4 ms·
I wonder what the cost would look like to widen the tunnels on old subway systems like the Tube to make for wider trains. The first thing that hit me about the
by bane 12y ago
I wonder what the cost would look like to widen the tunnels on old subway systems like the Tube to make for wider trains. The first thing that hit me about the Tube when I used it is how narrow the trains are (especially the older lines). It's not a surprised when probably most of it was dug out by hand, but running a modern tunnel boring machine down the line and laying new track and using the kind of ultra wide trains used in Asia would move far more people.
- zimpenfish 12y agoI'm guessing "a lot". From http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/4934f824-ead3-11e1-984b-00144feab49a.html#ixzz3FeLfMlGK http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/4934f824-ead3-11e1-984b-00144feab4... > A decade later, the Jubilee line cost £36m per mile to build and its extension in the 1990s 10 times as much. The tunnels for Crossrail, the newest underground railway connection in London, are budgeted at almost £1bn per mile.
- alexbilbie 12y agoWhatever the cost it wouldn't be worth it. First some lines run within metres of one another so you couldn't expand because there just isn't space. A back of the napkin plan if you were to go ahead would look like this: 1) Shut down the line completely 2) Remove the tracks 3) Design, build and then get underground some new boring machines which need to be capable of removing the metal lining, digging through earth and concrete then relaying the lining. 4) Rebuild platforms which would inevitably be damaged 5) Relay tracks 6) Design, build and get to London new wider trains Realistically you're looking at 3-5 years (at least) per line to widen them. I don't know if you live in London and are therefore aware how much we Londoners rely on the tube - even if they only widened one line, having it out action for that long would have devastating consequences for communities and businesses and every day Londoners' lives.
- bane 12y agoNo, I've only spent a few weeks there. But I did absolutely rely on the tube for most of my transport until I figured out the bus system. Of course it would be horribly disruptive, but it might somebody be a necessity.
- avn2109 12y ago>> "then relaying the lining." Former tunnel boring engineer here. Modern TBM's usually line the tunnel with prefab concrete sectional rings, which are built by a human-controlled hydraulic arm at the front of the TBM's trailing gear, immediately behind the cutterhead chamber. As far as I know, cutting heads that could bore soils/rock could not also bore through metal lining. This is limited by the material properties of the cutting surfaces, typically hard metals or coated ceramics. Heads with acceptable wear rates in hard rock or soils will likely have unacceptably high wear rates against metals. And 3-5 years is probably a drastic underestimate of project duration.
- lmm 12y agoEnlarging an existing line is very unlikely to be cheaper than building a new line - you'd need a one-of-a-kind special TBM to handle the lining of the existing tunnels, you'd still need to re-lay the track and electrics, you'd still need to enlarge the stations meaning you'd still need worksites on the surface and possibly knocking down buildings to dig access shafts and so on. And you'd have to shut down the existing line while you were doing it, which there isn't usually spare capacity for. Newer lines (i.e. Thameslink, Crossrail, Crossrail 2) are being built for mainline-sized trains; I don't think there'll ever be a new tube-diameter tunnel under London except for short extensions to existing lines. But we're going to be stuck with the ones we already have for a while yet.