3 ms·
> cells and all living things are self-organized reaction-diffusion systems Sounds intriguing. Can you explain more what you mean?
by mrfusion 12y ago
> cells and all living things are self-organized reaction-diffusion systems
Sounds intriguing. Can you explain more what you mean?
- craigyk 12y agoI'm going to guess he means they work via chemistry and exploiting heat in the system ie brownian ratchets.
- Balgair 12y agoSpecifically, Gibbs Free Energy (G = Heat - Temp*(Change in Entropy)). Basically, the energy available is the heat in the system minus some chaotic stuff (and no, you can't make it better, because physics). I have a good physics background and what is most supprising to me is how alive cells are. I initially came into the bio field just as the OP talks about, with the idea that cells are just tiny chemistry machines that are very complicated. I figured that eventually, we'd understand the cell from top to bottom give or take a century. Now.... not so much. Cells, especially eukaryotes like us and yeast, are just so alive to me. They do weird things and act on their own. You would think that with enough constraints in the inputs you would be able to very precisely predict what any one cell would do. Nope. They go off and do their own thing, replicate in some strange way, find some food source you never thought they could digest, eat each other, have sex in some novel way. And it's not just that you are not constraining the system enough either, or that the system is inherently chaotic and you see improbable events because of that. They really are alive and want to stay that way. I know this is not a good explanation, and that real science still has a lot to say about it. But with my background I felt the way OP did, that it was all overlapping Gaussian curves and gradients in N-space that makes it look alive. But now, having seen it up close and watched it all, now I am pretty certain that life is different somehow.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sveme 12y agoIt's quite a vast topic. When you look at typical biochemistry text books, everything seems static. Even when something changes (e.g., some changes in the environment), some proteins are switched off, others switched on and the cell returns to a certain seemingly static state. What's missing in this picture are the incredible dynamics in the system. It is a truly complex dynamical system, constantly switching from one fix point to another. The rates of processes and the dynamic location of molecules plays a much more important role in the inner workings of a cell than was previously believed. To be more specific: Self Organization Cells and organisms have incredibly detailed structures or spatial and temporal patterns on time and space scales far beyond typical biochemical reaction rates and the sizes of the molecules. These patterns are not created by someone or something; they emerge from the localized dynamic interplay between many same and different molecules - self organization. In a certain sense the cell and any organism is a dynamical system that self-organizes into intricate patterns, something that is mostly only appreciated by physicists working in biology, rarely by biologists themselves. This has consequences that are often still not appreciated. An example (hope I recall it all correctly, it's been a few years): I was working on so-called Src-family protein kinases (SFKs), proteins that phosphorylate other proteins and thereby change their conformation so that they themselves become activated. SFKs play a huge role in many different signal transduction pathways and therefore in many different diseases. Because of their importancy they are regulated/controlled on many different levels. One of them is that they are self-inhibiting: they bind intramolecularly to a phosphate group and thereby block its own activity. To become activated, they need to be dephosphorylated by some phosphatase and they need to be phosphorylated at another position by another SFK intermolecularly. In the standard biological treatment, it's all pretty simple: phosphatase dephosphorylates, SFK phosphorylates - done. However, as SFKs bind themselves, they block access to the site that the phosphatase wants to dephosphorylate - why could this system then be responsive to any changes, why doesn't it simply stay in this state forever? Dynamics. SFKs most likely (that was more my hypothesis at that time, don't know what the situation is like now) constantly unbind and bind its inhibiting phosphate at a low rate. In its unbound state, the phosphatase can access the phosphate. As the active SFK in turn activates its own phosphatase (a feedback loop), more phosphatases are around, dephosphorylating more SFKs in their unbound conformation, leading to a mostly active population of SFKs. Now when you incorporate spatial aspects into this, you get yet another picture: as SFKs activate themselves constantly (via autophosphorylation), a simple accumulation of many SFKs in a certain part of the cell (e.g., the cell membrane) could be enough to move the whole system above an activation threshold, leading to a complete cell-wide SFK activation. This would not require any of the standard causes used to explain activations in biology. Hope I managed to get at least a little bit across of what I mean. In a nutshell: for me, the Nobel Prize was awarded today to a novel experimental method that nicely shows that cells are no bag full of chemicals and should not be investigated and explained as such; the role of spatial and temporal patterns is much underappreciated still. Or something like that.