7 ms·
A related BBC news article is here: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-29520761 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-29520761 Including comment
by SideburnsOfDoom 12y ago
A related BBC news article is here: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-29520761 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-29520761
Including comment from the RMT Union about how they are "deeply concerned" about driverless operation, the "lethal and cash driven nonsense of removing drivers"
Well... driverless operation may be "cash-driven", and TFL s often focusing on savings over performance (e.g by removing staff from ticket and information booths) but "lethal" sounds like a slur. Driverless trains work well enough on the DLR in East London, and are probably an inevitable step in 21st century London.
- yangyang 12y agoAnd yet the Docklands Light Railway, also in London, and also under TfL control (though operation is outsourced to Serco, soon to be Keolis/Amey) has run without drivers (but with "train captains") for its entire history, over 25 years. And it does travel underground in places.
- stuaxo 12y agoDid they always have train captains ? I know there have been incidents (like a gang of kids chasing someone onto the tracks to be run over), that might have made them introduce "train captains".
- colinramsay 12y agoAccording to Wikipedia they've always had them. Doesn't having someone like this on the train mean it's not really "driverless"?
- yangyang 12y agoTo a point. They walk up and down the train, do the door opening / closing, check tickets here and there, and occasionally drive the train (though it always seems painfully slow when under manual control). I don't know how they'd do it on the tube. Presumably door closing would still require manual control.
- masklinn 12y ago> Presumably door closing would still require manual control. What for? The doors can be on a timer (station-specific if necessary)
- untog 12y agoPeople getting stuck in doors, holding doors open, etc. etc. - though I wonder if it would be more efficient to have a person per train or a person per platform for that.
- yangyang 12y agoIndeed - quite a lot of stations already have platform staff for checking doors and notifying the driver that it's OK to close. I suppose it would depend on the ratio of active trains to stations as it which is most efficient. I believe TfL have committed to manning all stations after the closure of ticket offices so having platform dispatch staff may be a useful use of labour.
- untog 12y agoThat did occur to me after I posted - someone on the platform would be much more useful - able to directions to people, etc.
- mynameisvlad 12y agoVancouver's Canada Line (fully automated) opens the doors fully and then tries to slowly close them if it detects an obstruction. A similar system could be in place.
- yangyang 12y agoThey'd probably never close in some stations, like Victoria at rush hour :-)
- 12y ago
- yangyang 12y agoThey definitely had them before that incident (which was at Shadwell IIRC).
- quarterto 12y agoSideburnsOfDoom mentioned that: > Driverless trains work well enough on the DLR in East London, and are probably an inevitable step in 21st century London.
- yangyang 12y agoHe / she edited after I replied.
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoMy apologies. Most of my edits are to fix typos or for sentence clarity, but I did add that part just after submitting the first version.
- danielbln 12y agoWorks well in lots of places: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_automated_urban_metro_subway_systems#Grade_of_Automation_4_Systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_automated_urban_metro_... Of course people whose jobs are affected by these systems will speak ill of it, I'm sure the carriage drivers union wasn't very pleased with the automobile back in the day either. We will see the same thing for trucks and cabs real soon.
- iaskwhy 12y agoKeep in mind section "Systems and lines with ATO and human driver (Grade of Automation 2)": most tube lines are already automated (to a point), it's just that there's still someone seating there at the helm.
- masklinn 12y agoI'm guessing that's why danielbln linked specifically to the Grade 4 section, rather than the whole article.
- ealexhudson 12y agoVictoria, Central and Jubilee are all "driverless". But they have drivers. There are actual reasons for this.
- masklinn 12y agoWhat "actual reasons" aside from inertia? The section danielbln linked to are UTO, they're fully automated and unattended (some of the trains don't even have a driver cabin, passengers can seat at the very front of the train) and most have been running for years if not decades without incidents (that I know of).
- vidarh 12y agoRMT (the union) mainly (there may be actual technical reasons too for some lines, but any technical reasons are likely to largely be a result of knowing that there's no point in investing too aggressively in enabling full automation if they won't be able to make full use of it). Notice the page takes care to point out that current drivers jobs are safe. It's likely that London Underground is basically betting it'll be easier to just hire at less than the replacement rate and gradually automate more and more rather than risk massive conflict with the RMT for years.
- masklinn 12y ago> "lethal" sounds like a slur. It is. There are dozens of ways to make automated trains as safe as or safer than driven ones, Lyon's line D has been fully automated for more than 20 years (since 1992), doesn't even use platform-side doors, and AFAIK the only incident so far was somebody falling on the train itself (dead drunk and trying to jump from a mezzanine to the quay) and hitting a camera in the tunnels in 2010 (the person was lucky and survived)
- waps 12y agoPfff I can't believe they're doing this. This is taking a tiny step in optimizing it. If we're eliminating train drivers, why do we even bother with having carriages ? Why can't I just get on a train at any station I want, and have it take me to any other station I want, ideally directly to street level ? I understand in 1798 why they went with one locomotive and lots of carriages. The engine is too expensive. One driver per carriage is not feasible. Great. All of those are eliminated. Electric motors are cheaper than "real" breaks, so every 2 wheels have an electric motor anyway. And if you have to have them, people power the train using the lots of small motors, because that means no big engine in the first carriage. But given that you need those things, why can't we just have every carriage be it's own "train" ? Why can't every carriage just have the destination that would be most convenient at that moment in time ? Why can't London subway be a traffic-immune taxi service ? Now THAT, I want.
- masklinn 12y ago> Why can't every carriage just have the destination that would be most convenient at that moment in time ? Because subway lines are fixed, have little branching and your carriage can't magically jump from one line to the other? Having independent carriages would mostly be messier, for no advantage.
- waps 12y agoEither they're fixed, or they have "little branching". Not both.
- lmm 12y agoCapacity. Legally we require a certain level of safety/signalling on the tube (and for good reason, given how bad a crash in a tube tunnel can be - after the Moorgate crash it took firefighters four days just to reach the front of the train). It's impossible to (legally) run trains closer than about two minutes apart. If you can only run one train every two minutes, then to take the number of people needed, you want trains as long as possible (e.g. Crossrail, which will use trains with about twice the capacity of Underground trains). Likewise "operational separation" of different lines is key to reliability, both to ensure incidents on one line don't affect service on another, and because points are subject to a lot more wear and tear than plain track (see the current disruption to south London rail services, caused by a cracked crossover at Lewisham). Going forward TfL is trying to move towards a network of simple, self-contained end-to-end lines, e.g. by separating the Northern line into two independent lines rather than one line with five branches. The kind of thing you're describing is in operation elsewhere in London where the capacity requirements make it more appropriate: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ULTra_(rapid_transit) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ULTra_(rapid_transit)
- embolalia 12y agoI don't know about how TFL will do it, but WMATA in Washington, DC did and will employ the same number of people under automatic operation as it does under manual operation. They were mostly just there to watch for problems and open the doors, but they were still employed (which should make the union happy). Interestingly, the crash that made WMATA stop automatic operation[1] would not have been avoided by manual operation. The operator would've seen the same suggested speed that the train did, and wouldn't have been able to stop any sooner. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/June_2009_Washington_Metro_train_collision https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/June_2009_Washington_Metro_tra...
- ohmygawd 12y agoYou're right - driverless trains can work very well. We've had them for 12 years in Copenhagen serving currently 22 stations, and they run smoothly with just 3 minutes between each train. In the first six months of operation back in 2002 there were a few problems (delays and such), but after that everything has been smooth (and no accidents to my knowledge).
- MrZongle2 12y agoIncluding comment from the RMT Union about how they are "deeply concerned" about driverless operation, the "lethal and cash driven nonsense of removing drivers" I suspect that if there were an Elevator Operator's Union, they would have said the same thing when elevators became sophisticated enough to be operated by a single button press.