4 ms·
If by a limp recovery after an ibank-created crisis, then yeah. Participation rate down, massive increases in SSD, massive growth in income disparity, no change
by Zigurd 12y ago
If by a limp recovery after an ibank-created crisis, then yeah. Participation rate down, massive increases in SSD, massive growth in income disparity, no change to these trends in sight. It's denial in the form of statistics.
> "You really think anybody has a clue as to how we'd design an economy that would lead to a specific economic outcome?"
Yes. Start with these design changes: raising the minimum wage and cutting the work-week.
- drcode 12y ago> raising the minimum wage... So you're saying making it more expensive to employ people is going to decrease unemployment?
- fuejhdjc 12y agoSo you're saying allowing wages to drop will make people better able to pay their bills?
- innguest 12y ago"We shouldn't drop wages because people won't be able to pay their bills". Appeal to consequences. Try another.
- fuejhdjc 12y agoAs if the parent comment wasn't as well. I was just pointing out that it's a two-way street. Suppose we continue with the status quo and jobs begin miraculously materializing: there's a very good chance that they will be lower paying than what we have now, and it will still be difficult to make a living. To some extent it's a lose-lose situation unless we can come up with a third option like a universal basic income. Edit: My, aren't we feeling pedantic today? I have a great idea: let's argue semantics rather than content!
- innguest 12y ago> As if the parent comment wasn't as well. Tu quoque fallacy. Try again. > I was just pointing out that it's a two-way street. No. Watch closely. You said if we drop wages then people can't pay their bills, and therefore we should not drop wages. Your claim is that we should not do something based on the consequences of that action. The parent said that increasing minimum wage is equivalent to making it more expensive to employ someone. The parent is not claiming anything, but genuinely asking: - assuming increasing minimum wages is another way to say that we would make employment more expensive - then how is it that making employment more expensive helps decrease unemployment? Which is a genuine question that you have not answered. > Suppose we continue with the status quo False dilemma. What is being argued is neither continuing the status quo nor increasing wages, but a third alternative, namely (I presume) abolishing minimum wage laws.
- innguest 12y ago> Edit: My, aren't we feeling pedantic today? Insulting is how the intellectually dishonest say "I'm out of arguments". > I have a great idea: let's argue semantics rather than content! How about you just answer the question: How is it that making employing someone more expensive (which is what increasing the minimum wage effectively does) help decrease unemployment? Why can you not answer such a straightforward question? Why do you avoid answering it by insulting me?
- mrow84 12y ago"We shouldn't increase the minimum wage because employment will go down". Appeal to consequences. Try another. Did I get the right level of condescension?
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoGiven that he's arguing a should statement rather than an is statement, "appeal to consequences", in this context, is actually consequentialism, and is the best framework we have for rationally justifying imperative statements.
- innguest 12y agoI disagree. I think things are wrong on principle, and not just because of the results. See deontology for a better alternative to consequentialism: http://lesswrong.com/lw/1og/deontology_for_consequentialists/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/1og/deontology_for_consequentialists...
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoWell, I gave reading that the old college try, but nothing in there actually justifies deontology, let alone your peculiar form of capitalist deontology, as Correct, let alone as a superior alternative to consequentialism.
- hikarudo 12y agoIn average, yes, because as a result more people will have jobs. Especially those who have a harder time paying their bills.
- Zigurd 12y agoThere are two separate problems we face: income inequality, and rapid destruction of jobs. Raising the minimum wage helps both, by raising the lowest incomes out of poverty and increasing discretionary spending on a mass scale. Another reason to raise the minumum wage is that we are in a permanent large surplus of labor. Without a higher minimum wage, all wages will get bid-down, especially at the low end. Perhaps you are fine living armed-up and behind barbed wire, but a functioning society has a lot of value. We are going to have to decouple remuneration and the value of an individual's contribution to society from a free market for labor.
- AnimalMuppet 12y agoI'm sure that you think that would work. In reality, though, people who are sure that their solution will fix the economy very often run into the law of unintended consequences. I buy drcode's skepticism more than I buy your certainty and optimism.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoHow much evidence have you actually looked at? A priori pessimism is no more innately correct than a priori optimism: both are ungrounded until you look at the data.
- AnimalMuppet 12y agoWell, I've looked at the fate of enough "this is sure to work" ideas for fixing the economy to claim that my pessimism is, on average, warranted. I haven't done an in-depth analysis of this specific proposal, however, so in that sense I haven't "looked at the evidence".
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoReally? And who, exactly, said that they were sure to work, and how, exactly, were the ideas implemented (that is, how loyal were the implementations to the proposals)?