3 ms·
> Some things are better than others. A strong debate between strong positions is healthier than an artificial social force reverting everyone back to mean. I
by pron 12y ago
> Some things are better than others. A strong debate between strong positions is healthier than an artificial social force reverting everyone back to mean.
I agree in principle, but the fact that there are good arguments on either side of the debate, and neither of them has been able to conclusively prove that one approach is decidedly better than the other, turns the debate into an argument over preference rather than absolutes, which is a very different kind of debate.
But I would even say something stronger: when it comes to programming languages, much (if not most or even practically all) of the arguments must eventually come down to psychology. If a programming language that can produce no bugs and still express useful programs were ever to be created, if that language is hard for people to use (because of human psychology), or even if people don't like using it -- I would say that that language is nearly useless, except for research purposes or maybe some domains where this property is important over all others (say, safety-critical embedded systems). So even if there is a "right answer" like you imply, the debate is in the realm of psychology -- not math or computer science -- and psychology, as we all know, does not usually yield hard answers even when it has answers at all. So while studying the properties of programming languages is computer science, their overall utility is (almost) purely within the realm of the social sciences.
To repeat an example I've made a few times, if your job is to catch a ball you can't argue that teaching you to compute the ball's trajectory with a Newtonian formula is better than practicing a few times simply because the former is more mathematically rigorous. Which is best depends on which approach better fits your psychology.
So here's my strong position: if someone debating programming languages denies that their general utility is mostly a matter of psychology rather than math, then that person is wrong!