3 ms·
2.5) We can't agree on what "good" is because there is no unified 'good' side here; there are a giant pile of adversaries. Everyone will say they're the good o
by JoshTriplett 12y ago
2.5) We can't agree on what "good" is because there is no unified 'good' side here; there are a giant pile of adversaries. Everyone will say they're the good ones and everyone else is bad. As one obvious example, the intelligence services in one country won't necessarily trust those of another, and vice versa. The only sane implementation is to use the definition of 'adversary' provided by the person whose data you're protecting. Anything else would be broken.
This is the same key escrow battle we had when cryptography was first propagated: "Oh no, it actually works, and we can't trivially break it, it'll be the end of the world!". Only this time, the battle is "Oh no, it actually works for people who aren't technically savvy, it'll be the end of the world!".
The answer is the same now as it was then: no, go away, we're building solutions that work and you're asking us to make them broken.