2 ms·
If you're measuring success by GNP, then it is trivial that the government taxing then spending on something is only worthwhile if the government is making more
by btilly 17y ago
If you're measuring success by GNP, then it is trivial that the government taxing then spending on something is only worthwhile if the government is making more effective decisions on that something than the taxed people would have through the free market.
You're right that that reasoning ignores social benefits other than GNP. However my experience suggests that it is easier to claim social benefits than measure them. And when you can't reliably measure a benefit, delivery tends to be very inefficient.
That isn't to say that government can't meet that bar. Economic theory says that private enterprise deals poorly with externalities. It is hard for a private enterprise to recoup the value provided by national defense, police, clean water supplies, public health inspectors, etc. For that reason it is economically efficient for us to be taxed so that the government will supply us those services.
However startups are a case where a person who is good at picking then nurturing entrepreneurs recoups the value from doing it well. Therefore there is every reason to believe that free enterprise does that job well, and so no reason to believe that the government is likely to do it better.
In that situation underinvestment is a signal that the market doesn't believe that the returns are there. Artificially improving those returns therefore should stimulate investment. And I believe would do it more efficiently than attempting to directly pick winners and losers.