.
- IgorPartola 12y agoWhy does every small town police department need its own staff for investigating "digital" crime? A centralized agency would actually be much more efficient for this, one that can collaborate with the local police department to match physical and digital evidence, perform arrests, etc. Not that I want yet another acronym agency charged with investigating everyone on the Internet, but it seems a waste to have each police department try to set up its own digital forensics lab.
- jahewson 12y agoIn the UK a town (or what in the US would be called a "city") does not have its own police department. Instead the UK is divided into just 45 territorial police forces, typically the size of a county. So the parent comment is not as inefficient as it would be in a US context where each town has its own independent force.
- kauffj 12y agoYou're 100% right except for one aspect: that it is surprising. The highest quality services are ones with multiple alternatives and low switching costs. Monopolies tend to provide poorer service and are more conservative because there is reduced incentive or pressure to change. Police are a perfect example of this; democracy is a weak lever. Edit: This is not inherently an argument against the provision of the police as a public good. It could be accomplished within democracy by stronger localization and flexibility in choice of provision (e.g. allowing neighborhoods to opt out / choose their own solution).
- bunderbunder 12y agoI'm curious about how a system where law enforcement is supplied by a competitive market would work.
- dazc 12y agoDon't go there. :)
- dragontamer 12y agoIt would diverge into racketeering, and then into Feudalism with different companies holding control of different regions. Although it'd be a libertarian distopia. Libertarians want it so badly but they don't really understand that it is how the world worked a thousand years ago.
- fleitz 12y agoLOL, exactly why do you think we need so many licenses, etc. If we don't have racketeering right now, how come individual police officers are allowed to keep the proceeds of any drug money they 'find'? Also, don't most people pay taxes so the force 'protecting' them won't ostensibly take them off to jail? When the police break the laws that are supposed to protect you is there any recourse for the police, or do they investigate themselves? Exactly what we have is racketeering, however, we have no alternative forces from which to purchase protection. If you read any book on the modern nation state it will tell you that the state is defined as the organization with monopolizes and projects violence over a given geographical territory.
- paulornothing 12y agoIn the US, I think the main issue has to do with most Police Departments only requiring a High School Diploma as an education requirement. I've had internships with Gov't agencies and volunteered at local PDs and it's a very common thread that a large portion of the workforce is computer illiterate. Sure higher education doesn't necessarily mean people will be proficient with computers but at least they will have exposure and familiarity. Also the people who make the decisions (higher ranking officials) are usually older and also phobic of technology.
- dublinben 12y agoThe problem also lies with compensation. If you have the skills to be a good computer forensics officer, you can make several times more money elsewhere.
- mark-r 12y agoIt's worse than that: some police departments will actively reject you if you're too smart. There are lots of stories about this which you can find with a quick search, including this one where someone was dismissed and lost their court case: http://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/story?id=95836 http://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/sto...
- skymt 12y agoI see the lack of seriousness with which law enforcement treats much digital crime as an aspect of the way society sees the Internet as less real and therefore unimportant. I also suspect this problem will disappear as those who grew up with pervasive computing gain influence.
- pjc50 12y agoI wouldn't describe this as "incompetent", I'd describe this as "the phone security working". There are techniques for tethering the phone and then downloading data from it, but arguably these rely on loopholes that Apple can and should be fixing. Phones don't have a concept of PACE. Until we can agree on a legal and technical system whereby the police have access to phones if and only if it's part of a criminal investigation, there are only two possibilities: too much police access, or no police access.
- ende 12y agoNo police access. Forever.
- mnarayan01 12y ago> You'd expect every major police force to have a "computer crimes" division, but they don't. I actually wouldn't. My (obviously potentially flawed) intuition would be that most "computer crime" could be handled by more centralized departments.