3 ms·
This Golden Key idea is one of those classic "I'm just an idea man, I don't have to figure out the nitty gritty details!" claims. Everything is easy if you can
by Someone1234 12y ago
This Golden Key idea is one of those classic "I'm just an idea man, I don't have to figure out the nitty gritty details!" claims.
Everything is easy if you can leave figuring out the intractable problems to someone else. When you actually sit and think about this for a few minutes the problems quickly become apparent.
The closest real world system to this is DRM on games consoles (e.g. XBox 360). They use secret "Golden Keys" to protect authoring but still need to allow users access to that same information.
However the way DRM worked in that context was a combination of hardware (e.g. roll-back proof) and tieing the whole thing into a mandatory update system (i.e. no games without updates).
That DRM actually got cracked several times, but because updates were required they could just ignore it and move on. The problem with the Golden Key suggestion here is that once your data is compromise it is game over forever. There's no do-overs as there is with DRM systems.
- smtddr 12y ago>>The problem with the Golden Key suggestion here is that once your data is compromise it is game over forever. There's no do-overs as there is with DRM systems. For the game consoles there aren't really feasible do-overs either if the keys at ring 0(the earliest security event) are revealed. As in, the only path to recovery is to physically replace every game console out there. http://www.ps3hax.net/2012/10/marcan-fail0verflow-about-lv0/ http://www.ps3hax.net/2012/10/marcan-fail0verflow-about-lv0/ >>The effect of this is essentially the same that the metldr key release had: all existing and future firmwares can be decrypted, except Sony no longer has the lv0 trick up their sleeve. What this means is that there is no way for Sony to wrap future firmware to hide it from anyone, because old PS3s must be able to use all future firmware (assuming Sony doesn’t just decide to brick them all…), and those old PS3s now have no remaining seeds of security that aren’t known.
- drvdevd 12y ago> This Golden Key idea is one of those classic "I'm just an idea man, I don't have to figure out the nitty gritty details!" claims. Most definitely. And even the way it was proposed at the end of the original WaPo editorial was very nonchalant: > However, with all their wizardry, perhaps Apple and Google could invent a kind of secure golden key they would retain and use only when a court has approved a search warrant. Let's all be sure to remind the "non-technical" public that there is no wizardry involved here. It's logic, mathematics, and science and some things are possible and some things just are not. Encryption in this sense is very black and white: either your data can be decrypted by a 3rd party or it can't. And if it can be decrypted by one 3rd party, you must assume it can be decrypted by any 3rd party.