3 ms·
S.A.C. performed background checks on prospective employees, but it is not known whether the firm detected this blemish in Martoma’s record. Of course, S.A.C. c
by jessaustin 12y ago
S.A.C. performed background checks on prospective employees, but it is not known whether the firm detected this blemish in Martoma’s record. Of course, S.A.C. could have learned of it and hired him anyway; forging a law-school transcript and mailing it to twenty-three federal judges demonstrates impressive comfort with risk.
It sounds as if they got exactly the kind of employee they wanted. Really, though, how did he think he'd get away with that, in the late nineties? By that point in time it was well-known that transcripts are provided by the registrar's office, not by students. Maybe it would have worked in the seventies...
The insider trading seems much the same. The sheer volume of those trades, coming less than a week before significant announcements of previously-secret information, was bound to throw up red flags. Did they have to short the stocks as well?
If this is the sort of thing that gets caught, there are bound to be billions of dollars of slightly subtler insider trading going unpoliced. The only thing I can think of is that possibly the really egregious insider trading crowds out the less aggressive sort. That's a reach though, and unless there's a good reason to believe it's true, why do we even bother policing this?
- PublicEnemy111 12y agoI had a mutual friend with the trader who gained inside information on the pharmaceutical stock that he then relayed to Martha Stuart. This trader(who I will not name, but can easily be found with a little googling) left his analyst position at SAC when the situation got messy then joined Front Point Partners as a portfolio manager. From what I understand, he was in the 8-figure range. FrontPoint was then itself brought down by an insider trading case relating to the top level mgmt. I dont think the trader even received a subpoena. The sad reality is that there is probably no risk in cheating if you're not a high-profile manager. My assumption is that these guys can produce "research" after receiving a subpoena that muddies the water just enough for their lawyer to bail them out.
- tankenmate 12y agoIt seems to have a similarity to other cases of justifying behaviour based on secret information post hoc; i.e. post hoc "constructive evidence" or "constructive cause" to perform searches or road stops, based circuitively from NSA and/or CIA information which can't/won't be revealed to a court.
- revelation 12y agoThere would have been no profit if it wasn't for the shorts, can't exactly sell $750m worth of shares quickly and without losses.
- jessaustin 12y agoMy reading of TFA was that they liquidated their holdings and sold the stocks short. Of course short-selling can hedge a non-liquid position, but that wasn't what was portrayed. After all, they didn't just not-lose; they "won" big.
- cmdkeen 12y agoUnless the stocks had risen since they bought them. It would also have been a much easier justification to the SEC - "this announcement was coming up, we didn't know which way it would go and were unhappy with the risk".
- rayiner 12y agoIt's a high-trust environment, and I think very few judges would demand an official transcript. What's interesting is the risk-versus reward here. You can get disbarred many years into a successful career if this came to light. Meanwhile, clerking for a judge is mostly resume polishing. It's very educational, but you end up working the same job after your one year appointment, you just get to signal to your lawyer friends you had really good grades in school. To Martoma, that was apparently worth risking his career for an indefinite period into the future.
- pdabbadabba 12y agoThat's exactly right. I can report that I've had five legal jobs since I started law school (including two clerkships) and nobody has ever asked for my official transcript. I'm frankly very surprised that somebody noticed the alteration. That being said, it still takes serious guts to pass off an altered transcript. He surely had no way of knowing that the judges would not eventually require an official transcript. I certainly assumed that I would need one before I could be formally offered the job.
- afro88 12y ago>The insider trading seems much the same. The sheer volume of those trades, coming less than a week before significant announcements of previously-secret information, was bound to throw up red flags. Did they have to short the stocks as well? It really was clever of Cohen to generate this reputation of having a 6th sense for stock movement. It turns obvious insider trading into "gee that Cohen is a genius, I wish my intuition was half as good as his" I bet a lot of his great trades involved some kind of insider knowledge but were put down to him having an uncanny ability to intuit the market. I guess he didn't have such a great intuition for how far he can push a ruse before the authorities caught on.
- ScottBurson 12y ago> why do we even bother policing this? I wonder about this too. It's so rampant that I think we might be better off repealing the insider-trading laws and just telling the public that the game is rigged, and always has been. They would be safer looking out for themselves than thinking that insider trading is being effectively policed.