6 ms·
Barack Obama Loves Startups: New Federal Office for Early-Stage Entrepreneurs
- jdminhbg 17y agoRetitled: Barack Obama Loves Federal Offices
- mrshoe 17y agoOr: Barack Obama Loves Green Tech/Alternative Energy Startups I don't think he cares about your social-video-sharing-for-cat-owners startup.
- ckinnan 17y agoDo we really think that the Commerce Department can run a venture slush fund without political influence and outright corruption? This is not the responsibility of the U.S. government, it is another avenue for the political class to expand their control of the economy.
- heuristix 17y agoI don't think the announcement of a new govt. office is something to be proud of in and of itself. But as a counterpoint to your argument, the SBIR program, also run by the govt. seems to be working really well for startups I personally know without political influence or corruption. I wouldn't say it's the most efficient funding source but it is definitely a net positive.
- ckinnan 17y agoIt is not a net positive because they tax successful parts of the economy and, through a political process, redistribute that money to favored businesses and connected insiders. Anyway, the U.S. government already operates SBA ($28 billion) and SBIR ($2 billion) among other programs... And those startups blessed by govt subsidy get an advantage over all other startups...these programs should properly be viewed as hostile to the HN community, because they disadvantage the majority of startups with higher taxes and an unlevel playing field.
- ryanwaggoner 17y agoAnd those startups blessed by govt subsidy get an advantage over all other startups Not that I disagree with your overall premise, but this is true of any kind of investment, and getting an advantage over your competitors is kind of the whole point of business. Also, I don't understand why the HN community should view this as hostile; what's to stop them from applying? Couldn't one argue that all external investment disadvantages the majority of startups since they don't get any of that investment, which results in an unlevel playing field?
- jibiki 17y agoThe standard counterargument runs like this: "Great, now founders have to waste time pitching to VCs and applying for government aid. Even less time available for working on the product." Of course, this doesn't quite address your point :)
- jazzdev 17y ago>Also, I don't understand why the HN community should view this as hostile Building a company based on merit is admirable. Building a company by getting the government to use its (not insignificant) power is not admirable (by the HN community).
- gnaritas 17y agoSays who, do you speak for the whole community?
- anamax 17y ago> Also, I don't understand why the HN community should view this as hostile We view it as hostile because they're taking our money to do it. You want my money for your biz? Ask me. Don't take it from thugs who took it from me at the point of a gun. Yes, I've heard all of the "but taxes go for good things". Maybe some do, but ... Here's my test. If I'm not willing to fund something by pointing a gun at my mother and saying "give me money", it shouldn't be paid for with tax money. Why? Because taxes come from pointing a gun at folks, including my mother. Is your biz so worthy that I should point a gun at my mother?
- jhancock 17y agoEvery adult U.S. citizen is a part of the "political class". The greater the involvement, the more you reduce corruption and even out influence. There is no other way for a Democracy to work properly. This is not limited to the paltry amounts being thrown at entrepreneur programs, but to the larger amounts in things like Social Security, Defense spending, etc... Although I'm not a fan of excess Defense spending, you would be well advised to remember that the Internet would not exist without it.
- tlb 17y agoSo, you're saying it's good for the gov't to give a lot of handouts, but to ensure fairness all citizens will have to get involved, follow politics, lobby their congressperson, to ensure the pork is divided fairly. How about just making the government hand out less pork. Wouldn't that be more efficient? As pork approaches zero, it's not only fair, but founders won't waste all their time writing grant proposals and we all won't have to waste our time getting involved in politics.
- jhancock 17y agoI agree with the first part of your response although its not really a goal of this form of stimulus to hand out "fairly". The goal is to provide for macro-economic stimulus. The second part of your reply depends on many factors. Not every form of stimulus ends up being a "handout" or "pork". Most stimulus can be debated ad nauseam as to if it had the intended effects and most likely if you can measure the effects, you have to do so in longer stretches than 2/4/6 year election cycles. I completely disagree that people should not "waste" their time in politics. Government is an investment. Its foolish to not oversea and provide/demand input to what you have invested in. This is a core problem with the U.S.: people think they can just pay taxes (preferably low) maybe even be so bothered as to vote once every few years, and government and the economy will run smoothly. To put it as bluntly as possible: "Democracy belongs to those that show up". If you do not get involved you will most likely find yourself eternally dissatisfied with the results.
- defen 17y ago> The greater the involvement, the more you reduce corruption and even out influence. I think you have a naive view of how the United States is run. The majority of the people in this country simply do not have the time/money/inclination to participate meaningfully in the political process beyond (possibly) going to the ballot box. Furthermore, most policy decisions are actually made by unelected career bureaucrats. What ends up happening is that vocal minorities who DO feel strongly about a particular topic end up having disproportionate influence. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture for an example, although the phenomenon is more general than that. From the article: "...regulatory capture occurs because groups or individuals with a high-stakes interest in the outcome of policy or regulatory decisions can be expected to focus their resources and energies in attempting to gain the policy outcomes they prefer, while members of the public, each with only a tiny individual stake in the outcome, will ignore it altogether. When this imbalance of focused resources devoted to a particular policy outcome is successful at 'capturing' influence with the staff or commission members of a regulatory agency so that the preferred policy outcomes of the special interest are implemented, then regulatory capture has occurred." That's democracy in a nutshell - except it applies to governments, not just regulatory agencies.
- known 17y agoOn the positive note, I believe this is the way to enforce http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/affirmative-action/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/affirmative-action/ for the denied and deprived sections of society in America.
- cma 17y agoARPA?
- padmanabhan01 17y agoThis is basically taxing the citizens to pay for the expenses of a private company. High time someone defines how and how not a Government can use/abuse tax payer's money.
- dschobel 17y agoif only there were some document which explicitly lays out the responsibilities of the federal government. darn those short-sighted founding fathers!
- jhancock 17y agoHere's a link to 5 people you may want to tell this to: http://www.federalreserve.gov/aboutthefed/default.htm http://www.federalreserve.gov/aboutthefed/default.htm Its my understanding they are buying out "assets" from private institutions in the trillions $$ these days.
- fatdog789 17y agoOMIGOD! I just read the US Constitution, and guess what!!! It allows for this sort of stuff! Let's blame the founding fathers!!!
- JCThoughtscream 17y agoSo, wait, the federal government will actually actively help and support startups. ... No, drawing a blank. Can't find anything wrong with this at all. This is actually how federal money should be spent, after all - investing in capital. Even if you view this through a lens of cynicism, the fact still stands that companies'll probably survive and thrive a lot more with governmental help than without. Which benefits everybody - more people make more money, which means they pay more taxes, which means the government can fund more startups, etc. I like it. I hope it works out as intended. This is definitely one of the few inarguable ways to get an economy moving along.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- pelle 17y agoEurope in particular but also states, cities and regions in the US are filled with these types of programs designed to promote startups. When I was younger I've been in them both in Denmark and in England. I'll go out on a limb and say that they have not helped one successful startup, who wouldn't have made it on their own. The real benefit of these programs is that politicians get to say they are being proactive about helping startups. All we really need is less red tape and general meddling in what we do.
- ryanwaggoner 17y agoI'll go out on a limb and say that they have not helped one successful startup, who wouldn't have made it on their own. Out a limb is right...come on, this kind of statement has no place in an intelligent debate. It's not even anecdotal, just baseless speculation.
- pelle 17y agoI would say that I have plenty anecdotal evidence, but I prefer baseless speculation. Anecdotal evidence is that a small (probably less than 10) prolific European investors like the Skype founders, Fon's Martin Varzavski et al have done a fantastic job promoting entrepreneurship Europe wide. My baseless speculation is that they have probably done considerably more in the past 10 years than the last 20 years worth of EU and state sponsored 'enterprise programs' and my guess is for a fraction of the money spent on setting up all the 1000s of enterprise agencies, regional enterprise centers etc sprinkled throughout Europe. US state and local governments are also filled with these local business development agencies and startup one stop shops. I just haven't spent any time looking at them, so yes I can only speculate that all of them together have had less positive effect on the world than one Paul Graham. Of course since Obama unlike all the governments of Europe always surrounds himself with the smartest people in the world, this is sure to be different. This time government will finally come through for us and help us out.
- arithmetic 17y agoLet this new office get serious about founder's visa and immigration issues, and then we'll see if there's any truth to all the startup love.
- tptacek 17y agoWhy is that? There appears to be nothing resembling unanimous support for "founders visa" among entrepreneurs.
- arithmetic 17y agoI'm a little suprised by your reply - I haven't seen an entrepreneur say "We don't really want a founders visa" either. We've seen several threads on news.ycombinator on the need for a "founder's visa" and immigration reform. The current H1 visa system is cearly busted. If there is going to be a new office set up for early-stage entrepreneurs, this is certainly one of the important tasks at hand for the federal office.
- tptacek 17y agoThe top-ranked comment on the most recent HN thread on Founders Visas argues against them: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=815457 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=815457 Eyeballing the whole thread, it looks like support ran 50/50. Note that, for instance, arguing for a "more Canadian-style immigration policy" is not the same thing as supporting the Founders Visa proposal. We are allowed to believe simultaneously that H1-B is busted and the Founders Visa is a bad idea. Wait, no, here's a more recent thread about Founders Visas. It's got 89 votes. The top comment opposes founders visas: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=832363 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=832363 It refers to the HN thread on Graham's original post about Founders Visas. 196 votes on that post. Again, the top comment opposes the Visa: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=556908 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=556908
- gojomo 17y agoI see many of these comments as criticisms of superficial implementation details, that don't necessarily indicate opposition to all variants of the Founders Visa idea. Comment votes, top-comments or even prevalence of critical comments are not reliable indicators of net agreement/disagreement. Threads have lots of factors that cause criticism and disagreement to be over-represented, or cause quibbles to be misinterpreted as opposition. I myself would criticize the 'investors panel' mechanism because I support the overall gist of any policy to increase founder immigration. Sure, I understand bokonist's critique and I'd prefer saner non-political mechanisms for boosting beneficial immigration. But given that immigration policy will continue to be a bureaucratic mess -- there's no 'grand fix' proposal on the table as an alternative -- even a flawed program could be worthwhile. All the existing 'doors' through which immigrants enter are politically-flawed; why not have one more door, also admittedly flawed, through which a few more valuable immigrants might enter?
- btilly 17y agoIn http://www.paulgraham.com/5founders.html http://www.paulgraham.com/5founders.html Paul Graham brings up the testimony at http://app.cypress.com/portal/server.pt?CommunityID=201&DirectoryID=204370&PageID=344&control=SetCommunity&space=CommunityPage http://app.cypress.com/portal/server.pt?CommunityID=201&... for why another attempt by the Federal government to direct money towards high tech innovation was counterproductive. That testimony is as relevant today as it was in the early 90s. I do not fully agree with that testimony, but I completely agree with the point that if taxing the private sector to raise money to fund startups only works if the public sector is better at predicting success than the private sector. And I think the public sector is worse at that. How should this affect government policy? Let's take green energy for my example. First I accept the proposition that basic research benefits from government funding. Why? Because commercialization timelines from are long, research benefits from sharing knowledge, and free sharing of knowledge causes economic benefits to accrue to different people than the ones who did the research. Therefore capitalistic incentives don't work so well. So I'm behind NSF grants into basic science. Second I accept that carbon fuels have significant externalities and cause global warming. By all means have some kind of carbon tax, or a cap and trade system to make oil more expensive to use. Economic theory is solidly behind this method of making private companies properly account for externalities. And that is where the government should stop. If the price of gas is high enough, consumers will demand that companies meet strict fuel standards. Additional fuel standards regulations are an admission that the incentives are wrong. If the economic returns are guaranteed to be there, then the free market will throw up solutions. Direct investment in green technologies is an admission that the economic incentives are not there for alternative energy, and breeds companies that are dependent on that direct investment.
- jbarciauskas 17y ago"I completely agree with the point that if taxing the private sector to raise money to fund startups only works if the public sector is better at predicting success than the private sector. And I think the public sector is worse at that." I can think of a number of flaws in this logic - for one, the public sector may not be as good at predicting winners and losers, but public investment can still be valuable if the overall level of investment is too low. The comparison is not strictly with the same amount of money being invested by the private sector - it is also the same amount of money being used in non-startup investment ways in either the public or private sector. Additionally, while the private sector will exclusively target companies with the greatest potential return on investment in cash terms, opportunities will be lost where the social benefit of the startup does not translate directly in to revenue, cash and profit. That's assuming that the private sector is in fact better at picking winners, and as I allude to in my last point, that their definition of a "winner" is the most beneficial, neither of which are proven.
- jonallanharper 17y agoSeeds of fascism, my friends. Let me guess... after I receive funding from GovCo venture fund, they get to strong arm my company with infinite stipulations and rules about diversity, salary caps, mandatory participation in government sponsored community service, or whatever the vote-buying scheme du jour is.
- parse_tree 17y agoWhy'd this get down voted? What he describes in paragraph 2 is not far from what happens with a lot of the current government ventures into the economy. E.g., private company's wishing to get in on government contracts need to publish their "diversity policies" to ensure they are diverse enough (I guess): http://www.personneltoday.com/articles/2008/06/19/46401/private-firms-bidding-for-government-contracts-must-publish-diversity-info.html http://www.personneltoday.com/articles/2008/06/19/46401/priv...
- kingkawn 17y agobecause he started with inane shit; "seeds of facism"
- dejb 17y agoThere are countless first world countries that have programs like this and you'd have to be batshit insane to start calling them facist nations. Maybe the people doing the voting down are from some of those countries. In Australia we have a programs like this.
- ColemanF 17y agoA bureaucracy meant to increase entrepreneurship...maybe he should make an Office of Government Non-Intervention, too.
- lehockib 17y agoJust out of curiosity will this program fund the artists in America? I ask because as a ceramic artist I work out of my studio in my barn. I give an "Art for Kids Program" that was created to be affordable to children in the Myakka City, Florida area. And, even still at the price of $10.00 per 3 hour class, they still cannot afford the program.I started the program because Myakka City is approximately 30 miles away from the nearest business establishment a child can go to for entertainment. The program is meant to get children off the couch, away from video games, and up from the computer doing something creative. I have been lucky enough to get a few businesses to donate clay, glazes and tools for the kids to work with, but the problem still remains that they can not afford the $10.00 to attend with today's economy. There are programs out there for artist, but an artist has to be nominated for the award, or the awards are so small that it barely pays for studio equipment. It is a worthy program of sponsorship, but then the problems remains as to, how do I afford to pay employees, and provide insurance for them, if the grants available to artist are so small. Read more about the "Art for Kids Program" at http://www.ladyhawkofheartland.spaces.live.com http://www.ladyhawkofheartland.spaces.live.com. Or am I off my rocker, for wanting help with a program that would open the minds of young children, and cause them to challenge themselves to do better and achieve more. I am thinking that the program shows Entrepreneurship, or am I incorrect in my thinking. Blondell Lehocki.