4 ms·
Milgram, Zimbardo, Freud, Mythical Man-Month, Peopleware, The Capilano Suspension Bridge, Elevator.... All crap. Amazing at the time, changed the way we think
by aaron695 12y ago
Milgram, Zimbardo, Freud, Mythical Man-Month, Peopleware, The Capilano Suspension Bridge, Elevator....
All crap.
Amazing at the time, changed the way we think, and contributed amazing stuff.
But all are 'just so' (Hipsters: Gladwellian) stories.
They break from convention and make us think but critically flawed.
Without them we may never have passed to the next level, but they are wrong.
- the_af 12y ago> Mythical Man-Month Critically flawed and wrong? Doesn't the main insight of this book -- that adding manpower to a late project only makes it later -- ring as true as ever? Fred Brooks isn't a phoney like Gladwell, either.
- endersshadow 12y agoI don't know enough about the others to make too much of a sweeping statement on them, but the heart of Mythical Man-Month is absolutely true and valid. It just has a bad title, so people assume it means something it doesn't. The heart of the story is this: Adding developers to a delayed project will only delay it further. It's not about parallel vs serial. It's about project management and how to handle delayed projects. I have yet to meet a PM in my career who really understands this, and almost all of them have referenced the saying, "Nine women can't have a baby in a month." To claim that it's "crap," "critically flawed," and "wrong" strikes me as naive, overly general, and dismissive because you can throw it into a "Gladwellian" bucket and be done with it. Fred Brooks learned his lessons from years of project management. This wasn't a guy who conjured up an idea for a book or a TED talk and just slapped some crap together.
- john_b 12y agoIf you're going to make sweeping generalizations about a whole class of ideas and people, please provide something to back up your assertions. As is, your comment only offers an opinion.
- chippy 12y ago>we may never have passed to the next level So you think that in half a century the human race has evolved, has gotten better? That these experiments were right for a certain brain, which no longer applies to modern brains?
- kyro 12y agoSave this sort of terse, over-opinionated, pseudo-insightful shit for Twitter, because that's one hell of a Tweetstorm you've got there.