4 ms·
It isn't the truth. The truth is there are very few places new jobs are coming from and many places they are being destroyed. Can you articulate a markets-as-na
by Zigurd 12y ago
It isn't the truth. The truth is there are very few places new jobs are coming from and many places they are being destroyed. Can you articulate a markets-as-natural-force argument that actually works? If not, it's time to question the viability of Libertarianism.
Libertarianism is wishful thinking. Or it's a fake and cynical beard for corporatism and oligarchy. If you want an economic outcome you have to design an economy that delivers that outcome. If you fail to do that you leave the field open for oligarchs.
- drcode 12y ago> The truth is there are very few places new jobs are coming from and many places they are being destroyed. Well, given that almost all measures show that the unemployment rate has gone down in the last 5 years, it means exactly the opposite of what you say: More new jobs are appearing than are being destroyed. (other time frames lead to other conclusions of course) > If you want an economic outcome you have to design an economy that delivers that outcome. That is pretty much a textbook example of the "wishful thinking" you accuse me of. You really think anybody has a clue as to how we'd design an economy that would lead to a specific economic outcome?
- nhaehnle 12y ago5 years is not a good time horizon for unemployment rate comparison, because that time window is during the Great Recession/Lesser Depression, which surely dominates any longer term (and therefore slower) effects of technology. > You really think anybody has a clue as to how we'd design an economy that would lead to a specific economic outcome? Not at a detailed level, but stuff like tax cuts for the rich and financial deregulation are not random accidents.
- Zigurd 12y agoIf by a limp recovery after an ibank-created crisis, then yeah. Participation rate down, massive increases in SSD, massive growth in income disparity, no change to these trends in sight. It's denial in the form of statistics. > "You really think anybody has a clue as to how we'd design an economy that would lead to a specific economic outcome?" Yes. Start with these design changes: raising the minimum wage and cutting the work-week.
- drcode 12y ago> raising the minimum wage... So you're saying making it more expensive to employ people is going to decrease unemployment?
- fuejhdjc 12y agoSo you're saying allowing wages to drop will make people better able to pay their bills?
- innguest 12y ago"We shouldn't drop wages because people won't be able to pay their bills". Appeal to consequences. Try another.
- fuejhdjc 12y agoAs if the parent comment wasn't as well. I was just pointing out that it's a two-way street. Suppose we continue with the status quo and jobs begin miraculously materializing: there's a very good chance that they will be lower paying than what we have now, and it will still be difficult to make a living. To some extent it's a lose-lose situation unless we can come up with a third option like a universal basic income. Edit: My, aren't we feeling pedantic today? I have a great idea: let's argue semantics rather than content!
- innguest 12y ago> As if the parent comment wasn't as well. Tu quoque fallacy. Try again. > I was just pointing out that it's a two-way street. No. Watch closely. You said if we drop wages then people can't pay their bills, and therefore we should not drop wages. Your claim is that we should not do something based on the consequences of that action. The parent said that increasing minimum wage is equivalent to making it more expensive to employ someone. The parent is not claiming anything, but genuinely asking: - assuming increasing minimum wages is another way to say that we would make employment more expensive - then how is it that making employment more expensive helps decrease unemployment? Which is a genuine question that you have not answered. > Suppose we continue with the status quo False dilemma. What is being argued is neither continuing the status quo nor increasing wages, but a third alternative, namely (I presume) abolishing minimum wage laws.