3 ms·
What a great experiment! Any form of government that tortures people because of their political disagreements is worth an embargo. Most people that write wistfu
by briandear 12y ago
What a great experiment! Any form of government that tortures people because of their political disagreements is worth an embargo. Most people that write wistfully about Cuba have never lived there. As much as a police state as the U.S. has become, you can still write blog posts against the government without ending up in prison. Try that in Cuba. Remember Che? Brutally murdered opponents in the name of the 'people.' The love-fest some people have with Cuba is astounding. The Cuban Intelligence agency does a great job of propaganda. Blaming the US embargo for the actions of Castro's government brutality is stupid. Are we next going to suggest that North Korea would be a friendly place if it weren't for those pesky South Koreans? The blame America for everything meme is starting to get old. People don't risk their lives trying to escape the Dominican Republic on a raft made from old car tires. Why is that? If the DR is poorer than Cuba, why aren't rafts washing up in the Florida Strait filled with Dominicans? How would Cuba have been doing without the decades of subsidies from the USSR? That experiment in total communism would have fallen flat on its face. The Soviets had a near 100% literacy rate and 'universal' health care, yet you ask anyone over the age of 50 if they would want to live under the Soviets again and it would be an overwhelming 'No.' Let's ask the Polish what they think of Soviet communism.. Any place where the answer to dissenting thought is arrest and imprisonment is a terrible place -- no matter how many doctors there might be. US prisons have universal health care too, but that doesn't mean we would want to live there. When Cuba has free and open elections, then maybe I'll change my tune. But when the people have no voice, then we should not be rationalizing a government just because the kids score well on a math test and it's cheap to get diabetes medicine. I would invite anyone here who thinks Cuba is so great to go live there. Defect to Cuba and let us know (assuming you can) how you're doing in 5 years.
- _delirium 12y ago> ask anyone over the age of 50 if they would want to live under the Soviets again and it would be an overwhelming 'No.' Do you know any such people? I do know a few of them. Not a statistically valid sample, since I don't research such things professionally. But I happen to have a few in my social group, through family and friend connections. And what's most surprising about them is how strongly pro-Soviet they are. The young people are not; they are mostly pro-West. But the older people are much different, much more nostalgic for Soviet times, and anti-West. Especially those who served in the scientific-industrial-military complex, which is many. Congregations of elderly scientists and engineers tend towards a pro-Soviet tone, especially in the form of complaining about how these useless new countries don't do science the way the old USSR did.