4 ms·
You make a lot of very good points. The only things I disagree with you on is your final point. >This goes without saying, but the one thing that anybody can d
by danieltillett 12y ago
You make a lot of very good points. The only things I disagree with you on is your final point.
>This goes without saying, but the one thing that anybody can do is to donate to Doctors Without Borders or any other institution trying to quell the crisis.
The scale of the outbreak is now beyond what MSF or any NGO can handle. Only the military can now command the resources needed to get things under control. All donating to MSF is doing is delaying the point in which we activate the military.
- phkahler 12y agoThis is a big if - If the data is to be believed, the plots on wikipedia show liberia getting a handle on it in the last couple weeks. The exponential growth in number of cases has been reduced (concave down on the plots). I suspect the people there are finally believing the disease is real and changing their ways, which is reducing transmission. Or it's just a blip or a reduction in quality of the data. I dunno.
- danieltillett 12y ago>This is a big if - If the data is to be believed, the plots on wikipedia show liberia getting a handle on it in the last couple weeks. No this is a sign that the hospitals have stopped taking in any new cases as they have reached capacity and hence new cases are not being recorded. No one has any idea of how many new cases there are out in the community. It could be that the R0 has been reduced because of changes in behaviour, or it could be because people are dying at home unrecorded. I hope it is the first, but given the state of things at the moment I fear it is the second.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoOn your last point. MSF are not just fighting Ebola on the ground, they are also putting pressure on governments. Sending them money helps them have the resources to do both jobs more effectively. Sure, we should be putting pressure on our governments to do more ourselves, but I do not think that there is an inverse relationship between funding MSF and the speed of government response, when MSF are one of the groups trying to increase the rate of government response.
- danieltillett 12y agoI suspect donations are not going to have any impact on the effectiveness of MSF’s lobbying efforts (i.e. I don’t think MSF’s lobbying for military intervention by the west is money constrained). I am more than happy to be corrected on this if anyone has any data. What I am hoping by my comment is breaking people out of the thinking that this can be solved by donations to NGO’s like MSF. I believe it is far too big now for any NGO to deal with no matter how well resourced. If we can only get on top of the outbreak by military action lets stop messing around and start lobbying for this directly - every day we delay is only making the problem bigger and harder.