4 ms·
"Today’s LED-based lamps cost up to $100 each ... Over the long term, we can absolutely get the cost down to the $20-25 range" While they do sound better than
by ams6110 17y ago
"Today’s LED-based lamps cost up to $100 each ... Over the long term, we can absolutely get the cost down to the $20-25 range"
While they do sound better than the abysm that is the compact flourescent bulb, at that price they're a no-go compared to incandescents that are $0.20 - $0.25 or less at retail.
- Retric 17y ago10 watts to create the equivalent light of a 60-watt incandescent bulb; the color of the light output must mimic that of today’s incandescents; and the bulbs must last at least 25,000 hours Assuming 8c / kwh: Energy savings = 50w / 1000 (w/kw) * 25,000h * 0.08 $ / kwh = 100$. They still stuck compared to CF, but if you keep a light on 24/7 then these should just about break even compared to incandescents at 100$.
- camccann 17y agoHow often do people actually do a full-lifetime total cost estimate like that, instead of just going for what's cheapest right at the moment?
- harpastum 17y agoOn the other hand, 25,000 hours at 2 hours a day gives the bulb a lifetime of almost 35 years. I think you could really sell people on the "just set it and forget it" model.
- throw_away 17y agoon the other hand, what will be the impact on a manufacturer's bottom line when its customers have no incentive to ever upgrade or replace? maybe they could just license the light bulbs to end-users... :)
- mhb 17y agoAre manufacturers of granite countertops going out of business because of that?
- camccann 17y agoOnly if they believe you, though. CFLs have a lifetime of around 10,000 hours but some people discovered the hard way that they don't handle some operating environments, and then stopped trusting the rated lifetime at all.
- anamax 17y agoIn what operating environments should I expect CFLs to hit 10k hours? I'm not getting anywhere near that in a socket with no cover (so there's no heat build-up and room temp is steady too) that's turned on/off once/weekday and stays on for 4-6 hours. Nope, no dimmer. That's pretty much a best case for incandescents, I've had some last for years in those exact sockets, but I'm replacing CFLs pretty much every year.
- camccann 17y agoAnecodtally, I've been using CFLs exclusively for years and I don't think I've ever had one die. So either you've gotten extremely unlucky or there's something nonobvious causing your problem. Do you lose CFLs at the same rate in other sockets? I'm not an expert, but my first guess would be that you have dirty power messing with the electronic ballast; that wouldn't affect an incandecsent bulb appreciably, I expect.
- bhousel 17y agoMore anecdotal evidence.. I bought a few packs of cheap "Globe" brand CFL bulbs on Amazon, and had several failures after about 2 weeks. These were just in a normal ceiling fixture in the kitchen, which we only use a few hours a day. Sadly, the packages mention a guarantee, but there seems to be no way to claim it. They're Chinese made bulbs imported through Canada and the company doesn't respond to phone or email. OTOH, the Ikea branded CFL bulbs we bought have been working fine for years. I guess you get what you pay for..
- anamax 17y agoI don't have problems with any other electronic equipment, so if CFLs are delicate flowers.... (Filtered power isn't an option for a socket in the ceiling.)
- HeyLaughingBoy 17y agoAfter they've bought the cheap ones a few times and had to replace them after 3 months? You'd be surprised. Especially if the bulbs in question are in a high vaulted ceiling lamp. It's not just the cost of the bulb, it's the reliability and the time it takes to keep replacing them that's important.
- trebor 17y agoJust so long as you don't drop the CFL! Have you read the warnings on that thing? Mercury gas accounts for as much as 40mg/bulb, and they say vacate the entire premises, change air filters, and destroy whatever the bulb broke on (like clothes or furniture). Hazmat!
- anamax 17y ago25k hours is about three years of 24/7. You might be able to ignore the time value of money for that period, but you can't for 9 years, which is 25k hours of 8/7. I doubt that there's a large fraction of lights that are on 24/7. I suspect that the big users are around 8/7 and between 6/5 and 10/5.