3 ms·
It's cars, mostly. Many of California's cities have laws requiring massive, incredibly wasteful amounts of parking to be built even in supposedly high-density
by CalRobert 12y ago
It's cars, mostly.
Many of California's cities have laws requiring massive, incredibly wasteful amounts of parking to be built even in supposedly high-density or transit-oriented communities. In addition, there are rules saying houses have to be set back a certain distance from the road, which takes a good deal of space. Finally, most places also require that roads meet a certain (high) "Level Of Service", meaning lots of cars can move through very quickly. Nevermind the fact that by building things like this you are forcing them to go much, much FARTHER. Have you noticed that driving through LA (or San Jose for that matter) is mostly driving through a sea of parking lots and wide streets? See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Level_of_service http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Level_of_service for more.
There is also a cultural preference for lots of land; I'm bemused by how many people mock "McMansions" for having small yards but never spend any time in their own yards.
This is less true in the bay (and not at all in SF) than other parts of the state (looking at you LA) but it remains a problem. Also, areas where the majority of the population are homeowners tend to vote against new housing construction. This increases the value of their own homes at the cost of strangling newcomers to the area and making the cost of living exorbitant. Of course, without new housing those areas will continue to consist primarily of homeowners, so the cycle continues. Even in supposedly lefty places you see people oppose construction that would help increase housing supply, presumably because it's bad for the environment or will damage neighborhood character. I'm sympathetic to those claims, but making people commute from 40 miles away (if they're LUCKY it'll be on BART or Caltrain, but probably not) can't be good for those things either.
I wonder if it's time we reconsidered whether it makes sense for highly interdependent neighboring communities to be separate cities. Would we have a more integrated and efficient transportation, housing, and office infrastructure if the bay from San Mateo up to Mill Valley and east to 680 were the same city? Quite possibly. It would at least mean, to some small extent, that they couldn't say "we'll take your companies but housing the plebs is somebody else's problem - only huge single-family homes for us, thank you!".
- Shivetya 12y agothere is also a lot of, we like our town and we don't want others here. Hence throw up building codes, regulations, and such, to keep housing from being built. You can use all sorts of PC buzzwords to make it palatable, from environment to maintaining historic sites. When large scale housing is built it usually is where people don't want to be.
- muzz 12y agoThrowing up obstacles to building housing is often called NIMBY-ism or "PC", but it is also what owners of homes would be expected to do it they were maximizing their own economic self-interest
- tn13 12y agoI was not aware that other home owners get a say into what is being built in the city. That should explain anything. It is very much like our Indian community where people on H1B often demand immigration reforms but once they have it they demand stricter immigration laws. :P
- CalRobert 12y agoIt explains some of the enclaves of low density you see even in large cities. Santa Monica and Beverly Hills come to mind as good examples of this; those areas would normally expect to draw more building but the local residents fight tooth and nail against it. Even small developments spend years and years being fought over. Source: I lived in SM and attended city council meetings that discussed the matter because I wanted to see more transit-oriented development and improved bike infrastructure. Can't say I'm sad I left; socal is dysfunctional with regards to transportation. I do miss the beer, though.
- CalRobert 12y agoI should have clarified that SM and BH are independent cities within Los Angeles. LA itself has some of the stranger borders of any city I know.