6 ms·
>This article is exactly WHY I am not legitimately concerned about a wide-spread infection in the Western world. Leaving aside the moral argument of preventing
by danieltillett 12y ago
>This article is exactly WHY I am not legitimately concerned about a wide-spread infection in the Western world.
Leaving aside the moral argument of preventing huge numbers of innocent people from dying Ebola if we can, there are two reason we in the west should be concerned:
1. There is a serious risk that Ebola will mutate to become more infectious. It is very unlikely to become airborne (this is about as likely as pigs becoming airborne), but it could relatively easily mutate to slow down its kill speed. At the moment Ebola kills so quickly that there is little time for a patient to spread it to other people. Ebola is under huge selection pressure to slow down the disease progression in humans. We could see a strain arise that takes a month to kill you where you are asymptotically infectious for a couple of weeks. Model this sort of virus and things look far less rosy for us in the west. The more people we let Ebola infect the more likely that such a strain will arise.
2. Once the number of cases get very large (25,000 a day by Jan 2015 according to the CDC) this is going to start disrupting international trade as countries close their borders. We already saw the sort of recession that can result from disruptions to trade when this happened in the GFC and the Asian crisis in the 90s. With interest rates at or near zero in most countries there is not much that can be done to buffer us economically.
- AlexDanger 12y agoYou can bet Madagascar will be the first to close their borders.
- asdffdsajkl 12y agoFor those that didn't get the reference - this is a reference to the web game pandemic in which the objective is to design a virus/bacteria/parasite to infect the entire world - Madagascar is the hardest country to infect in this game because it only has one port in the game.
- phkahler 12y ago>> There is a serious risk that Ebola will mutate to become more infectious. Not likely. Survival of the fittest for a virus usually means allowing the host to live longer - in other words LESS lethal. It is not likely to become airborne, and if it did it would not be ebola any more. The symptoms of most diseases are not an accident, they are tied to the means of transmission: Colds make you cough and sneeze. Flu makes you cough, sneeze, barf and sweat. Rabies makes you crazy and want to bite. STDs some think may make people horny. Ebola makes you barf, shit, bleed, sweat. The one scary thing is I once read that a single gene make Ebola hemoragic, and if that were to transfer to a flu, that would be very deadly. But it would also be less virulent due to that same deadliness and so would be selected against as our response to related flu vidii would wipe it out. None of that is helpful short term, but this notion of the virus getting more horrible than it already is, I don't think so.
- danieltillett 12y ago>Not likely. Survival of the fittest for a virus usually means allowing the host to live longer - in other words LESS lethal. Lethality is irrelevant to a virus, all that matters is the probability of transmission. Ebola is about as rapidly deadly as a virus can be and still be viable. The selection pressure is all on shedding large numbers of virus particle in all directions - there is no selection pressure on preventing you from dying. So why does Ebola kill then? It is basically a side effect of its mechanisms of transmission. It diverts your body into producing an enormous number of viral particles and then makes your body “leaky” so that they are released into the environment to infect someone else. If you were to design a virus based on Ebola from scratch for maximum transmission in humans you would slow down the disease progression, but you would find it hard to remove the lethality. Another way of thinking about Ebola is that the current strain is not at the local maximum for optimal transmission in humans as it kills too quickly. Any slow down in disease progression will cause the infectiousness in humans to increase. This is why this is something we should be worried about.
- ObviousScience 12y agoThe GP said "more infectious", not "more lethal". Your comment is violently agreeing with his point.
- danieltillett 12y agoYes I know, but I thought it better to explain in a different manner than just point this out. Another way to look at the problem is how optimised the current strain is for human transmission. As a zoonotic virus it is not very likely that Ebola is well adapted for effective human-to-human transmission. We should expect that the more people that it passes through the better adapted to humans Ebola will become and the more difficult it will be to contain. The unknown is we don’t know how well adapted it could become to humans, but personally I would rather not run this experiment in the wild to find out.
- phkahler 12y agoMy point was that more infections would mean less lethal in this case.
- wobbleblob 12y ago>Ebola is under huge selection pressure to slow down the disease progression in humans. We could see a strain arise that takes a month to kill you where you are asymptotically infectious for a couple of weeks. The virus doesn't gave a goal, to kill the patient. The death of the host is just an unfortunate side effect that really harms the spread of the virus. The really successful viruses have mutated to a form where they don't kill the host, don't make you sick enough to stay in bed, and just make you go to work and cough and sneeze all over everyone at the office.
- danieltillett 12y agoThis may all be true, but it does not say anything useful about Ebola and what the selection pressure it is under. At the moment the speed of disease progression to death is so fast that it is slowing the spread of Ebola. If the Ebola took longer to kill it would infect more people. The problem with Ebola is its mechanism of transmission is quite closely linked to the reason it is lethal (large virus production and body fluid leakage). It would take a very large leap in genome space (mutations) to turn Ebola into a virus that is efficiently transmitted, but causes limited symptoms like a Rhinovirus. It is not a large jump in genome space for it to just become slower in progression.
- robomartin 12y agoPerhaps the problem is your choice of words. Saying "selection pressure" implies intent, determination, a collective mission, if you will. Evolution has none of those drivers. It has no objectives. It sets no goals. And it certainly does not operate in some collective purpose driven form within a population. It's random mutations that either survive the environmental contex within which they exist, or they don't. In this case the fact that more people are infected does not mean that we are at the doorstep of a "super-ebola" mutation any time soon. It could take ONE mutation or 100 MILLION YEARS of intense mutations to arrive at "super-ebola". Nobody knows. The virus certainly isn't under any "selection pressure" to do a darn thing. It could become perfectly benign in six months just as much as it could become horrifically good at killing us by the millions.
- Shivetya 12y agothe real threat is that this disease is going to come to more Westernize countries and fester amongst poor populations who already do not trust their local officials. combine this with a sense of entitlement far too many people have when it comes to travel and restrictions of such, already in the US there is push back from those being monitored who had contact with the Dallas patient. We even have protesters rallying because a dog was put down. How do you contain irrational actions, the mutation of the disease may occur or not occur, but damn if a bunch of people aren't exercising self destructive behavior. People love to ridicule the Africans suffering through this as backward and superstitious all the while ignoring that entitlement, arrogance, and such, will cause similar containment issues in supposedly better countries. The fact that traffic hasn't been stopped already is criminal, its starting to read like World War Z. Europe will have it worse as they cannot easily control people getting in, the US has an ocean but air travel tends to mitigate that.
- mcguire 12y ago"The fact that traffic hasn't been stopped already is criminal,..." Something, something, no city in the first world is more than 24 hours away from food riots, something, something.
- mcguire 12y ago"2. Once the number of cases get very large (25,000 a day by Jan 2015 according to the CDC) this is going to start disrupting international trade as countries close their borders." This is what has me worried. It seems somewhat likely that overreactions will cause more harm (and possibly kill more people) than the disease itself.
- danieltillett 12y agoI would agree that the economic effects are much more likely to affect most of us in the west directly than the chance of coming down with Ebola. The world economy is not really in a good state to handle an external shock like massive trade disruption right now.