4 ms·
> However, organizing world wide sanctioned competitions in who can take the most drugs (the most advanced, the most risky, the largest volume) is bound to lead
by ekianjo 12y ago
> However, organizing world wide sanctioned competitions in who can take the most drugs (the most advanced, the most risky, the largest volume) is bound to lead to horrible results for most of the participants.
It's already happening in most competitions, you just don't know about it. When there's money at stake, ways to improve your performance drastically and very little chance to get caught, you have the right conditions in place.
- maggit 12y agoHmm, let me try to make my point clearer. What's happening now is a competition in taking the most drugs while avoiding getting caught. The possibility of getting caught limits what you can do. Isn't the idea here to remove this limitation, to open up for experimenting with more things? This is certainly a good way to find out how to manipulate human bodies with drugs, but it does seem to be at the (cynical) expense of the guinea pigs.
- ekianjo 12y ago> The possibility of getting caught limits what you can do. What I'm saying is that the possibility of getting caught is very remote to what you can already do nowadays. There's much more effort and investment done at improving the drugs and hiding them than efforts to detect and prevent the abuses. And the subjects are willingly taking drugs anyway, so we are all just being a bunch of hypocrites when we celebrate "clean" sports because everyone involved know that 99% of athletes are taking drugs heavily. It's like pro wrestling: it's all fake, but everyone pretends otherwise.
- davidw 12y agoWhen they started testing out EPO illicitly on cyclists in the early 90ies, a number of young men died of heart attacks in their sleep, because their blood got too thick. Having some rules and regulations doesn't mean no one dopes, but it does curb how much goes on, which likely is beneficial to everyone's health: not even the dopers can take all they would were there no rules.
- ekianjo 12y agoThere can be rules, but let's stop pretending no one takes drugs. It's just ridiculous to believe that any athlete is not doped at this stage, except for certain disciplines where muscular mass or stamina has no advantage whatsoever.
- davidw 12y agoI think that's highly unfair, and defamatory towards those who do compete fairly. Like anything in life, there are some bad apples, some honest people, and some in the middle. The rules help keep the honest people honest and give them a fighting chance.
- ekianjo 12y agoYeah, life is unfair, that's big news. Many athletes who retire and move away from the competition have revealed over the years what's happening behind the scene. Unless you consider everything they say is BS, it's really a small minority who is not taking any drug.
- davidw 12y agoThe ones who have doped obviously want to justify their actions by saying "everyone else is doing it too!" So yeah, to some degree what they are saying is BS, which is kind of what you'd expect from cheaters. At some periods in time in some sports, it's probably less BS, because many of them were doing it. It's a long and complex discussion, without, clearly, much chance of getting accurate data. But there are guys out there competing clean.
- ekianjo 12y ago> The ones who have doped obviously want to justify their actions by saying "everyone else is doing it too!" There's a non negligible chance they are telling the truth, too. What's the point of saying that everyone does it instead of continuing to pretend the said sport is clean? This is rather a behavior indicating they realized something was wrong. And I'm not really convinced that, in cycling, for example, it's realistic to have cyclists run through hundreds of kilometers of mountains day after day and still being as fresh as ever. But hey, believe what you want.
- scott_s 12y agoAthletes who know they will be tested who are on PEDs will often try to down-cycle before being tested. If PEDs are allowed, no such down-cycling would occur. This is maggit's point: even if people are still on PEDs with restrictions, they are more likely to be on even more PEDs with no restrictions. It's like the speed limit. Just about everyone goes 10 - 15 mph over the posted limit as a matter of course. One reason some people don't go faster is the threat of getting caught, and the resulting consequences. (And one reason some others don't go faster is they don't feel safe at faster speeds.) But if we removed the posted speed limits, it's likely people would go even faster. And for the record, I don't think the possibility of getting caught is remote. In professional MMA, fighters are getting caught every month.
- gajomi 12y ago>This is certainly a good way to find out how to manipulate human bodies with drugs, but it does seem to be at the (cynical) expense of the guinea pigs From the athletes perspective the "drugs" aspect is totally incidental. There are plenty of sports where people and up pushing there bodies to extreme and dangerous limits without drugs. The athletes always have to end up finding a balance in risk, and the need to find this balance wouldn't be abandoned with the introduction of a "drugs OK" domain, as far as I can tell.
- scott_s 12y agoThe need to find the balance would remain, but it would change what is being balanced.